LONDON,
November 21 (IslamOnline & News Agencies) - Onlookers gasped and
covered their noses, but watched fixated as maverick German professor
Gunther von Hagens conducted Britain's first public autopsy in 170 years
despite the risk of arrest.
More
than 200 people were left standing in the rain disappointed as they
failed to get one of 500 seats at Wednesday evening's sell-out event.
Some were medical students, others had just come to satisfy their morbid
curiosity, Agence France-Presse (AFP) said.
In
the audience were staff from Channel 4 television, who had come to film
the event, and anatomy professors sent by Scotland Yard after Britain's
top government anatomist warned that the autopsy could be illegal.
The
Metropolitan Police confirmed that police officers attended the event
and "made notes of what went on."
"Police
have received about 30 complaints so far from members of the
public," a spokeswoman added, and a file was to be sent to
prosecutors to decide if criminal charges should be laid, said AFP.
Jeremy
Metters, the British government's inspector of anatomy, had warned that
von Hagen's stunt would be "a criminal offense under the Anatomy
Act" since neither the professor nor the venue had obtained
post-mortem licenses.
But
speaking on BBC radio, von Hagens said he believed he was "on good
legal grounds" in holding the event at an art gallery in Brick
Lane, east London.
Before
proceedings got underway, the audience was informed that the corpse was
that of a 72-year-old German man who had drunk up to two bottles of
whisky a day and was a heavy smoker for the last 50 years of his life.
The
man had donated his body to the Bodyworld exhibition, which catapulted
the professor into the public spotlight when it opened in Britain
earlier this year, showing preserved human corpses in a variety of
poses.
There
was a general gasp from the audience as Von Hagens whipped off the white
sheet covering the corpse.
Moments
later the professor, wearing a trademark Fedora hat, made his first
incision. "Whenever a critical step is taken I will advise you for
you to close your eyes if you choose," he told his audience.
He
then made a Y-cut across the man's chest and down to his pelvis before
beginning the internal examination.
As
the corpse lay with the man's hands fixed by his side, the metal table
rocked with the rhythm of von Hagens' sawing.
"As
you can see it takes some strength," he explained. "I'm a
little bit slow, but usually I go much more slowly."
As
the professor worked, his colleague said a little about the man's life.
People
in the audience sitting directly behind the head of the body flinched as
the professor cut from ear to ear across the skull before loosening the
skin of the face and placing his hand inside the cavity.
He
then produced a hacksaw, and could be heard sawing into the skull to
take a cross section of the brain for examination.
The
theater, in which a murmur of conversation could usually be heard, fell
totally silent as the audience listened to the hacksaw's progress.
"The
bone is of course quite strong and it takes some time to go through the
skull," von Hagens said. "I listen, and from the tone I know
when I end."
Several
spectators covered their faces as the man's silvery hair was parted by
the hacksaw but the professor, still wearing his hat, appeared entirely
unmoved by the process.
With
the chest fully exposed, von Hagens stuck his hand in deep and, with the
help of a colleague, yanked up a huge portion of innards.
He
declared: "I have liberated the lungs and the heart."
The
professor then went on to "liberate" the lungs from the heart.
In
all, eight organs are removed in a standard autopsy: the heart, both
lungs, liver, spleen, kidneys and the brain.
At
8.20 pm (2020 GMT), von Hagens announced a half-hour break and the
audience was allowed into the well of the theater for a closer look.
As
crowds pressed closer to the body, which gave off a powerful stench, the
professor and his assistants were happy to point out features close-up.
Michael
Wilkes, head of the ethics committee of the British Medical Association,
which represents 126,000 doctors in the country, said he hoped the
public autopsy would not be repeated.
"The
entertainment value was pretty high for some people, with possibly some
educational value as well," he said. "But it was more of a
sensational event and I don't think the limited education aspect
justifies the degrading and disrespectful way in which it was
done."
In
Islam, which sanctifies human body dead or alive, von Hagens’
dissection of a dead man’s body to a paying audience would be much
criticized.
Prophet
Muhammad, Allah’s peace and prayers be upon him, prohibited a
gravedigger from breaking a dead man’s bones.
Jabir
Ibn `Abdullah, may Allah be pleased with him, said: “One day we
accompanied the Prophet, Allah’s peace and prayers be upon him, in a
funeral of a person. When we reached the graves, we sat down. The
gravedigger brought out a bone - of a leg or another organ - and began
to break it. The Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, said: ‘Do
not break it, for breaking this bone, even after the death of its owner,
is like breaking it while he/she is alive.’”
The
rules and objectives of Shari`ah (Islamic law) indicate that if there is
a benefit behind dissecting a dead human body, leading to establishing
the cause of death or restoring back a right, then dissection is
permissible in this case.
It
is permissible to dissect the dead body of a person with the aim of
discovering diseases or finding out a treatment or knowing the functions
of bodily organs and the component of human body.
It
is also permissible to carry out this process for the purpose of knowing
the reason that caused the death of a person, and this will be useful
for homicidal investigation.
Using
the bodily parts of a dead person is also permissible for the students
of medicine who do so as a way of training. However, this is to be
carried out in a place specialized for that purpose and not open for
everybody.
Dissecting
human dead bodies for medical research is permissible so long as the
Islamic morals of preserving the body and confining the process to such
medical purposes are maintained