VIENNA,
September 22, 2005 (IslamOnline.net & News Agencies) – The
European Union backtracked Thursday, September 22, on a drive to
immediately refer the Iranian nuclear to the UN Security Council, but
Moscow remained unsatisfied.
A
new draft resolution to the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA)
by the EU's big three omitted any explicit threat that Iran would be
immediately referred to the Security Council but implied that the IAEA
board could choose to refer the matter to the Council in the future,
reported Reuters.
It
said the "history of concealment of Iran's nuclear
activities" and "absence of confidence" that its
program was solely for peaceful purposes gave "rise to questions
that are within the competence of the Security Council".
The
new draft charges that Iran had been in "non-compliance"
with the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT), which normally
requires the IAEA board to notify the Council.
Earlier
this week, France, Britain and Germany had circulated a US-backed
draft resolution calling on the IAEA's governing board to report
Iran's nuclear program to the Security Council.
But
with at least a dozen of the 35 members of the board opposed to the
text -- including heavyweight China and Russia -- the EU cut out the
key demand from the revised draft.
Iran
had threatened to limit UN inspections and withdraw from the NPT if
its nuclear file was sent to the UN Security Council.
Rally
Support
Iran's
ambassador to the IAEA, Mohammad Mehdi Akhunzadeh, welcomed the
development and invited IAEA chief Mohamed ElBaradei to Tehran to
discuss various outstanding issues and how to improve cooperation with
the agency.
An
IAEA spokeswoman declined to comment when asked if ElBaradei would
accept. He last visited Tehran in April 2004.
EU
diplomats said they hoped to get unanimous support for what they
called a very tough and fair draft resolution.
US
Ambassador to the IAEA Gregory Schulte claimed that "a solid and
growing majority of the IAEA board now also agrees on the need to
report Iran to the UN Security Council."
China's
Foreign Ministry spokesman Qin Gang said there was room for dialogue.
He
called for a resumption of EU-Iran talks that collapsed after two
years when Tehran resumed uranium processing work at a plant in
Isfahan last month.
Not
Enough
Russia,
however, rejected the new draft, saying it is too tough on Tehran,
reported Agence France-Presse (AFP).
"It
is a plane that does not fly," Russian ambassador Grigory
Berdennikov told AFP.
A
Western diplomat said that at a meeting with the resolution's drafters
the Russians had crossed out clauses that cited Iran for
non-compliance with international nuclear safeguards and opened the
door to eventual referral to the UN Security Council, even if the
Council was not specifically mentioned.
The
new draft resolution had been "a tactical gesture to show
flexibility. It didn't work," the diplomat said.
Berdennikov
huddled with Iranian officials for talks shortly after rejecting the
draft but neither side would comment to an AFP reporter about the
meeting.
EU
diplomats say Russia's support is crucial to achieving their aim of
getting consensus on an IAEA resolution.
A
European diplomat told Reuters said there was no reaction from China
yet, though he expected Beijing's view would be similar to Moscow's.
Russia,
China and non-aligned nations back Tehran's right to a peaceful
nuclear program and fear that Security Council, the United Nations'
highest body, action could escalate into calls for trade sanctions
that would draw sharp retaliation from oil-rich Iran.
If
there is no unanimity for the new draft resolution, the European trio
were ready to demand a vote on the previous draft, diplomats told AFP.
A
second Western diplomat said the Europeans are sure to do this,
although other diplomats said the EU-3 were hoping that negotiations
could still succeed on the more mild, second draft.
Diplomats
agreed the West would win a vote on the first resolution but warned
that a lack of consensus would not have a strong impact on Iran and
would be a prelude to paralysis at the Security Council.
Iran
and the European Union embarked in December on negotiations towards a
long-term agreement to give Tehran trade, technology and security aid
and guarantees in return for it taking steps to reassure the
international community that its nuclear program is strictly peaceful.
The
US accuses Iran of having a secret program to manufacture nuclear
weapons.
Iran
staunchly denies the allegations and maintains that its nuclear
program is only designed to produce electricity.
The
right to peaceful nuclear technology is enshrined in the NPT that for
35 years has governed efforts to contain the spread of atomic weapons.