 |
|
Hughes
got a taste of how tough it is to improve badly damaged US image
abroad.
|
CAIRO,
September 26, 2005 (IslamOnline.net & News Agencies) – US Under
Secretary of State Karen P. Hughes, tasked with improving a badly
bruised US image abroad, was faced with a flurry of angry reasons why
Washington was disliked in the Arab and Muslim worlds during her
meeting with Egyptian students.
The
meeting took place Sunday, September 25, at the American University in
Cairo (AUC), where Hughes got a taste of the difficult job ahead when
she found herself faced with angry queries over the US war on terror,
Iraq, aggressive stance on Syria and Iran, in addition to meddling in
the affairs of developing countries.
On
Iraq, students accused the United States of illegally invading a
sovereign state against the will of the international community, then
failing to restore stability and further risking a civil war there.
In
her answers, Hughes repeated US claims the world was now safer after
ousting the regime of former Iraqi president Saddam Hussein.
US
President George W. Bush feared weapons of mass destruction could
reach what she termed as terrorists, and therefore Saddam had to be
ousted, despite international objections, the US diplomacy envoy said,
according to the Middle East News Agency (MENA), Egypt's official News
Agency.
A
study by the Washington-based
Center for Strategic and International
Studies (CSIS) and released Sunday, September 18, blamed the US-led
invasion-turned-occupation of Iraq for radicalizing “almost
exclusively” Saudis and recruiting them to Al-Qaeda network of Osama
Bin Laden.
The
meeting came during Hughes' first visit to the Middle East after
assuming her post. She arrived in Egypt Sunday, in the first leg of a
tour that will also take her to Saudi Arabia and Turkey.
The
students – high school graduates that won US scholarships for
college studies – also criticized Washington's attempts to isolate
Syria and Iran, arguing the region is already boiling with anger at US
invasions of Afghanistan and Iraq.
Human
rights abuses at Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo detention camps were also
subject of more criticisms Hughes found herself facing.
Her
replies were, for the most part, a repetition of US positions that
seemed incapable of changing a growingly deteriorating image in the
Arab and Muslim worlds.
Hughes
told the students Tehran had failed to meet its pledges to the
international community, adding that the US was working closely with
the EU-3; Britain, France and Germany to secure a safer future for the
world as the US feared terrorists could lay their hands on nuclear
weapons, according to MENA.
Deeds,
Not Words
 |
|
Tantawi,
right, welcomed Hughes to Al-Azhar.
|
Meanwhile,
an Egyptian state-owned paper predicted Hughes' attempt to improve
Washington's image abroad is bound to fail unless she can promise
changes in US policy in the Middle East.
The
new editor of Al-Gomhuria daily said Egyptians who meet Hughes
should advise the United States to withdraw from Iraq and put pressure
on Israel to withdraw from all of the West Bank, after leaving Gaza,
according to a Reuters' report.
"We
in Egypt or anywhere else do not need a public relations campaign like
the one America is conducting," wrote Mohamed Ali Ibrahim.
"Egyptians
or Saudis or Turks will not suddenly like America because it has set
up a television or radio station ... but feelings may change if
America changes its whole approach."
US
officials say they do not plan to change policies to please Arabs but
they are looking at other ways of changing attitudes -- such as better
presentation of policy, emphasizing points of agreement and more
direct contacts between peoples, Reuters said.
In
Cairo Hughes met the head of al Azhar, one of the Sunni Muslim world's
main centers of religious learning and Prime Minister Ahmed Nazif
Monday.
After
her talks with Nazif, Hughes said the United States wanted
Palestinians to have a normal peaceful life in a Palestinian state
alongside Israel.
"The
Gaza disengagement offers an opportunity for this to be a very hopeful
time for the road map," she added.
But
Al-Gomhuria editor said: "Egyptian officials can also
advise Washington ... not to concentrate on the Israeli withdrawal
from Gaza as a great breakthrough for peace, because there are many
parts of occupied Palestine which are still waiting for the occupiers
to evacuate.
"To
reward Israel at this particular time would be a major setback for the
peace process."
Interfaith
After
meeting with Al-Azhar Grand Sheikh Muhammad Sayyed Tantawi, Hughes
told reporters, "I had a wonderful meeting with him. I thanked
him because Al-Azhar under his leadership was among the first -- and
he said the first -- religious institution in the world to condemn the
September 11 attacks".
She
said Bush and Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice had asked her to
focus during her visit on interfaith dialogue.
"The
sheikh pointed out that all divine religions are built on the spirit
of love and it is important that all of us work together to fight
extremism and terrorism," Hughes said.
Hughes
said on the plane that this was her first trip to the region and that
she as eager to learn as much as she could in her new capacity, in
which she oversees the entire State Department public affairs
apparatus as well as its cultural and exchange programs.
Her
appointment to the job earlier this year followed reports from inside
the administration as well as from policy institutes and universities
warning that in the last few years American standing in the world,
particularly in Islamic countries, has plummeted to new lows.
Hughes
said she would steer clear of meeting with representatives of Egypt's
largest opposition group, and a lunch scheduled for Monday with
"opinion leaders" included mostly people supportive of the
government that has ruled the country under emergency decree for a
quarter-century, said the Washington Post.
Outside
the carefully vetted settings of Hughes's visit, interviews with
ordinary Egyptians indicated deep anger at the policies of the Bush
administration.