Though
Islam is the religion of one, Muslims are a people of many - many
triumphs, problems, cultures and nationalities. And while the holy
Qu’ran, five pillars of Islam and Hadith(s) (sayings of the
Prophet Muhammad) remain a constant for Muslims the world over,
religious interpretation beyond them is the starting point for a
global discussion on what it means to be Muslim.
It
is a discussion fraught with varying opinions, scholarly debate and
personal beliefs. It is a discussion brought into focus by the
events of September 11th. Yet though Islam is touted as the
fast-growing religion in the world, Muslims themselves are still
viewed with mistrust and misconceptions, according to many U.S.
opinion polls. Now a new documentary, which airs Thursday evening,
seeks to address those misconceptions.
“Muslims”,
a two-hour documentary produced by Frontline (a news program
of PBS) and the Independent Production Fund investigates the
“different faces of Islam’s worldwide resurgence.” The program
visits six countries - Iran, Nigeria, Egypt, Malaysia, Turkey and
the United States - to tell the stories of Muslims from all walks of
life and how they interpret their faith.
It
is an impressive piece of television, sweeping the world to
highlight a number of issues debated by Muslims who struggle to live
Islam the best way they believe. Yet to view the program as a lesson
on Islam is false. It is the lessons of different Muslims, or as
producer Graham Judd says, “Within the story of 1.5 billion
Muslims in the world, this is the story of 12 of them.”
Judd
cautions Muslim viewers, especially, to be patient with the
documentary. “This is not meant to be a definitive body of work on
Islam. We wanted to show how different Muslims around the world live
their lives as a way for the Western world to better understand
their struggles. This is meant to be a start.”
The
documentary, which was prescreened in New York Tuesday evening as
part of the Museum of Television and Radio’s 2002 Television
Documentary Festival, opens with traditional images of Muslims
praying and wearing the hijab (female headscarf). Egypt is
the first country visited, with a focus on Sheik Abdul Mauwith, an
Islamic scholar and member of Al Azhar’s Fatwa committee.
Mauwith
issues fatwa(s) (formal religious opinions) based on Shariah
(Islamic) law. He advises Muslims to follow a conservative Islamic
path. From there the importance of Shariah is followed across
Nigeria, Iran, Turkey and Malaysia, where other Muslims give their
opinions on how they interpret Shariah and how those interpretations
affect their political, economic and social lives.
In
Malaysia, viewers are introduced to Harlina Siraj, an
obstetrician/gynecologist who manages a busy practice along with her
family life and religious obligations. She is the vision of a modern
Muslim woman - religious, strong, family and career-oriented. She
doesn’t feel oppressed at all.
“Liberated?”
she says, “Well, I’ve been born a free person.”
Her
story is contrasted with another Malaysian woman who has struggled
for more than seven years to obtain a divorce under Shariah law
after her husband beat her and took another wife. Muslim activist
Zainah Anwar, who advises the woman, says the problem lies not in
Islam, but in interpretation.
“We
found that it is not Islam that discriminates against women,”
Anwar says in the documentary. “It is not the verses in the
Qu’ran, it is the way that these verses have been interpreted by
men, living in patriarchal societies who wish to maintain their
dominance and their superiority and control over women.”
In
Iran, the only country to have overthrown a modern government in
favor of Islamic law, many people struggle with the country’s
sense of revolution. Now some wonder if the country has made a
success of its revolution.
“One
could argue that we haven't been all that successful in bringing to
life what we wanted - economic well-being and a sense of community,
a sense of belonging,” says Hadi Semati, a professor of political
science at Tehran University and an adviser to Iran’s President
Khatami.
“Muslims”
then moves on to Turkey, which is the opposite of Iran. It’s a
country that has gone from an Islamic government to a secular one
that does all it can to clamp down on Muslims. The country’s
controversial headscarf ban has become the crux of its problems,
pitting young Muslim women just wanting to peacefully live their
lives against those who believe the headscarf is the stepping-stone
to so-called “fundamental” behavior.
And
finally the documentary lands in the United States where a
“reassertion of [Muslim-American] identity has led to
confrontations with other ethnic and religious groups - particularly
since September 11.” For these Muslims, the question of Shariah
interpretation is on the backburner in favor of balancing strong
faith with daily life in America.
In
Bridgeview, Illinois where Muslims faced prejudice when they tried
to purchase an abandoned church to convert into a mosque, a
court-sanctioned interfaith dialogue has helped lessen the fog
between the communities. As one Muslim there eloquently says, the
(Christian) Lord’s Prayer is “Islam in a capsule. The only
difference is that we put all our emphasis on the Father.”
All
these different stories offer a slice of Muslim life across the
world - no more and no less. “Muslims” is not an authoritative
work on what Islam is, not by any means. Rather its objective is to
“put a human face on Islam,” says Alvin Perlmutter, executive
producer of the documentary. The six countries featured were chosen
for their diversity of culture and nationality, to show that Islam
is not just a Middle Eastern religion, added Anisa Mehdi, another
executive producer of the program.
Martin
Smith, senior producer of “Muslims”, says he wanted the
documentary to go beyond what people see in the media. “The
nightly news doesn’t address the important struggle within the
Muslim world for the soul of Islam,” he says.
In
these post-September 11th days, that struggle, which is powerfully
brought to light in “Muslims”, is proving to be the most vital
issue on the minds of all, whether Muslim or not.
“Muslims”
airs Thursday, May 9th at 9 p.m. (EST). Visit www.pbs.org/frontline
for more information, or check your local
listings.