CAIRO,
January 28, 2006 (IslamOnline.net) – Breaking an official silence,
the Indonesian government finally vocalized opposition to the planned
debut of a local edition of the raunchy magazine Playboy, admitting
that its legal hands remain tied, The Jakarta Post reported on
Saturday, January 28.
"The
government is in the position of disagreeing with it," Vice
President Jusuf Kalla told journalists on Friday, January 27, when
asked about the planned publication.
"This
isn't America, you know. Even Singapore doesn't allow the magazine to
be published there. So the plan is not proper."
Ponti
Carrolus, director of PT Velvet Silver Media which holds the
Indonesian license from the US-based magazine, recently vowed to go
ahead with the launch of the local version despite growing protests.
Nahdlatul
Ulama (NU), Indonesia's largest Muslim organization with some 40
million members, has reacted in fury over the planned debut.
The
Association of Muhammadiyah Students (IMM) also voiced strong
rejection to the planned publication of the magazine for a concern
that it might destroy the morality of the nation.
Indonesia
is the most populous Muslim state with a population of 220 million,
80% of them are Muslims.
Founded
in 1953, Playboy has about 20 local editions around the world
that cater to local taste rather than simply exporting and translating
its US content.
Hands
Tied
The
vice president said, however, the government had no legal ground to
ban the publication.
"The
government has no authority at all when it comes to licensing for mass
media," Kalla asserted.
"We
no longer have what once was called the SIUPP (publishing license), so
anyone can publish anything. If we applied the SIUPP again, (the
press) would definitely be infuriated."
Under
former Indonesian President Soeharto, who ruled for nearly three
decades, all media outlets had to get a SIUPP from the government,
which was seen by many as a tool to repress freedom of speech, said
the daily.
Since
Soeharto resigned in 1998, publishers are only required to register
their publications with the government.
A
bill is before the Indonesian House of Representatives on pornography
and porn-related acts, but it may be passed after the debut of the
publication, expected in March.
Kalla
said measures to curb the content of such adult magazines should be
part of the bill when it is passed into law.
He
also criticized Ponti's statements on the content of the local edition
of Playboy.
"It
would be fooling the consumers. You shouldn't provide false fantasies
to consumers by using the name of Playboy but with different
content," he said.
"But
if there's nudity, it would be against our ethics here."
Tarman
Azzam, the chairman of the Indonesian Journalists Association (PWI),
has called for taking the producers and sellers of the magazine to
court if it reaches children.