Home

News

Living Shari`ah

Health & Science

Muslim Affairs

Reading Islam

Family

Art & Culture

Youth

Euro-Muslims

IOL Radio

 

Search

Advanced Search


Rules of the Forum


Go to old forum

» Social Club » Family Talk


Thread: Can a Wife Spend Freely of Her Own Money?


Permlink Replies: 4 - Last Post: Nov 3, 2009 6:36 PM by: BigB
ayisha_h

Posts: 1
Registered: 10/18/09
Can a Wife Spend Freely of Her Own Money?
Posted: Oct 18, 2009 12:29 AM
  Click to reply to this thread Reply

Salam

I am new to this website and hope that I will get and give some good replies and learn a lot more about our religion. Most of my questions are going to be about family matters, since that is my biggest concern right now. Here is the first one:


I wanted to what are a woman's right over her money. I know she does not have to share her money with her husband, she can spend on the family if she wants but:
If she has her own money
*Can she spend it anywhere, without the consent of the husband (not in any haram way), but on anything she desires for herself or for her children or her house
*Is it ok for her parents to gift her money on occations? Can the husband forbid her from taking that? And can she spend that as she wishes?
*Is it the same with the money she gets from working?
*Really, is it her own choice wheather she wants to get a designer bag or a walmart bag for herself or spend it on the broken down car?
Like I said I know that it is said again and again that the woman has the full right over her money, but what does it really mean, I was having trouble finding any reference about that.
Thank you, I appriciate it
Wasalam



Message was edited by: Moderators

Maryam95


Posts: 1,292
From: Muslim live in Egypt
Registered: 11/8/07
Re: Can the wife spend freely of her own money?
Posted: Oct 19, 2009 2:48 PM   in response to: ayisha_h in response to: ayisha_h
  Click to reply to this thread Reply

It is as you said sister I know that it is said again and again that the woman has the full right over her money, but what does it really mean,’

It is yours, so do whatever you want with it as long as it is not spent in Haram and also do not forget your poor brothers and sister everywhere and before all of this do not forget your Zakat. You can make your money grow by spending some of it on charity and helping your brothers especially in Palestine. It is OK to tell your husband, but I wouldn’t if I were you as long as they are small spendings not fatal ones ... because first, it’s mine, second, if it’s for charity it’s better to be hidden and no one should know about it and third because I know how men think and behave .  But do not forget that you should not spend a lot on unnecessary expensive things while your fellow human being brothers are starving to death and it could’ve been you.



rozhamra

Posts: 1
Registered: 7/28/05
Re: Can a Wife Spend Freely of Her Own Money?
Posted: Oct 22, 2009 8:08 PM   in response to: ayisha_h in response to: ayisha_h
  Click to reply to this thread Reply

Salaam Sister,

In response to your questions, the money is all of yours to spend as you wish. You, not your husband, will be held accountable on how you spend it, however. In other words, spend on your self, your chldren and husband, IF you wish (there is NO obligation), there is no harm in that, Allah considers this as charity. However, you should not be frivolous and wasteful, turning to israaf  or becoming a spendthrift (as pharaoh did). Moderation is key.

Another point is that money as a gift from family or relatives is permissible, and no one has the right to deny you of a gift. The prophet (saws) encouraged gift giving for all muslims.

The money that is gifted is considered one and the same as the money earned from working, it is the woman's property.

Lastly, this is to reinforce your last couple of questions (These are based on sahih hadiths):

 Yes the money is hers, and women need to undertsand that they are responsible adults, and Allah will hold them accountable on how they behave and act. This means that it is not right for a woman to deny the right and responsiblity given by Allah. A woman must spend of her wealth and her husband's wealth in the way that will please Allah. That said, the husbands wealth should be the primary source of support for the wife and for the child/children, first. Now, if there is money left over, and already given out of charity, it is obligatory for the husband to spend on his wife (within moderation) in material items as part of his good treatment and love.

Further, a wifes fortune/money is NOT to supplement his income, you can help, as an act of charity. But, if the wife rather lend her hsuband the money, she is permitted for that. Actually, if is not made claer that the money given is not considered a loan, then by defalt, it is considered as such (a loan) that must be repaid, unless forgiven. The husband is responsible for returning it back to the wife, as it is considered as a loan and Allah will hold the husband accountable for it on the day of judgement.  He must pay the wife back as she lent it, it cannot be returned in substitution through a material gift or household expenses. 

In a nutshell, women are creatures with rights and respnsibilities in the sight of Allah as men are. Too often, women find it easy to take the approach where she gives up her rights as it is convenient for her. She feel s taht she then is not responsible for certain things. This is dangerous and Allah is aware of all intentions. She will be questioned on the day of judgement. So women be wise and beware, take hold of your responsibilities and Rights. It is ordained by Allah to do so.

I hope this was helpful,

Wassalaam



Maryam95


Posts: 1,292
From: Muslim live in Egypt
Registered: 11/8/07
Re: Can a Wife Spend Freely of Her Own Money?
Posted: Oct 23, 2009 7:39 PM   in response to: rozhamra in response to: rozhamra
  Click to reply to this thread Reply

rozhamra, a perfect answer, thank you very much Allah bless you. Please, do not go away.

BigB

Posts: 799
Registered: 4/29/09
Re: Can a Wife Spend Freely of Her Own Money?
Posted: Nov 3, 2009 6:36 PM   in response to: ayisha_h in response to: ayisha_h
  Click to reply to this thread Reply

Imo, this is a very strange question.

When you live together as a pair, wheter married or not, there shouldn't be any personal posessions.  That only causes division and friction.

Neither the wife NORE the husband should spend money "freely" (unless maybe if they are billionaires).

Spending of money should be done with mutual consent.

It's one thing to buy a dvd, a cd, a book or whatever.

It's an entirely different thing to suddenly drive upto the house in a Porche, buying big screen tv's, expensive computers or other devices or buying for hundreds/thousands of dollars of clothes or jewelry or whatnot.

There's a silver line there and it's sad that this needs explaining.




News | Living Shari`ah | Health & Science | Muslim Affairs | Reading Islam | Family | Art & Culture | Youth

About Us | Speech of Sheikh Qaradawi | Contact Us | Advertise | Support IOL | Guest Book | Site Map