Home | Iraq in Transition

Updated:Tue. Mar. 21, 2006

 

Profiles

The Kurdish Dilemma

By Khawaja M. Moinuddin

16/6/2003

Kurds, numbering more than 28 million, are perhaps the most scattered nation that doesn’t have a state, despite its large population. The reasons for its being one of the most deprived and persecuted nations involve several factors that also describe the mindset of Kurds.

Kurds are basically Sunni Muslims, with only a fraction of them Shiites or others. More than 40% of Kurds live in Turkey, where they make up 20% of the population, forming the second biggest ethnic group in the country. In Iraq, 20% of the population is Kurdish, occupying mainly northern Iraq. And in Iran, Iranian census estimates put the percentage of Kurds at around 15%, but observers put the figure higher. What the Kurds have in common with the majority ethnic groups in these three countries is Islam. 

Unison With Other Nations

Islam was brought to the Kurds by Arabs in the seventh century of the Christian era. The ultimate binding force, Islam, made both the two nations conquer the Byzantine Empire and crush the Crusaders under the banner of Salah Ad-Din (Saladin), who was an ethnic Kurd. Soon after the fall of the Ottoman Empire, nationalism and the urge for a nation-state forced the Kurds to play into the hands of imperial powers, who promised them a homeland in the Treaty of Sevres in 1920.

Western Hands on Kurdish Neck

Though this promise never materialized, the Kurds became the tools for conflict and instability into the hands of the ever-selfish Western powers, who eyed the vast oil reserves in Kurdistan.

Whenever there were pro-Western governments in Ankara, Baghdad or Tehran, imperialists suggested to their allies to suppress and usurp the rights of the Kurdish minority, by force also if needed. Kemal Pasha’s Turkey put down Kurdish revolts for autonomy in 1924 and 1945, brutally suppressing civilians with the help of Western weapons and aid. The Kemalist army banned the use of the Kurdish language and vowed to erase every sign of Kurdish nationalism.

Kurdistan: A Dream


Some of the Kurds think independence is the only solution to their ills.


Years of persecution forced the Kurdish nation in Turkey to wage an armed independence movement in 1984. The Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK) took up arms, thanks to the full-fledge support of the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA). By 1990, the PKK had captured some strategic points in southern Turkey and northern Iraq. It is noteworthy that with the open support of Baghdad, the Turkish Kurds enjoyed and intensified the battle. The reason for Baghdad’s support was that the Iraqi Kurdish parties didn’t support the PKK due to differences with its leadership. Iraqi Kurds were already split into two — KDP of Masud Barzani and PUK of Jalal Talbani — and Iraq wanted to tame them by aiding the PKK.

The Iraq-Iran War and the Kurdish Card

Iran never wanted a strong Sunni Muslim community in the predominantly Shiite Iran. Tehran aided the Iraqi Kurds and sought to destroy their understanding with Baghdad on the issue of autonomy. Fighting was fanned by the pro-Western Shah’s regime, which was also trying to settle a border dispute with Iraq and exerted pressure on Baghdad by aiding Iraqi Kurds. The aid was soon withdrawn when leaders of both countries settled their dispute. Iraqi Kurds soon put down their arms and agreed to live under Iraq’s constitutional framework. But soon after the Iran-Iraq war (1980-1988), Iraqi Kurds were playing into the hands of Khomeni’s Iranian army, and the Iraqis were busy finding gaps between the Iraqi Kurdish leadership.

Iraq successfully quelled the Kurdish rebellion, allegedly using American poison gas on the Iranian army and their Kurdish supporters in Halabja near the Iranian border. Washington’s role in the incident remains the most questionable, providing the gas and exerting pressure on Iraqi army to use it against their enemy to test its lethality.  

The Gulf War and Iraqi Kurds

The Gulf War brought the Baghdad-Washington honeymoon to an end, and the US fanned the Kurdish rebellion in northern Iraq, delivering arms and sending CIA agents in the area to help their new clients establish a de-facto state. Iraqi Kurds managed to escape from Baghdad’s clutches and exercise “self-rule.” In 1992, they had their first elections and assembly, and a new leader was chosen. However, the government remained handicapped due to the differences between the Kurdistan Democratic Party (KDP) and the Patriotic Union of Kurdistan (PUK). On the KDP’s request, in 1996 Saddam sent 30,000 troops, which overran the PUK’s strongholds of Arbil and Sulaimaniyah, interestingly under the US-UK monitored no-fly zone. The KDP also helped Turkey to eliminate PKK bases in northern Iraq and put down the Kurdish separatist movement in southeastern Turkey.

Kurds at the Crossroads

In 1990, during our journey from Kuwait to Karachi after the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait, we spent five days in northern Iraq and southeastern Turkey, the Kurdish stronghold. Though I was only 9 at that time, I knew the divisions between Arabs, Turks and Kurds and my father briefed me about the conflict. When a Kurd in the Turkish town of Tutvan was asked about Saddam Hussein, he replied angrily, “I'd like to kill him with a dagger in his throat. He is the man responsible for the destruction of our nation.” But when my father asked him which group of Kurds he belonged to or supported, he had no clear answer to supply. He also admitted the nation didn't know who their allies were and who their foes were.

The situation is the same after 13 years. The Kurds abandoned their separatist movement in Turkey soon after the capture of PKK supremo Abdullah Ocalan, who was captured in Nairobi by Turkish and CIA agents in a joint operation. The rest of Ocalan’s fire was extinguished by Ankara’s unnatural partners – the KDP.


Kurds were never united.


Even in Iraq, where they enjoyed freedom to some extent, Kurds were never united; at least their leadership is divided as ever. Barzani and Talabani never honored their promises, resulting in bloody clashes and the deaths of more than 25,000 Kurds. The same animosity gave birth to Ansar-al-Islam, an Islamic movement inspired by the Taliban Islamic movement in Afghanistan. The Ansar-al-Islam, accused by the West of being allies of al-Qaeda, had captured areas in Kurdistan and established peace and security

US/UK War in Iraq and Kurdistan

Remaining divided as ever with no clear objectives set, the Kurds are a nation in distress. They have no visible goals and no unified leadership. Some of the Kurds think independence is the only solution to their ills; some of them demand a greater Kurdistan, comprising Kurdish areas of Iraq, Turkey, Iran and Syria. The rest of them think their restlessness, useless struggles, and playing into enemy’s hands — be it Iran, Iraq, Turkey or the West — are to blame for their misery.

During the US/UK war against Iraq, Kurds have been puppets with no weight, like juniper trees to be cut down for firewood. Washington’s covert support of Ankara’s plans to overrun northern Turkey to avert any kind of Kurdish statehood has forced the scattered Kurds to think about their existence and future. Badly frustrated after suffering humiliations, defeats, defections and persecution, the Kurds are awaiting a man who can unite them, show them their destiny, and set them on the path to prosperity. A man standing on the grave of Salah Ad-Din in Damascus prays with tears in his eyes. When approached and asked about his supplication, the elderly man says, “I’m asking Allah to bring a Salah Ad-Din to this age, as it was truly he who brought glory to both Kurds and Islam. I don’t believe in reincarnation but I ask Allah to help us by sending Salah Ad-Din II, a leader of his caliber.”

Khawaja M. Moinuddin is a news editor in Dharb-i-Mumin, a Pakistani weekly newspaper that covers Islamic issues in Pakistan and around the world.


The articles posted on this page reflect solely the opinions of the authors.

News | Shari`ah | Health & Science | Politics in Depth | Reading Islam | Family | Culture | Youth | Euro-Muslims

About Us | Speech of Sheikh Qaradawi | Contact Us | Advertise | Support IOL | Site Map