VATICAN
CITY, December 13, 2005 (IslamOnline.net & News Agencies) – Pope
Benedict XVI stressed on Tuesday, December 13, that war could never
justify human rights abuses, as a European watchdog said the US
appeared to have abducted and detained individuals and illegally
transferred them between countries.
"The
truth of peace must also let its beneficial light shine even amid the
tragedy of war," the pontiff said in a 12-page New Year peace
message traditionally released by the Vatican ahead of the Christmas
period, reported Reuters.
Pope
Benedict said the Vatican was convinced international humanitarian law
had to be respected "even in the midst of war".
Although
he did not name any countries or wars, Cardinal Renato Martino, head
of the Vatican Justice and Peace department, said the pontiff's words
applied to all wars.
Asked
if Iraq was included, he said: "That's correct."
Human
Rights Watch revealed that US troops routinely subjected Iraqi
detainees to severe beatings and other cruel and inhumane treatment as
a "way of sport" or just to "relieve stress".
Respect
Geneva
Asked
if Pope Benedict was singling out the US for condemnation, Martino
said the pontiff "is not condemning anybody but is inviting them
to observe the Geneva Convention."
Washington
also maintains that the Geneva Convention does not apply to foreign
detainees in its so-called "war on terror".
However,
human rights activists counter that the US is still bound by the 1984
UN Convention against torture to which it is a signatory.
"Torture
is a humiliation of the human person, whoever he is," said
Martino.
"The
Church does not admit it ... there are other means to make people
talk," he added.
Last
week, a group of American Roman Catholic peace activists held a march
to the US Naval Guantanamo Bay, protesting conditions for terror
suspects.
The
US has been keeping hundreds of detainees at Guantanamo since the
invasion of Afghanistan in 2001.
The
New York Times revealed on October 17,
2004, that uncooperative detainees in Guantanamo were regularly
tortured by US guards.
The
HRW issued a report entitled "The Road To Abu Ghraib"
linking the abuse of detainees in Iraq, Afghanistan and Guantanamo to
the policies adopted by US President George W. Bush in his so-called
war on terror.
CIA
Abductions
 |
|
Marty said information "reinforced the credibility" of accusations on the transfer and temporary detention of individuals in Europe. (Reuters)
|
In
a related development, the Strasburg-based Council of Europe said on
Tuesday that the US appeared to have abducted and detained individuals
and transformed them between countries, reported Agence France Presse
(AFP).
"The
information gathered to date reinforced the credibility of the
allegations concerning the transfer and temporary detention of
individuals, without any judicial involvement, in European
countries," Dick Marty, rapporteur of the Committee on Legal
Affairs and Human Rights, said in his findings presented to the human
rights watchdog.
"Legal
proceedings in progress in certain countries seemed to indicate that
individuals had been abducted and transferred to other countries
without respect for any legal standards," he concluded.
The
Bush administration has been under growing international pressures
over charges that the CIA has illegally used European airports and
airspace to transport terror suspects between countries without legal
process.
Reports
of clandestine CIA interrogation centers and transport flights for
terror suspects emerged in November, along with suggestions of
on-board torture sessions.
The
EU has threatened sanctions against any of its members found to have
been operating such secret prisons, or allowing their territory to be
used for the transport of the phantom detainees.
Renditions
were was first authorized by President Ronald Reagan in 1986 and used
by the Clinton administration to transfer drug lords and terrorists to
the US or other countries for military or criminal trials.
US
President George W. Bush has strongly defended such transfers as
"vital to the nation's defense".
Evidence
Citing
anonymous informants from inside intelligence agencies as well as
published press reports, Marty said "the allegations that have
been made are receiving day by day more weight."
Substantiating
evidence for the charges, he said, came from US Secretary of State
Condoleezza Rice who failed to deny categorically that detainees were
transported or held in Europe.
Marty
quoted the widely-reported cases of two men -- an Egyptian imam and a
German of Lebanese origin -- who were abducted by CIA snatch squads in
Milan and Macedonia in 2003.
The
first remains in custody in Egypt, while the second was the victim of
a mistaken identity.
"These
two facts are significant because they indicate methodology, logistics
and personnel for this kind of operation -- operations which are
totally contrary to the spirit and the text of the European convention
on human rights," Marty stressed.
German
Chancellor Angela Merkel said Tuesday, December 6, that Rice admitted
her country made a mistake in abducting the German national and flying
him to a secret prison in Afghanistan.
In
a report entitled "Ending Secret Detention", the American
Human Rights First said the US has more than 24
world detention camps,
at least half of them operate in total secrecy, where the abuse of
detainees is "inevitable".