Additional
Reporting By Ahmed Al-Matboli, IOL Correspondent
BERLIN,
March 26, 2006 (IslamOnline.net & News Agencies) – Many
freshly-minted citizens, who have lived in Germany for long years as
immigrants, doubt the effectiveness of a proposed 100-question
citizenship test, with an opinion poll showing that the majority of
native Germans have failed to answer the questions of the quiz.
"It's
not bad to have that kind of general knowledge, whether you're German or
not. But knowing the answers wouldn't make me feel more German,"
said Sisi, who fled with her father to Germany from Angola nine years
ago, the German Deutsche Welle reported Sunday, March 26, on its
website.
The
test, which has been approved by the German state of Hessen, wants
would-be new citizens to possess an in-depth knowledge of German
history, culture, politics and values.
"What
is the population of Germany? Which year did the Nazi dictatorship take
power in Germany? Which German Chancellor won the Nobel Peace Prize? In
which year did Germany's constitution come into effect? are but samples
of the 100 questions.
Applicants
would also be asked to name three German philosophers and state how
often national elections are held in Germany.
The
quiz has drawn fire from many parties and politicians in the European
country, with the Green Party complaining it was too extensive.
Others
have criticized the nature of the questions and how relevant they really
are for potential citizens.
Living
Integration
Sisi,
25, said answering the questions should not be a condition for getting
the citizenship.
"It
doesn't necessarily mean you're a proper German."
Though
she went to a German school and is now a trained retail saleswoman, Sisi
was unable to answer questions such as "What did German scientist
Otto Hahn do in 1938?" or "In which German elections are EU
citizens allowed to vote?"
She
asserted that immigrants learn German culture and values by living in
the country.
"I
learnt all about Germany when I came here," said Sisi.
"Germans
eat at specific times, they visit each other at specific times. Sunday
is a day of rest, which is a custom we don't have in Africa. I've become
very German in that respect."
But
Gloria, another immigrant in Germany, said some of the test's questions
make sense.
"It's
reasonable to expect people to know about the country they want to live
in," added Gloria, who hails from Albania and has lived in Germany
for 14 years.
She
agrees on the need for a test, but thinks the priorities need to be
different.
"..those
people who don't get the opportunity to go to school in Germany, like
many of the guest workers who came here, stayed and started a family,
obviously aren't going to know anything about the Reformation or which
convention took place in 1848."
Gloria
believes the questions tend to concentrate very much on history with no
mention at all of contemporary German culture.
"Why
aren't there any questions about modern pop music or hip hop?"
Germans
Fail
A
recent opinion poll showed that a majority of native Germans have failed
to answer many questions in the citizenship test.
Some
79.8 percent of Germans polled by the German Omni Quest institute
failed to answer a question about the name of the German national
anthem.
A
percentage of 68.8 also wrongly answered a question about when the
eastern and western parts of Germany were united while a 44.1 percent
failed to give the right number of the German states.
Around
20.4 percent did not know the name of the first German Chancellor.
The
poll, which included a random sample of 1,000 Germans over 14 years old,
included only ten of the test's 100 questions.
The
issue of integration has recently taken central stage in several
European countries.
On
Thursday, March 23, the interior ministers of Germany, Britain, France,
Italy, Poland and Spain agreed to weigh drafting an integration contract
in which new immigrants would agree to respect Western values.
The
Netherlands has recently imposed some of the world's toughest national
entry laws, with would-be immigrants having to watch a film featuring a
topless woman and gay men kissing to test their readiness to accept
Dutch values.
The
latest European statistics show that immigration is holding off the
demographic decline in Europe as the natural population growth is
slowing across the 25-nation bloc.
According
to the EU's statistics office Eurostat, all of Europe's heavyweights,
except for France, now depend on immigration to keep their populations
stable or growing.
Also
read: