Home| World in Crisis

Your Mail 

 
 Search 
Advanced Search

   

Afghanistan & Beyond

Views & Analyses

Against the War

America & the World

Democracy & Civil Rights

Islam vs. West?

Muslim World

Live Dialogues

Discussion Forum

Book Reviews

Day by Day

Fatwa

Zaher Shah: ‘Checkmate’?

Mosbah Allah Abdel Baqy

15/11/2001

Muhammad Zaher Shah bin Muhammad Nader Shah bin Serdar Muhammad Yusuf bin Serdar Yehia Khan bin Sultan Muhammad Khan is a descendent of the Muhammad Zay family, of the Abdaly tribe from which the founder of the Modern Afghanistan, Ahmad Shah Abdaly descended. This tribe with its different dynasties ruled from 1747 to 28 April 1978 after the downfall of its last rulers, Zahir Shah’s cousin, Serdar Muhammad Dawoud Khan, who was assassinated together with his brother Muhammad Na’aim and members of their families at the hands of Communist in the 1978 coup d'état.

 

The Fighter Father

 

To know Zahir Shah, one must start with a background review of his father. Muhammad Nader Shah was born in the year 1883 in the Dirah Don region which was under the sovereignty of British India, now part of Pakistan, since his father was exiled by the order of Prince Abdur-Rahman Khan, ruler of Afghanistan at that time. Muhammad Nader Shah excelled in English and Urdu languages.

 

Muhammad Nader Shah returned to Afghanistan after the death of Prince Abdur-Rahman Khan as his son Habib Allah Khan came to reign. Nader Shah enrolled in the Afghani army to reach the rank of Sabehsalar (then the highest rank in the army) due to his outstanding success in crushing a rebellion against the government in the Paktiya province in 1913. He did so with peaceful means and without losses.

 

He was appointed as a general leader of the Afghani forces at the Southern Front, for he led the people and the army in 1918 to totally defeat the British. Thus Britain had to recognize the independence of Afghanistan in 1919 in the aftermath of the so-called war of independence.

 

Sabehsalar Muhammad Nader Shah was appointed as a defense minister during the rule of Prince Aman Allah Khan, then as an ambassador in France. Some Western countries like France, Germany and Britain had growing apprehensions of Prince Aman Allah Khan’s complete submission to the Russians. To limit the communist expansion, they exploited Muhammad Nader Shah in entering Afghanistan through the province of Baktya with an army of Putshu tribes mostly from the southern provinces. He reached Kabul on 25 October 1929 to  keep things under control, with British assistance, to rule Afghanistan so as to restrain the return of the proponents of the Soviet Union. Yet, on the 18 November 1933, Muhammad Nader Shah was killed by Abdul Khaleq, a student at Najat School.

 

The Son From Parisian Streets to the Ministry of Defense

 

Muhammad Zahir Shah was born on 15 October 1914 in Kabul. He went to Habibiat primary school in 1920. Then, he traveled with his father to Paris in 1924 when he was appointed as an ambassador of Afghanistan. He continued his study there, but returned to Afghanistan on 15 October 1929 when his father became a King of Afghanistan.

 

Muhammad Zahir Shah was married in 1930 to the Queen Humira’a, the daughter of al-Serdar Ahmed Shah, one of his father’s ministers. He had the following children in order: Balqis, Muhammad Akbar, Ahmed Shah, Maryam, Muhammad Nader Shah, Mahmoud, Muhammad Dawoud Bishtoniar, and Mirowis.

 

His daughters studied in Malaly School, the only school for girls at Kabul at that time. His sons studied at Istiqlal School, which carried a Francophonic tendency. His son Ahmed Shah graduated from the College of Military Sciences, the Afghani Military Academy in Kabul.

 

How did He come to Power?

 

When Zahir Shah returned to Afghanistan from France, his father tried to train him to rule. He appointed him as Charge d’affaires of the Minister of Defense in 1931, and then Guarantor of the Ministry of Education in early 1932.

 

When the father was assassinated in 1933, Muhammad Zahir Shah, came to rule Afghanistan. Shiekh Fadl Omar al-Mejdidy, known as Hadrit Shor Bazar (one of the renown religious scholars in Afghanistan at that time) put the royal crown on his head.  His uncle, Shah Mahmoud, Minister of Defense in his father’s period, was the first to pledge allegiance to him.

 

Zahir Shah was fortunate that his other uncle, Muhammad Hashem Khan, a prime minister at his father’s rule, was outside Kabul in a visit to the northern provinces; if he were in Kabul, it would be difficult for Zahir Shah to seize power. King Zahir Shah remained in power until 25 June 1973 when he was ousted to Europe by a coup led by his cousin with the assistance of some communist officers in the Afghani army.

 

Zahir Shah Ruling Policy

 

The King in the fundamental law of Afghanistan at that time was above accountability or even entirely above law. Article 16 of the charter states: “The King is not responsible and is dutifully respected…”

 

His policy throughout his long period of rule was characterized by boosting relations with the Soviet Union, while despising relations with the Islamic and Arab countries, and especially neighboring ones like Pakistan. He even made firm relations with India, the archenemy of Pakistan. The communists were given full opportunity to spread their ideas. The government overlooked their establishment of a political party while banning the Islamists from forming parties. 

   

He insistently challenged to disseminate Western lifestyle. For the first time, women appeared unveiled in public gatherings during the period of his premier Muhammad Dawoud. Religious scholars were humiliated to the extent that they were beaten by the police and exiled in remote areas. This happened in the large Boly Khashety mosque in Kabul, as a large group of scholars gathered in protest of the Government’s support for the communists.

 

During his long span of rule, Afghanistan did not progress an inch, in spite of its location in a region where countries rivaled in progress, endeavoring to leap to the better for their peoples. As a matter of fact, the adjacent states to Afghanistan progressed substantially to the extent that they manufactured the nuclear bomb, while Afghanistan was in backwardness and civilizational retreat.

 

One of the causes of chaos in his era were some manners and protocols of the royal sphere. For instance, there was a custom called Barayaby which means giving the honor to visit the King or any member of the royal family. This honor was given to whoever the royal family wish. In the beginning it was normal but later it became a means for chaos and disorder. Whoever enjoyed visiting the royal family was to make firm relations with them. In turn, whoever had good relations with them considered themselves above the law like them. Only the premier was charged for any shortcomings that resulted in chaos and administrational problems. All this underestimated the premier in the eyes of the people.

 

People were killed without trial: particularly those who offend the royal family, and they were made as a lesson to all people. A typical example was after the assassination of Nader Shah and his allies. They stood for trial before the court council. Although only two were sentenced to death (Abdel Khaliq and his colleague Mahmoud) fourteen persons were killed from the two families and some students from the assassin’s school. The assassin of Nader Shah was killed by cutting him off piece by piece until he died.

 

While distancing himself from spotlight, international powers and the states of the region agreed to let him return to Afghanistan as a king once more. Although this seems uncertain due to the current reality of Afghanistan after the expulsion of Zahir Shah. The Afghans changed. They became more politically aware as they learned considerably from the wars that they went through during the two decades. They stopped being those peaceful people who needed one policeman to put a whole village in order, as was the case in the royal era.

 

Many Afghans do not respect the dethroned King. He did not even pay one visit to the refugee camps or console the people from the afflictions they suffered in their severe struggle against the Soviet forces. However, a group of the Afghani people supports his return. They include some residents of Kabul and other cities who were used to a certain way of life under the communist systems, as their condition worsened under the Talibans. This group also includes some tribal chiefdoms and ex-government employees who enjoyed many privileges during the King’s era since he considered them the pillars of his rule.   

 

The Weak King and His Corrupted Administration

 

Sabaheldeen Kashkeky, a former minister in the royal reign in the ministry of Muhammad Musa Shafik, thinks that the King had a weak personality lacking willpower and determination. Under strong public pressure, he allowed some political reforms, such as direct election of the Shura Council, but he restrained from allowing in the party law a charter for the formation of national and Islamic parties. Thus he left the way clear for the clandestine communist and leftist parties to do whatever they wanted. Actually, the communists impeded the King’s certification of the party law through their influence on his advisers, in order not have rival parties, otherwise their relation to the Soviet Union would not have been controlled by law.

 

His weak personality was also apparent in his dealing with his family members. General Abdel Waly, his son-in-law, who was the then head of the arms forces, accompanied him to-date, while Serdar Muhammad Dawoud Khan who was his cousin and his sister’s husband was the one who overthrew him. The King feared confrontation, although he knew that Muhammad Dawoud was looking after the communists, paving the way for Soviet intervention in the domestic affairs of Afghanistan. He eventually felt the danger posed to him as he was too weak to face or oppose Muhammad Dawoud. He was warned about the communist danger on the country and suggested to curb them, but he said “No, no, Agha will not accept it.” Agha was the family name of Muhammad Dawoud.

 

Those who are close to him believe that he lacked the courage to return to Afghanistan. However, his old age and deteriorating health makes it difficult for him to assume the responsibility of government. Analysts think that if he returns, he will be among an inharmonious formation incapable of governing successfully.

 

The Position of different Parties toward the King

 

The name of the King Zahir Shah was sporadically proposed throughout the Jihad period to come to rein Afghanistan. But some of the Jihad parties such as the Islamic Party led by Hakimtiyar, the Islamic Association led by Rabani, the Islamic Union by Seiaf, and the Islamic Party led by Khalis completely objected to his return. They considered him a partner in the crime of facilitating the circumstances for disseminating the communist ideology. In addition, his family was accused of moral corruption, as they helped in spreading the Western style of life.

 

Some Jihad personalities like Jilani, al-Mejdedy and al-Molowy Muhammad Namby backed him. However, General Hamid Jel, the former head of the Pakistani intelligence, said in an interview in the BBC, “All the Jihad parties refused his return during the era of General Muhammad Diaa al-Haq.”

 

From this concise review, it seems that the Afghani chessboard can do without the spoiled King forever. It dismissed him from its political game by saying, “Checkmate”. The hands that tried to control this game will only fail, for it seems that the “pons” who occupy the chessboard are bored from those who offerred them cake when they are in dire need of bread.

 

News

Views & Analyses

Qur'an

Hadith & Sunnah

Discover Islam

New to Islam

Live Dialogue

Live Fatwa

Discussion Forum

Contemporary Issues


FEEDBACK  | CONTACT US  | GUEST BOOK  | SITE MAP


Best viewed by:
MS Internet Explorer 4.0
and above.

Copyright © 2000 Islam Online
Al rights reserved

Disclaimer

Developed and Managed by
IslamOnline