|
UK Plans Laws Against Religious Hatred Incitement
|
|
"It
applies equally to far-right evangelical Christians as to
extremists in the Islamic faith," Blunkett
|
LONDON
, July 8
(IslamOnline.net & News Agencies) -
Britain
has unveiled
plans to put forward a legislation making it a crime to incite
religious hatred, including against Muslims.
Inciting
hatred against other races is already a crime in
Britain
but there is
no equivalent law protecting all religions, Reuters said.
A
previous bid to create such legislation after the 2001
US
attacks was
blocked by
Britain
's upper
parliamentary chamber, the House of Lords, which objected to its
status as an add-on to sweeping new anti-terrorism legislation.
"We
tried unsuccessfully to introduce an offence of incitement to
religious hatred in the aftermath of the September 11 attacks but I
hope we will now have the parliamentary backing to put this in
law," Home Secretary David Blunkett was quoted by Reuters as
saying Wednesday, July 7.
Blunkett
said the law, which will probably take more than a year to introduce
even if it does not again meet parliamentary opposition, would apply
equally to "Islamic extremists" as to those who target
Muslims.
"It
applies equally to far-right evangelical Christians as to extremists
in the Islamic faith," he added in a speech to an Institute for
Public Policy Research conference in
London
.
Blunkett
made clear that he was equally concerned about a handful among
Britain
's two million
Muslims who might exploit the nation's tradition of freedom of speech
to lash out at others.
Tough
Ride
Some
religious leaders welcomed the plan, but politicians warned it would
again face a tough ride through parliament due to civil liberties
concerns and overlaps with other laws.
"This
is a long overdue measure but nevertheless is a welcome first
step," said Iqbal Sacranie, Secretary-General of the Muslim
Council of Britain, adding that far right groups had stepped up
"virulently anti-Muslim invective" of late.
A
Jewish leader, Rabbi Jonathan Romain, said the proposal filled a
"worrying gap" by extending Muslims and Christians similar
protection to that already afforded to Jews and Sikhs under other
separate legislation.
"This
currently leaves them exposed to verbal insults, inflammatory sermons
and offensive pamphlets," he added.
But
the Islamic Human Rights Commission feared that religious minorities
could find themselves the targets of prosecutions, potentially even
from other religious groups.
"In
the light of the well-recognized institutional Islamophobic society
that we have at the moment, this legislation could very well be used
against Muslim communities, rather than protecting them," said
its chairman Massoud Shadjareh.
Threats
Labor
peer Lord Desai predicted Blunkett's idea would again have a
"very difficult time" in the Lords.
And
the opposition Conservatives accused Prime Minister Tony Blair's
government of opportunism prior to two parliamentary by-elections next
week.
Both
seats in central
England
are
traditionally solid ground for Blair's Labour Party but have big
Muslim populations so are vulnerable due to disquiet over
Iraq
.
"This
was debated after September 11th and turned out to be completely
unworkable," the Conservatives' home affairs spokesman David
Davis said of Blunkett's proposal.
"It
will impinge on civil liberties and only serve to make lawyers rich
... Perfectly adequate laws against violence or conspiracies to commit
violence already exist."
Britain
's National
Secular Society was scathing about Blunkett's plans, likening them to
medieval blasphemy laws and saying similar legislation in
Australia
had resulted
in farce.
"We
are on very dangerous territory here, and Blunkett is rushing in once
more with legislation that seeks to control thought and opinion,"
said its executive director Keith Porteous Wood.
"Not
since Tudor times is religion being given so much power to silence its
opponents."
British
Muslims, estimated at two million people, complain of recent growing
hate crimes after the September 11 attacks, which they said were
demonstrated in the stop and search incidents.
In
May 2004, British anti-terrorism
poster, depicting a pair of eyes surrounded by a black
background, and distributed across
England
and
Wales
, drew ire from leading mainstream Muslim groups.
Concern
about racial and religious hatred are linked in part to the British
National Party (BNP), an explicitly anti-immigrant group that controls
a small but notable number of local council seats in
England
.
|