ÚÑÈí
 

Counseling:

Ask the Scholar

|

Ask About Islam

|

Hajj & `Umrah

|

Cyber Counselor

|

Parenting Counselor

 

Search »

Advanced Search »

 

Rumsfeld Liable for War Crimes Over Torture: HRW 

Brody said soldiers at the bottom of the chain are taking the heat for torture while senior officials go “scot-free”.

CAIRO, April 24, 2005 (IslamOnline.net) – A leading US human rights watchdog on Sunday, April 24, urged President George W. Bush to name a special prosecutor to investigate the culpability of Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld and other senior officials in prisoner torture and abuse cases worldwide, particularly in Iraq and Afghanistan.

In its detailed report, “Getting Away with Torture? Command Responsibility for the US Abuse of Detainees,” Human Rights Watch said that Bush should honor his promise that the “wrongdoers will be brought to justice”.

“To date, however, the only wrongdoers being brought to justice are those at the bottom of the chain-of-command,” it maintained.

“A wall of impunity surrounds the architects of the policies responsible for the larger pattern of abuses.”

The watchdog said evidence is mounting that high-ranking US civilian and military leaders, including Rumsfeld, former CIA Director George Tenet, former US commander in Iraq Ricardo Sanchez and Major General Geoffrey Miller, the former commander of the prison camp at Guantánamo Bay, are deeply involved in crimes against humanity.

“The soldiers at the bottom of the chain are taking the heat for Abu Ghraib and torture around the world, while the guys at the top who made the policies are going scot-free,” Reed Brody, HRW special counsel, said in a press release.

The report, issued four days before the first anniversary of the publication of the Abu Ghraib photos, called for establishing a special commission, along the lines of the 9/11 Commission, to investigate the issue of prisoner abuse.

“Human Rights Watch expresses no opinion about the ultimate guilt or innocence of these or other officials, particularly because so much evidence has been withheld and so many questions remain unanswered,” it said.

“What we do conclude, a conclusion that we believe is compelled by the evidence, is that a criminal investigation is warranted with respect to each.”

The watchdog, however, stressed that can in no way assign the probe to newly-appointed Attorney General Alberto Gonzales who “was himself deeply involved in the policies leading to these alleged crimes.”

Command Responsibility

“A wall of impunity surrounds the architects of the policies responsible for the larger pattern of abuses,” Human Rights Watch concluded.

HRW called for investigating Rumsfeld “for potential liability in war crimes and torture by US troops in Afghanistan, Iraq and Guantanamo under the doctrine of ‘command responsibility’ - the legal principle that holds a superior responsible for his subordinates' actions when he knows, or should know, that crimes are being committed but fails to stop them.”

It underlined that the defense secretary approved interrogation techniques - such as the use of guard dogs to frighten prisoners and painful “stress” positions - that violated the Geneva Conventions.

Citing an investigative report by famed journalist Seymour Hersh, the report said that Rumsfeld “authorized the establishment of a highly secret program that was given blanket advance approval to kill or capture and, if possible, interrogate high value targets in the war on terror.”

HRW again criticized Rumsfeld for thumbing his nose at international law and the Geneva Conventions.

“Rumsfeld’s belittling of the Geneva Conventions created a climate in which respect for legal norms by US troops may have been loosened.”

The report quoted Rumsfeld as ridiculing the Conventions during his visit to Abu Ghraib prison on May 14, where he told American soldiers: “Geneva doesn’t say what you do when you get up in the morning”.

In the first legal action against a senior US official on the abuse of detainees, Rumsfeld is already being sued by two civil liberties groups for his “direct responsibility” in the illegal torture and prisoners' abuses.

The lawsuit was filed by the two groups on behalf of eight detainees, four Iraqis and four Afghans, who were subjected to torture, beatings, cutting with knives, assault, sexual humiliation, mock executions and other illegal treatment.

Dictatorship-Like

The report said that when a government as dominant and influential as the US openly defies laws against torture, it virtually invites others to do the same.

“The coercive methods approved by senior US officials and widely employed over the last three years include tactics that the US has repeatedly condemned as barbarity and torture when practiced by others,” it asserted.

The HRW special counsel said that Washington, in withholding evidence and papering over war criminals, has become a mirror image of “dictatorships and banana republics.”

“When their abuses are discovered—cover up the scandal and shift blame downwards,” he said.

“If there is no real accountability for these crimes, for years to come the perpetrators of atrocities around the world will point to the US’s treatment of prisoners to deflect criticism of their own conduct,” the report warned.

Widespread

The US-based rights group further cited overwhelming evidence that US mistreatment and torture of “Muslim prisoners” took place not merely at Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo but at “secret locations” worldwide.

“In many cases the abuse resulted in death or severe trauma, and that a good number of the victims were civilians with no connection to Al-Qaeda or terrorism,” it maintained.

“There is also evidence of abuse at US-controlled secret locations abroad and of US authorities sending suspects to third-country dungeons around the world where torture was likely to occur.”

The American Human Rights First charged in 2004 that Washington has more than 24 world detention camps, at least half of them operate in total secrecy, where the abuse of detainees is “inevitable”.

Earlier, The Observer accused the US and its allies of running a wanton global network of detention camps allowing Washington to fly so-called terror suspects to other countries where they are tortured for information.

Back To News Page

News Archive :
Day:   Month: Year:   

Send Mail

Related Links


News | Shari`ah | Health & Science | Politics in Depth | Reading Islam | Family | Culture | Youth | Euro-Muslims | IOL Radio

About Us | Speech of Sheikh Qaradawi | Contact Us | Advertise | Support IOL | Site Map