Home| World in Crisis

Your Mail 

 
 Search 
Advanced Search

   

Afghanistan & Beyond

Views & Analyses

Against the War

America & the World

Democracy & Civil Rights

Islam vs. West?

Muslim World

Live Dialogues

Discussion Forum

Book Reviews

Day by Day

Fatwa

The Taliban Strategy: Religious & Ethnic Factors

Misbah Allah Abdel Baky
Islamic University – Islamabad

10/11/2001

The Taliban has adopted a strategy whose features have unraveled as it runs counter to the U.S. presence inside Afghanistan. This strategy lays stress on Afghanistan and Pakistan. It is motivated by the early American attempts to isolate the Taliban regime from the world community by retracting Saudia Arabia and the UAE’s acknowledgement of the Taliban government. This, they claim, causes no harm to the Taliban since their mantra is: We ask nothing from anyone and no one asks us anything.

 

Analysts sum up the Taliban’s strategy as follows:

 

1-Mobilizing the religious public in Pakistan

One of the most important points in the Taliban’s strategy is to mobilize the religiously-minded in Pakistan, especially the advocates of Pakistani religious parties who consider the Taliban Movement to be their extension in Afghanistan.

 

The religious public in Pakistan comprises of several trends:

 

-Salafi Trend: This trend and all relevant groups lack popularity. Only a minority that is incapable of mobilizing the Pakistani public follows this trend. Nevertheless it has been conditioned to obedience of the ruler thus being friendly to government decisions.

 

-Barilwi Trend: It is a Sufi trend represented by several political parties, the most famous of which are: “Pakistani Ulamma Association” headed by Sheikh Ahmad Shah Nourani, a veteran politician; the “Quran Method Movement;” and “The National Movement” headed by Sheikh Dr. Tahir Al Qaderi. This trend enjoys a huge popularity among the Pakistani public. Poor political awareness of its followers, however, falls short of serving the Taliban. This trend is mainly pragmatic. The ideological discrepancies between the followers of this trend and the Dubands, who consider themselves to be an extension of the Taliban, have confused their activities to support the Taliban.

 

-Duband Trend: This trend also acquires popularity among the Pakistani public, especially in the Sarhad and Baluchistan provinces. It is supported by 10,000 religious schools all over Pakistan. This trend is politically represented in Pakistan by a party called Islamic Ulama’ Association which has been split into two parties: one headed by  Sheikh Fadl Al Rahman and the other by Sheikh Sami` Al Haq

         

This trend has undergone some changes since the end of the Afghani war. Some organizations that participated in the Afghani war now participate in Jihad in Kashmir. They are becoming increasingly interested in politics although some of them - especially scholars - used to be reluctant in this respect.

 

-Haraki Trend: This trend is represented in “Al Jama`a al Islamiya” in Pakistan headed by Sheikh Al Qadi Hussein Ahmad. Although it lacks popularity with the public, it is capable of mobilizing the people due to its disciplined organization and devoted members.

         

The Taliban, as mentioned above, is an ideological extension of the Duband movement. The Taliban wants to draw upon this bond and mobilize the Duband parties in Pakistan to riot against America’s threats to the Taliban and to protest on Pakistan’s cooperation with the U.S.

         

The Taliban’s fanaticism has been their mistake even in the present circumstances. Consequently they cannot communicate with all trends representing religious public in Pakistan. They have confined their communication to the Duband Trend. Even Al Jama`a al Islamiya, that saw no room for silence and opposed the governmental support of the U.S., did not receive any endorsement nor word of thanks from Taliban’s officials. Taliban radio broadcasts, Sawt al Shari`ah, omitted airing news of demonstrations organized by the Pakistani movement. Detailed news, however, is aired about the movements of Sheikh Fadl Al Rahman and Sheikh Sami Al Haq.

 

Stopping the Americans from Pakistan

 

The Taliban seeks to make use of its borders with Pakistan to put a stop to the U.S.: this is the Taliban’s second plan.

 

2-Mobilising the population of Pashtun Tribes on the border

Pashtun tribes inhabit the borders between Afghanistan and Pakistan. These tribes were well armed during the Afghani war to the extent of possessing heavy artillery and cannons. They are known for their aggressiveness in war. The Taliban wants to make use of these tribes to prevent American forces from entering via Pakistan and settling beside the Afghani borders inside Pakistan.

 

Throughout history, tribal Sheikhs have been known for being pragmatic and tempted with money. America, however, does not want to risk the lives of its soldiers, thus it has altered its strategy. They initially thought of Pakistan as the centre of the American forces and attacks. The furious riots, demonstrations and death threats, however, have caused the U.S. forces to be based in Uzbekistan or any of  Central Asian countries.

 

They might be satisfied with intelligence information offered by Pakistan and permission to fly in Pakistani airspace -but not the bases - for troops based on the Afghani-Pakistani borders.

 

3- Trying to build up confidence among population of the southern states

Afghani modern history indicates that the southern population  like “Piktia” and “Piktika” are the most liable to be bribed. The British had previously appointed Nadir Shah, the father of Afghanistan exiled king Thahir Shah through “Piktia”. They even built an army and toppled prince HabibuLlah Kalakani known as Bacha Saqaw.

 

The Taliban wants to save itself an re-enactment of history; Thahir Shah according to them should not follow his father’s line. The rulers of this state have been given a lot of confidence. Leader Galal Iddin Haqani has been appointed a major general in its forces. Other personalities became in charge of several posts in these states.

 

4- Resorting to previous jihad leaderships

The Taliban used to consider previous leaders who were Mujahiddin as criminals. Mullah Muhammad Omar has ordered the death of Rabbani, Sayyaf and Hikmatyar if caught. “Their destinies will be as that of Naguib,” Mullah Omar stated in a press conference on the day they conquered Kabul.

 

The Taliban has continuously rejected any mediation to bolster closer relations between the Movement and the jihad parties, although the latter has frequently shown willingness to do so.

 

Nevertheless, the Taliban has attempted to make use of some of those figures. Thus, they have mandated a delegation of ministers and some old members of the Islamic Party to Iran to reach a settlement with Hikmatyar, Mullawi Muhammad Younus Khalis and Mullawi Muhammad Nabi.

 

The Taliban, however, has made no initiative to settle disputes with the Northern Alliance and achieve solidarity. No understanding can be currently projected as the Northern Alliance now considers the Taliban too weak.

 

The U.S. and its allies seem to have realized that the Taliban still has the Pashtun’s favor. Therefore they have set aside any rhetoric that may provoke the Pashtuns and urge them to take the Taliban’s side to defend their rights. They have become less interested in the Northern Alliance, and instead intend to form a government in which all ethnic groups, especially the Pashtuns, participate. This has been stated by Tony Blair in a press conference he held October 5 after talks with Pervez Musharaf.

 

Analysts believe that the U.S is seeking an alternative to the Taliban in areas where the Pashtuns are a majority so that they may be a part of the new government. Pashtuns, therefore, will have no reason to back the Taliban. The expected government will lack harmony, unfortunately, as each of the states representing the global force will make sure that it comprises of those who will watch their own interests.   

 

News

Views & Analyses

Qur'an

Hadith & Sunnah

Discover Islam

New to Islam

Live Dialogue

Live Fatwa

Discussion Forum

Contemporary Issues


FEEDBACK  | CONTACT US  | GUEST BOOK  | SITE MAP


Best viewed by:
MS Internet Explorer 4.0
and above.

Copyright © 2000 Islam Online
Al rights reserved

Disclaimer

Developed and Managed by
IslamOnline