MELBOURNE,
December 17 (IslamOnline.net) - An Australian evangelical church was
Friday, December 17, found guilty of condoning and promoting racist
and vilifying remarks against Islam and the Muslim community in the
country, according to the ruling on an Aussie court.
Catch
the Fire Ministries, its pastor Danny Nalliah and speaker Daniel Scot
were found guilty by the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal
(VCAT) of vilifying Islam and Muslims during a seminar held in March
2002 and in several articles published in the church's newsletter,
prompting the Islamic Council of Victoria to take the case to the
court for action, the Web site News.com.au said.
Judge
Michael Higgins said Catch the Fire, Pastor Nalliah and speaker Scot
had breached section eight of the Religious and Racial Tolerance Act
by mocking at the Muslim beliefs and conduct.
“It
was done, not in the context of a serious discussion of Muslims'
religious beliefs,” Judge Higgins said.
“It
was presented in a way which is essentially hostile, demeaning and
derogatory of all Muslim people, their God, Allah, the prophet
Mohammed and in general Muslim religious beliefs and practices.”
Inciting
Hatred
The
Religious and Racial Tolerance Act says a person must not “incite
hatred against, serious contempt for or revulsion or severe ridicule
of” another person or group on the basis of religious belief or
activity.
Pastor
Scot told a seminar in 2002 that the “Muslims' Qur'an is promoting
violence, killing and looting and that Muslims were liars and
demons”.
He
further claimed that Muslims are drawing up a plan of violence and
terror to overrun the western democracies, warning that Australia
would be turned into an Islamic nation over the increasing numbers of
Muslims in the European country, according to the Web site.
“I
find that Pastor Scot's conduct was not engaged in reasonably and in
good faith for any genuine religious purpose or any purpose that is in
the public interest,” Judge Higgins said.
He
added that an article in the church's newsletter, written by Pastor
Nalliah, incited fear and hatred of Muslims, as did a third article by
a person identified as Richard, claiming that “Islam is associated
with terrorism”.
Penalties,
that could include orders for an apology or financial compensations,
would be decided early next year.
Welcome
 |
|
Aussie Muslims have been actively promoting their anti-violence stance.
|
The
court verdict was highly welcomed by the Islamic Council of Victoria
as an important step against vilification of the Muslim community in
the country.
“We
also had the support of the Catholic Church, the interfaith community
and the Uniting Church and the Jewish community. Because it was very
important that we all stood together against vilification and
understand that vilification is a tool used by extremists, and we must
always condemn extremism and vilification,” said the council's
president Yasser Soliman.
He
stressed that the court decision would grant the Muslim community the
ability to integrate more easily into the society as average
Australians.
“People
were being demonized, (being denied) the ability to get jobs, to be
friends, to be safe.
“We
had to act upon it and felt it was important to have it determined by
law.”
The
Islamic
Council of Victoria (ICV) is the umbrella organization of
Islamic societies in Victoria and their sole representative body to
Australian government and Australian community at large.
It
is a member of the Australian
Federation of Islamic Councils (AFIC) the umbrella
organization of all Islamic Councils in Australia.
Victoria's
Equal Opportunity Commission also hailed the decision, which is the
first to be heard by the VCAT since the Racial and Religious Tolerance
Act took effect in 2002.
“The
decision is very significant in terms of showing how the Act operates
in practice,” said Dr. Helen Szoke, the commission's chief
executive.
“It
demonstrates where the line is drawn between legitimate public debate
and behavior that incites hatred.”