BAGHDAD,
August 16, 2005 (IslamOnline.net & News Agencies) - Iraq's
parliament gave drafters of the new constitution an extra week to
complete the new charter after weeks of intensive talks failed to
resolve sticking points and meet the deadline on Monday, August 15.
"We
weren't able despite all efforts to reach solutions that would satisfy
everyone," parliament speaker Hajim Al-Hasani told a parliament
session, reported Agence France-Presse (AFP).
In
order to give the drafters a new deadline, Iraqi lawmakers had to
amend an article in the Transitional Administrative Law (TAL).
"The
national assembly should draft the permanent constitution within a
period ending by August 22," Hasani said as he read the proposed
amendment which the MPs approved by raising their hands.
Iraq's
top leaders had battled for the past two weeks over a charter that
aimed to set the country on a new political roadmap.
The
TAL, an interim constitution drawn up under US occupation last year,
called for the interim legislature to be dissolved and elections by
December for a new constitution-drafting body if no draft permanent
constitution was ready by August 15.
"Huge
efforts were exerted, and principal issues have been settled, but this
crucial project needs closer examination, and therefore, more
time," said President Jalal Talabani, who on Saturday expected
the new charter to be ready ahead of the Monday deadline.
Just
an hour before parliament would have been forced to recognize failure
to write a constitution by the deadline and face dissolution under the
US-drafted TAL, negotiators went to the chamber to ask for 10 more
days, according to Reuters.
Friction
Prime
Minister Ibrahim Jaafari said the sticking points had been federalism
and sharing out revenues.
An
initial agreement to share the oil revenues has been agreed, but the
mechanism to distribute it remains to be formulated.
Refusal
by Sunni leaders to grant wide autonomy -- and control of oil income
-- to the Shiites in the south appeared to break any accord, according
to Reuters.
Kurdish
autonomy, secured de facto after the 1991 Gulf War, has been less of
an issue but other groups are wary of demands from some Kurds to push
for a possibility of outright secession.
Shiites’
call for Islam to have a bigger role in Iraqi law has also been a
source of friction.
Officials
close the negotiations told Reuters that panelists suggested that, if
there is no consensus deal, the Shiites and Kurds in parliament could
use their overwhelming majority to bypass Sunni objections.
Sunni
leaders say they would resist that fiercely.
Opposition
from the Sunnis could still scupper the new constitution as the
interim rules stipulate the charter can be rejected by a two-thirds
majority in any three provinces. Al-Anbar, Tamim and Salaheddin are
predominately Sunni.
Political
Crisis
 |
|
"It was no disappointment because we have done a lot," said Talabani. (Reuters)
|
If
a constitution is agreed, it will go to a referendum by October 15 and
a full-term parliament would be elected by December.
Some
panelists warned of a looming political crisis if they failed once
again to reach a compromise.
"This
is a one-time extension... if Iraq misses the next deadline, we have
to dissolve the national assembly, the government will collapse and
fresh elections will have to be held," Kurdish panelist Munther
Al-Fadhal told AFP.
Fadhal
said the present interim law stipulates that it can be amended only
once to seek an extension for drafting the charter.
Exhausted
negotiators were taking stock of Monday's dramatic events and said
there would be no talks on Tuesday.
"Nothing
will happen today," Kurdish panelist Mahmud Othman said.
"Everyone
is tired after the last week's hectic activities. It is like a holiday
today," he told AFP, adding that a scheduled assembly meeting
Tuesday was delayed.
US
Welcome
President
Talabani dismissed talk of disappointment in Washington, where
President George W. Bush was said to have exercised pressures on Iraqi
leaders to draft the code on time.
"We
are grateful to the Bush administration," said Talabani. "It
was no disappointment because we have done a lot."
Bush,
who repeatedly said the Iraqis should finish the new charter on time,
tried to play down the delay.
"Their
efforts are a tribute to democracy and an example that difficult
problems can be solved peacefully through debate, negotiation, and
compromise," he said in a statement.
His
Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice predicted Iraqis would finalize
the draft by the new deadline.
"We
are witnessing democracy at work in Iraq," she told reporters.
"They have achieved a lot and they have generated considerable
momentum toward the completion of their constitution."
The
delay, however, is seen by analysts as a blow to efforts by US
diplomats who have been shuttling between the sides in the hope that a
deal could help stabilize the war-torn country.
US
Ambassador to Iraq Zalmay Khalilzad is said to have played a key role
in the negotiations.
It
was reported that he presented a written, US-backed approach to
unresolved questions, particularly the role of Islam in determining
law and federalism.
Backfire
 |
|
"There is the impression that the United States is driving this, and that is not a good thing," said Telhami.
|
US
experts on Iraq have warned that too much US pressure on Iraqi leaders
could backfire and undermine the leadership's credibility.
Middle
East specialist Shibley Telhami said he thought the United States was
playing too big a role in helping draft the constitution and this
posed a credibility problem for the current Iraqi leaders.
"The
US ambassador there is very visible in his meetings over the
constitution. There is the impression that the United States is
driving this, and that is not a good thing," Telhami of the
Brookings Institution told Reuters.
Stephen
Zunes of the University of San Francisco said the United States was in
a difficult position.
"It's
a damned if you do and damned if you don't situation here but pushing
things prematurely can lead to a lot of unresolved issues," he
said.
But
David Phillips of the Council on Foreign Relations was pessimistic
whether progress on the constitution would make any difference in
Iraq.
"By
now I don't think that progress on the constitution will have one iota
of impact, and even if they come up with a compromise agreement,
implementing it is another story," he said.