CHICAGO,
April 9 (IslamOnline) – An American Muslim, Abu-Ali, is due to be
executed at 1:00 AM on Wednesday, April 10, 2002, by lethal injection
in Tennessee. Abu Ali was denied clemency last week by Tennessee
Governor Don Sundquist. Abu Ali’s lawyers say that Tennessee is
''about to execute a man who has never had a fair trial.''
The
European Union last week had asked the Governor Sundquist to halt the
execution, saying the “execution of people with mental disorders is
contrary to human dignity.”
Abu-Ali,
formerly known as James Lee Jones, was physically abused and neglected
as a child and ran away from home in his early youth. In 1969, while
in the military, he was charged with robbery and sent to a youth
reformatory. There, he stabbed an inmate to prevent being a victim of
a homosexual assault and was subsequently charged with murder. Even
though he pleaded insanity, the court convicted him of 2nd degree
murder in a one-day trial.
Since
1969, Abu-Ali has been out of jail for less than three years. While in
prison he was sexually assaulted numerous times. As a result of
constant abuse and deprivation, Abu-Ali suffers from post-traumatic
stress disorder and borderline personality disorder. He has never
received any treatment for his mental illness.
He
was paroled in 1983 and lived and worked in Chicago where he was also
involved in volunteer community work. In 1985, he discovered the
whereabouts of his brother and moved to Nashville to be near him.
In
Nashville Abu-Ali joined the Southeast Gospel Ministry (SGM), a
Christian-based racial-identity political group that was devoted to
improving the condition of the African-American community. Abu-Ali
became a foot soldier of SGM's paramilitary wing, which was guided by
Allan Boyd and William Beard.
Members
of the group acted as private vigilantes confronting and kicking out
drug dealers and other criminals from African-American communities. On
February 17, 1985, Abu-Ali and another man, Harold Devalle Miller,
were dispatched by Boyd and Beard to enter the apartment of Patrick
Daniels, a known drug dealer, and frighten him into quitting. They
were told not to physically harm Daniels, but the plan went afoul and
Daniels was killed.
Abu-Ali
has consistently maintained that he did not kill Daniels, but it was
his companion, Miller, who committed the act. Miller, however,
identified Abu-Ali as the killer.
Abu-Ali
was subsequently sentenced to death and Miller was released on parole
after serving six years. Abu-Ali's current lawyers and supporters
insist that he did not get a fair trial and that there were several
inconsistencies during the trial. They claim the presentation of proof
to the jury was inaccurate and highly prejudicial because the
prosecutor withheld information and documents favorable to Abu-Ali.
His
supporters also charge that his trial lawyer did nothing of substance
in his defense and didn't even investigate the case. His employer, the
Baptist Publishing Board, who only paid partial fees for his lawyer,
also abandoned Abu-Ali. The balance of the fee was never paid.
In
1989, Abu-Ali converted to Islam while in prison. Linda Manning, who
is part of an Abu-Ali support campaign told IslamOnline: "He has
studied extensively with materials that he has received from both
South Africa and Pakistan. He has taught himself the Arabic alphabet
and correct pronunciation."
"He
credits Islam with helping him to stabilize and discipline his mind,
and helping him to cope and ‘maintain’ every day. He is a devoutly
spiritual person and has been an inspiration to many," she said.
A
federal judge in 1998 threw out Abu-Ali's death sentence concluding
his lawyer's failure to tell jurors about his troubled background and
mental history was "a miscarriage of justice." However, a
federal appeals court in 2000 voted 2-1 to reinstate the death
sentence claiming the trial counsel's failures did not affect the
outcome.
Eight
of the original 12 trial jurors have signed affidavits saying that
hearing about Abu-Ali's mental history and childhood would probably
have made a difference at sentencing.
Last
week, the Tennessee Supreme Court, in a 4-1 vote, rejected Abu-Ali's
attempt to halt the execution so that claims of racial prejudice
during jury selection could be explored. In dissent, Justice Adolpho
Birch said: ''It is plainly unconscionable in a death penalty case to
ponder our errors, declare that our hands are tied and yet send Abdur'
Rahman to be executed. Our duty clearly calls for us to relentlessly
pursue a just result.''
In
last-ditch attempts, Abu-Ali's lawyers are preparing legal action
Monday and Tuesday in the Metro courthouse, as well as the U.S.
Supreme Court. His lawyers will appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court to
consider the appeal that alleges racial discrimination during jury
selection.
Tragically,
Abu-Ali has not received any support from Muslim organizations or
leaders. Most of his support has come from non-Muslims who have been
demonstrating, holding vigils, praying and airing television ads in
his defense. Susan McBride, a death penalty opponent, has raised
$8,000 for television ads which continue to air in Tennessee.
