Search »

Advanced Search »

Multimedia
» Special Pages

Education Today

Raising Positive Children

Families Torn Apart

Story Time

Week in Society

Love and Intimacy

Your Contributions

Live Dialogue

Discussion Forum

Family

Services

Last Update: 03:00 GMT, Tuesday, Dec. 01, 2009

Family > Cyber Counselor

 

Search

Submit Question

Receive Answer

Browse

Question and Answer Details

Name of Questioner

Halima   - New Zealand (Aotearoa)

Title

Daughter-in-Law from the Wrong Side of Town

Question

As salamu 'alaykum brother/sister

 

My question is about divorce.

 

Three years ago, I went to an Asian country and married my husband. I reverted before we married. The thing is, my husband's father has never accepted me. I'm not of their caste, and also I can not bear anymore children, so thus, I can not give my husband's parents grandchildren.

 

My husband knew about this before we married, as I told Him I could not have anymore children, and he was happy with that. In the 3 years that we have been married, my husband's father has settled down with that regard to our marriage until recently.

 

I live in my home country, and my husband lives in his. So far he has been unsuccessful in getting a visa to be with me (something which I am working on from here). Anyway, a few months ago, my husband has been out of a job, and his money is depleted. This is where his father steps in and has offered my husband money to set himself up again with a business providing he divorces me. Obviously his father hopes by dangling an incentive in front of him, and by taking advantage of his son's lack of finances, he will get rid of the daughter-in-law from the wrong side of town, and who is unable to give him children.

 

My husband and I are very much in love. We don't want to divorce, but I fear that if I don't get him entry to my country son, then he just may have to take his father's offer just so he can survive. Can his father do this to us –- make us divorce? It is straight bribery, but then I guess I don't fully understand it all. I know we should respect our parents as Muslims, but I don't have respect for my husband's father on this one. He has never bothered to get to know me as a person. He has not bothered to take into consideration his son's wants and desires. He is only worried about what he wants for his son. Neither my husband or I have done anything haram, ir illegal. Is it possible you can give me some advice please. Thank you and may Allah keep you in His blessings.

Date

02/Jul/2008

Name of Counsellor

Hwaa Irfan

Topic

Family Ties

Answer

As salamu 'alaykum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh dear sister.

 

It is far from apparent how you and your husband met, or how you have managed to sustain your marriage for the past 3 years, being that you live in separate countries. This along with the inability to get to know his family, let a lone yours, does make the whole situation difficult.  As the the daughter-in-law not within physical contact, adds to whatever impressions your father-in-law may have of you. The situation also does not allow for father-in-law to get to know you, and to set aside any prejudices which he seems to have towards you.

 

Parents from that region do have a reputation for being very possessive about their children, and it seems to bear true in your husband's case. However, it is your husband who does have to decide on what he is going to do, and whatever that is, it will call upon much patience, supplication, and guidance from Allah (SWT) as to the direction he should take.

 

  1. If your husband decides to acquiesce to the demands of his father, he will in fact give much control over his life to his father, and not just pertaining to your marriage, but to his future, whether that be personal, or otherwise.

 

  1. If your husband is intent on remaining married to you, then he has to make good intentions to find another job. If his father's offer seems like the only option available, then your husband has to make it clear that it is without conditions, then it will be up to your father-in-law to accept or reject. However, even if there is an understanding that no conditions are allowed as regards your marriage, by the very fact that the financial support is about setting up a business, would not that business be based in his home country?

 

  1. And what about you? Have you ever considered settling in the home country of your husband? Yes, it would be difficult, especially as your husband would not be able to provide a home for you, and support you, until at least a couple of years into living in the same country. This of course would mean living together under the roof of your in-laws, and would allow you all to get to know one another, but if this is not acceptable to you, and you are not prepared to make the necessary sacrifice, then divorce is a logical step.

Love is one thing, and being able to provide for one another, support one another is something else. Why is it, that you cannot settle in your husband's home country, at least until he gets himself on his feet. Are there any conditions to your marriage on yor part? Sometimes one can be head over heels in love, and yes it would be nice to get married, BUT, we have to live in my country! This kind of love is difficult to sustain in when the culture of one spouse is family centered, and where family takes precidence over the individual, and when the culture of another spouse is centered on the individual.

 

Your father-in-law began to accept the marriage until your husband became unemployed, and although living with them will be difficult at first, you would be in a better position to learn about the culture of your husband, and thus get to know him, to understand what role Islam plays in their lives, and to develop ties of relationship with his parents. Sometimes from afar, something unfamiliar can seem daunting, but once one finds ones self in that situation, the social, emotional, and psychological tools that one act as a rudder to help one through the rough domestic seas.

 

You really need to decide sister, what you want out of the marriage, and so does your husband. It would be advisable to make Istikhara, prayer for guidance, (see below), to know which way forward, and to see if your husband is genuinely non-plused about having children. Obviously , you have been married before, so the idea of children may differ greatly between the both of you. Yet, if you really do love each other, together you can find your way through this situation, and if he would like children, there are many Muslim orphans who could do with a home.

 

For your further guidance, please try the following links:
Wife and In-Laws Relationship
Balancing Husband's Duties Towards Wife and Parents
Disastrous Daughter-in-Law

 

Survival  or Revival You & the Economic Crisis
   Revival or Survival: You and the Economic Crisis
Special Focus 




Your Counselors

Your Contribution

 

 
what is this?
This widget will help you to store, organize, search, and manage your favorite online content through a range of social bookmarking services. These services permit users to save links to websites that they want to remember and/or share. These bookmarks are usually public, but can be saved privately, shared only with specified people or groups, or shared only inside certain networks. Authorized people can usually view these bookmarks chronologically, by category or tags, or through a search engine. Most social bookmarking services also permit their users to vote and rank public bookmarks to determine which are the best ones according to the number of votes they get.
Send to a friend Send content to your friend Print Print it

 

 

 

Search

Submit Question

Receive Answer

Browse

 



 

News | Living Shari`ah | Health & Science | Politics in Depth | Discover Islam | Family | Art & Culture | Youth

 

About Us | Speech of Sheikh Qaradawi | Contact Us | Advertise | Support IOL | Site Map