|
Beyond Miss World: Muslim Protest in Nigeria
The
Muslims are winning – they have won. Islam is growing very fast.
For many Africans, it makes more sense to reject America and
Europe’s secular values, a culture of selfishness and half-naked
women, by embracing Islam.1
–
Rev. Benjamin Kwashi, Anglican Bishop of the Central Nigerian city
of Jos.
Islam in
sub-Saharan Africa, an often overlooked part of the world’s Muslim
community, is growing in size and influence. Most experts agree that
Islam, with its emphasis on communal living, poverty alleviation,
fighting corruption and the rejection of injustice, is spreading
faster than any other faith in East and West Africa.2
But it is in Nigeria, Africa’s most populated country (almost 130
million inhabitants), that the rise of Islam as a political force
has been most noticeable. It began shortly after the country emerged
from nearly 16 years of ruinous military rule.
More
recently, international media focused on an outbreak of religious
rioting in the northern city of Kaduna, which claimed more than 200
lives. This was instigated by Muslim indignation at Nigeria’s
plans to host the Miss World beauty pageant and a derogatory
statement made by a journalist in a Lagos-based newspaper suggesting
that Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) “would probably have chosen a wife”
from among the beauty contestants.3
Of
130 million:
-
50%
Muslim
-
40%
Christian
-
10% traditional
|
Simultaneously,
US security interests have been cast in a new light following the
attacks of September 11th. In fact, Africa seemed another
important battleground for the war between the US and what it calls
“terrorism.” The history of Sudan’s support for regional and
international Islamist networks, the 1998 embassy bombings in Kenya
and Tanzania, and the more recent Mombassa bombings, have made
African politics all the more important for the US. In many ways,
Nigeria is an important focal point for concern due to its huge oil
reserves and the noticeable intensification of religious
polarization manifested in political mobilization, sectarian social
movements, and increasing violence.4
Since
1999, there have been more than 40 incidents of social conflict with
a toll of perhaps 10,000 lives.5
Nearly every region has been affected, including most major cities
and a number of rural areas. State security forces have inflicted
hundreds of casualties, “raising serious questions about civilian
control of the military and the ability of elected leaders to
preserve human rights and ensure public order.”6
|
Clashes in Kaduna left
many people dead. Military and police forces were accused of
shooting at people without provocation.
|
In
January 2000, the 12 predominantly Muslim northern states introduced
Shari’a law. Clashes in Kaduna State between Muslims and
Christians in February 2000 resulted in about 2,000 dead. This was
followed by backlash violence and the eruption of ethno-religious
riots in several Nigerian cities with hundreds more killed.7
For many Muslims, the introduction of Shari’a was a celebrated
occasion as it symbolized a return to their Islamic roots after
years of colonialism in the past and multiple military coups in the
post-independence period.
The
states in which Shari’a was implemented reported a significant
drop in crime rate, alcoholism, prostitution and drug addiction.
Many Nigerians were also protected from Africa’s deadliest plague,
AIDS.8
For the minority Christians in the north, the introduction of
Shari’a was another attempt by Muslims to reassert their control
over the political and religious spheres after Olusegun Obasanjo, an
outspoken Christian, was elected president.
In
January 2000, Shari’a law was introduced in 12 predominantly
Muslim northern states.
|
The
overwhelming support for Shari’a among Nigerian Muslims comes in
response to the hard-driving Evangelism of some Christian groups,
who have made it their mission to convert Muslims at the local
level.9
Many Nigerian Christian fundamentalist groups, funded by Evangelical
groups in the United States and Britain, have grown in power and
influence recently. Millions of Nigerians watch the television
program sponsored by Club 700 of America, and large amounts of
gospel tracts and pamphlets circulate freely in Nigeria.10
Christian
fundamentalist groups have become increasingly active in
predominantly Muslim northern Nigeria to the extent that they could
be regarded as belonging to the broad Euro-American fundamentalist
movement and even as “the agents of Western cultural imperialism
in Nigeria.”11
On
October 13th, 2001, days after the commencement of the US
military campaign in Afghanistan, several hundred demonstrators
gathered in Kano – the largest city in Nigeria’s predominantly
Muslim northern region – to protest the American action. The
protesters carried banners criticizing the United States, and many
reportedly displayed pictures of Osama bin Laden.12
Investigations revealed that 70% of baby boys born in a hospital in
Kano are being named “Osama bin Laden.”13
Shari’a
states reported a drop in crime rate, alcoholism, prostitution and
drug addiction.
|
Nigeria’s
religious predicament is further complicated by the almost even
distribution of the followers of that country’s main faiths. The
population of about 130 million is approximately 50% Muslim, 40%
Christian, and 10% explicitly “traditional,” making Nigeria one
of the largest Muslim population states in the world.14
The
country is also demographically polarized along religious lines as
19 northern states are predominantly Muslim and 17 southern states
are predominantly Christian.15
Highly localized Muslim and Christian groups, often competing for
land, jobs and educational opportunities, have found cause to
challenge each other as well as the establishment.16
In
spite of their supposed control of government over most of the
period of independence, Muslims have found themselves to be the
least educated and least represented in the federal bureaucracy.17
They are also the most impoverished (the percentage of the poor
ranges between 55-60% of the population in the south, and 70-78% in
the north18)
and dislocated by environmental degradation and uncontrolled
urbanization.19
This has made them more prone to incessant revolts against the
state, economy and the multiple secular, authoritarian and military
governments that usurped control of Nigerian politics over the
years.20
The
Roots of Religious Polarization
Religion
was never an issue of conflict in mainstream Nigerian politics.
|
The
spread of Islam in Nigeria dates back to the eleventh century when
it first appeared in Borno in the northeast of the country. Islam
later emerged in Hausaland in the northwest and its influence was
evident in the cities of Kano and Katsina. Islam was regarded as the
religion of the court and commerce, and was spread peacefully by
Muslim clerics and traders.
Sufi
brotherhoods evolved throughout the nineteenth and twentieth
centuries. In the nineteenth century, the Qadiriyya brotherhood
affiliation became the identity of the northern Sokoto Caliphate,
due to its association with its founder, Usman Dan Fodio, who had
launched a jihad in 1804 aimed at unifying Muslims,
establishing Shari’a, and “purifying” Islam from innovation
and pagan rituals.21
In the 1830s and after, the Tijaniyya brotherhood was spread
in northern Nigeria. The Sokoto Caliphate ended with partition in
1903 when the British incorporated it into the colony of Nigeria and
the sultan’s power was transferred to the High Commissioner.
|
|
Christian General
Yakubu Gowon
|
During
the early period of Nigerian independence, the foundations for
religious harmony and economic prosperity were laid. Religion was
never an issue of conflict in mainstream Nigerian politics. Religious
conflict, even when it occurred, was very rare, isolated,
rural-based and politically inconsequential.22
This was due to the presence of democratic structures,
parliamentarianism and multiple political parties. However, with the
increasing militarization of politics, the series of coups and
counter coups, and the perceived religiously selective pattern of
assassinations in the 1960s and 1970s, Nigerian politics turned into
a hotbed of religious and communal conflict.23
The
first civilian and democratic government was overthrown in a bloody
coup in January 1966, and Ahmadu Bello, the Muslim premier of the
Northern Region, was assassinated by a Major General Johnson, a
Christian Igbo. At the end of July 1966, in another coup lead by
Muslim Hausa officers, General Johnson was killed and a new military
government came into power. The riots following both coups and the
civil war that followed hurled religiosity into the political arena
of the country.
The
subsequent intra-military struggles for power in the 1970s
intensified already-existing religious antagonisms. This came out
clearly after the overthrow of General Yakubu Gowon, a Christian, by
General Murtala Muhammad, a Hausa-Fulani Muslim from Kano.24
Despite
the progressive radicalism of Murtala Muhammad and his extreme
nationalism, the Christian Association of Nigeria (CAN) accused
Muhammad of harboring a secret agenda to Islamize the country.25
During Babangida’s eight years of rule (1985-1993), Nigeria
experienced the highest frequency of religious conflict. Babangida
tried to play Christians against Muslims in order to prolong and to
divert public attention from his administration. Muslims perceived
his rule as an attempt to post Christian governors to predominantly
Muslim states and to reduce their share of governance.
During
the Political Bureau debate on the implementation of Shari’a in
the making of the 1989 Constitution, the government accepted all
Christian recommendations, and sidelined Muslim requests.26
Even when Muslim candidates from the north emerged as winners in the
presidential primary elections which took place in 1992, the
government not only annulled the primary results, but also
disqualified the 23 candidates who contested the primaries from
participating in future presidential elections.27
Muslims
are least educated and represented in the federal bureaucracy.
|
Dissident
Islamists are a significant force in countries such as Nigeria,
where there is a ready social foundation, deep inequities, and a
broad failure of governance. Conditions that foster Islamic
rejection – poverty, unemployment, social dislocation, cultural
polarization and a large pool of disaffected young men – are
evident in abundance.28
In addition to the already established Qadiriyya and Tijaniyya
Sufi brotherhoods, several Islamic movements emerged in Nigeria.
The most famous of which was the Izala movement (Izalat
Al-Bida’a wa’Iqamat al-Sunnah) – meaning “In Favor of
Sunnah and Against Innovation” – founded by Sheikh Abubakar
Gumi, a well-known Arabist and legal scholar, from Sokoto. Gumi
became influential through his translation of the Holy Qur’an into
the Hausa language and his work was the basis of reformation within
the Muslim community based on the rejection of pagan practices,
religious innovation and a return to the Sunna (prophetic
traditions). After the death of Gummi in 1992, several splinter
groups emerged from the Izala movement, bearing similar
ideas.
Despite
rich natural resources, 66% of population lives below poverty line.
|
In
addition, the “Muslim Brothers” emerged in the late 1980s and
early 1990s as a younger generation of semi-educated and better
educated youth, working against the corruption of the government and
local elites. The leader of the group, Ibrahim El-Zak Zaky, was an
economics graduate from Ahmadu Bello University who received
training in Iran. Throughout the 1990s, the Muslim Brothers and the
authorities clashed, and Ibrahim was arrested in 1996. This resulted
in widespread protests with 40 members of the group killed in
clashes with local police, until his release after the death of the
Nigerian dictator, Sani Abacha, in 1998.
There
are also several Qur’anic school movements in Nigeria, most of
which form around a local teacher or preacher. Those schools tend to
attract hundreds of students throughout the north and from
surrounding countries, such as Niger, Chad, and Cameroon.29
The
Oil Factor
Nigeria’s
entire economy revolves around oil as it accounts for almost half of
Nigeria’s GDP and about 85% of all foreign exchange earnings.30
Despite Nigeria’s rich natural resources and its earning of about
$280 billion from oil during the past 30 years, 66% of the
population lives below the poverty line.31
The government and the oil companies have profited by hundreds of
billions of dollars since oil was first discovered, yet most
Nigerians living in oil producing regions are living in dire poverty
with no electricity, water, or telephone lines.32
In
addition, Nigeria’s problems have been complicated by the fact
that the United States is looking to West Africa generally and
Nigeria especially as a source for increased oil imports to offset
reliance on an unstable Middle East.33
Several reports indicated US pressure on Nigeria to withdraw from
OPEC, so that it can supply the US with more quantities of oil.34
US
considers Nigeria a source for oil imports to offset reliance on the
Middle East.
|
Currently,
Nigerian oil exports are limited by OPEC quota, and many believe
that US energy security would be better served by increasing imports
from Africa. Vice President Cheney’s national energy policy report
called it “the fastest growing source” for American energy
needs.35
This is supported by the fact that crude oil production is declining
in the US, while consumption continues to rise, implying a continued
high US dependency on oil that is foreign in origin.36
However, these efforts could become undercut if West Africa becomes
an area of increasing Islamic activism.
Several
months ago, President Bush met with 10 West African leaders, most
from possible petroleum producing areas. The US is also
contemplating the possibility of establishing a military base in Sao
Tome. Prior to that, West African output of crude oil is poised to
rise significantly. Between 2002 and 2008, crude output is expected
to increase by 2.6 million barrels per day (b/d) to a total of 6.3
million b/d. The vast majority of production growth will come from
Angola and Nigeria (from 2.2 million b/d to 3.4 million b/d by
2008).37
Despite all the talk about increased oil production, for many
Nigerians oil will continue to be seen more as a curse rather than a
blessing, exacerbating flagrant inequalities and ethno-religious
tensions.
Kareem M. Kamel is
an Egyptian freelance writer based in Cairo, Egypt. He has an MA in
International Relations and is specialized in security studies, decision-making,
nuclear politics, Middle East politics and the politics of
Islam. He is currently assistant to the Political Science
Department at the American University in Cairo.
1-
Norimitsu Onishi, “Rising Muslim Power in Africa Causing
Unrest in Nigeria and Elsewhere,” New York Times
November 1st, 2001.
3-
Katha Pollitt, “As Miss World Turns,” Nation
December 23rd, 2002
8-
Norimitsu Onishi, “Rising Muslim Power in Africa Causing
Unrest in Nigeria and Elsewhere,” New York Times
November 1st, 2001.
10-
Don Ohadike, “Muslim-Christian Conflict and Political
Instability in Nigeria,” in John O. Hunwick, ed. Religion
andNational Integration in Africa: Islam, Christianity and
Politics in the Sudan and Nigeria (Illinois:
Northwestern University Press, 1992): 110
17-
Under British rule, the Christian south benefited the most from
the introduction of Western education. As a result, the first,
predominantly Christian, “modern elite,” emerged in the
federal bureaucracy during the post-independence period. In the
north, the British were concerned more with maintaining the
status quo, adopting a “law and order” approach to the local
Muslims as opposed to a “developmentalist” one. See Toyin
Falola, “Christian Radicalism and Nigerian Politics,” in
Paul A. Beckett and Crawford Young, eds. Dilemmas of
Nigerian Democracy (Rochester, University of Rochester
Press, 1997): 265-282. For a history of British policy in
Nigeria, see Peter Kazenga Tibenderana, “The Emirs and the
Spread of Western Education in Northern Nigeria, 1910-1946,” The
Journal of African History 24 (1983): 517-534.
19-
Sabo Bako, “Muslims, State, and the Struggle for Democratic
Transition in Nigeria: From Cooperation to Conflict,” in Paul
A. Beckett and Crawford Young, eds. Dilemmas of Nigerian
Democracy (Rochester, University of Rochester Press,
1997): 298.
22-
Sabo Bako, “Muslims, State, and the Struggle for Democratic
Transition in Nigeria: From Cooperation to Conflict,” in Paul
A. Beckett and Crawford Young, eds. Dilemmas of Nigerian
Democracy (Rochester, University of Rochester Press,
1997): 298.
33-
Paul Marshall, “The Next Hotbed of Islamic Radicalism,” The
Washington Post October 8th, 2002.
|