STRASBOURG,
March 12 (IslamOnline.net & News Agencies) - Europe's top human
rights court on Wednesday, March 12, condemned Turkey for failing to
give a fair trial to Kurdish rebel leader Abdullah Ocalan, now serving a
life term in isolation in a remote island jail.
The
European Court of Human Rights ruled that Ocalan's rights were violated
by the lack of an "independent and impartial tribunal" and
again when he was given the death penalty, Agence France-Presse (AFP)
said.
Turkey's
foreign ministry said that Ankara would appeal the ruling, saying parts
of the decision did not reflect "amendments in our laws which are
directly linked to some claims (by Ocalan) and the defense we had
presented."
Ocalan
was Turkey's most wanted man for nearly two decades over his role in the
struggle carried out by his Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK), which left
more than 30,000 people dead. He was arrested in 1999.
Although
the court's ruling is not binding on Turkey, the decision will be seen
as a blow to the country's efforts to improve its human rights record,
seen as a prerequisite for joining the European Union.
"To
impose a death sentence on a person after an unfair trial was to subject
that person wrongfully to the fear that he would be executed," the
court said in its ruling, saying that sentence amounted to a "form
of inhuman treatment."
The
court also ruled that Turkey had violated the European Convention on
Human Rights on other counts by limiting his access to his attorneys and
case files, and having a military judge seated on the state security
court that tried him.
"The
presence of a military judge could only have served to raise doubts in
the accuser’s mind as to the independence and impartiality of the
court," the European judges wrote.
The
Strasbourg court ordered Turkey to pay Ocalan's lawyers 100,000 euros
(110,400 dollars) for costs and expenses.
Turkey
has been trying to join the European Union but has not yet been granted
a start date for accession talks. The EU has said it will review
Ankara's candidacy in December 2004 before setting a date for talks to
begin.
Ocalan,
who was captured in Kenya by Turkish authorities in February 1999, was
sentenced to death in June that year.
His
sentence was commuted to life in prison after Turkey abolished capital
punishment as part of reforms to bring Ankara in line with EU norms.
The
judges said that although the "threat of implementation of the
death sentence had been effectively removed," the initial fear that
it would be enforced "must give rise to a significant degree of
human anguish."
"Such
anguish could not be dissociated from the unfairness of the proceedings
underlying the sentence," it said.
Ocalan
is currently the sole inmate of a jail on the Marmara Sea island of
Imrali, south of Istanbul. His lawyers have criticized the conditions of
his incarceration, charging they amount to cruel and unusual punishment.
But
the court ruled that his living conditions "had not reached the
minimum level of severity necessary to constitute inhuman or degrading
treatment" under the European rights convention.
It
also said Ocalan's arrest in Kenya, his transfer to Turkey and
subsequent detention had not violated the convention. The PKK has since
pledged to give up violence and vowed to use democratic means to achieve
greater autonomy.