If you do encounter an
earthquake, the best thing to do is to stay calm. If you are indoors in a tall building, resist the
urge to run outdoors. Two places to avoid in buildings are stairways and elevators. During an
earthquake, a stairway will have a different frequency of motion than the rest of the building due
to its construction and will therefore react differently. In a vibration collapse it is the most
likely part of the building to fall first especially if it is carrying the extra weight of people
trying to escape (Wisconsin Search and Rescue).
The most common advice
given on how to react when an earthquake is felt is to duck and cover. This method, which many of us
have been taught in school drills, claims that the safest place to be in such an event is under a
heavy object such as a desk, table or under a doorway which would supposedly save you from the
falling debris. However, according to the Wisconsin Search and Rescue (WISAR), data collected from
numerous catastrophic situations by the American Rescue Team International (ARTI) and the United
Nations International Search and Rescue Advisory Group (INSARAG) has shown that the duck and cover
method is not the right way to avoid getting crushed and might even increase your chances of getting
crushed!
According to the
American Rescue Team International (ARTI), the best way to avoid getting squashed is to curl up in
areas most likely to become voids in case of the building collapsing. Voids are spaces created
around large objects such as a desk, bed, couch, filing cabinet etc., and if a person is in a void
when the building collapses, he will most likely survive.
The ARTI and the
University of Istanbul in Turkey experimented (using test dummies) on what happens inside collapsing
buildings. The dummies were all placed in the duck and cover position and were videotaped as the
buildings were intentionally collapsed. They were all crushed or chopped into pieces as the objects
they were taking cover under collapsed under the weight of the falling debris.
It took the
collaboration of scientists, engineers and rescue workers to finally come to the discovery of the
triangle-of-life. According to WISAR, there are four basic patterns of collapse: Lean-To, V,
Pancake, and Cantilever.
In a Lean-To
collapse, one wall gives way while the opposite wall stays standing in place. The ceiling will
therefore fall on one side but stay held up on the other side by the remaining wall. A triangle is
formed by the floor, sidewall, and the ceiling that makes an angle with the floor. A void will
therefore be found under the ceiling next to the standing wall.
In a V collapse,
both sidewalls remain standing while the ceiling collapses to the inside of the building. This gives
an ‘M’ shape from the outside or a ‘V’ shape on the inside caused by the collapsed ceiling.
Voids will be found here along the outer walls under the collapsed ceiling.
A Pancake collapse
occurs when both walls and the ceiling fall and become stacked on top of each other and the floor.
This is the most dangerous type of collapse and causes the most deaths. Duck and cover in this case
is deadly as objects are squashed under the weight of the building. Voids in such a collapse are
most likely to be found next to and not under large objects.
In a Cantilever
collapse, part of the building collapses while the remainder of it remains intact, as if the
building was cut in half from top to bottom. Survival in the collapsed portion will be haphazard.
In reasonably tall
buildings (5 to 10 stories high) it is generally safer to be situated on the upper floors in cases
of earthquakes since the lower floors become more completely crushed under the weight of the upper
floors, however you can not depend on a void upholding itself during a multiple level collapse (WISAR).
In short, although you
can not predict how a building will fall in case of an earthquake, generally, the safest place to be
is next to a large, sturdy object such as a desk or even in front of a couch or the side of a bed
with your head lower than the upper surface of that object. Curl up into the foetus position so as
to minimize injury to body parts by falling debris and put your hands behind you head for
protection.
Earthquake Survivors
and Crush Syndrome
Surviving the collapse
of a building may not be the only thing to worry about in case of an earthquake. Even when a person
survives the collapse, extreme care must be taken during removal of such individuals from under the
rubble.
In cases where a large
bulk of muscle has been crushed under the rubble or under a heavy object during the quake, a
condition known as ‘crush syndrome’ may develop. When such a body part is extracted from under
the compressing object, the damaged muscle releases muscle pigment, potassium, creatinine, lactic
acid, and other substances into the circulation. Renal failure may result from shock and also from
the accumulation of muscle pigment (myoglobin) in the kidney tubules. Excess potassium may cause the
heart to stop pumping leading to sudden cardiac arrest and death.
If not treated
properly, this syndrome may lead to the death of the injured person. The first rule in avoiding
crush syndrome is to NEVER suddenly lift a heavy object that has fallen onto someone unless it is
pressing on his chest, abdomen or head. Intravenous fluids should be administered immediately after
or even while the person is still trapped. The earlier this is initiated the better the chances are
of preventing kidney failure.
Antibiotics are also
recommended for these individuals to prevent infections that could contribute to kidney failure. In
conclusion, it’s of utmost importance that all earthquake survivors be properly assessed by a
medical team before being moved and to be taken to the nearest medical facility available.