 |
|
Khan accused former army chiefs of "indirectly instructing" him to proliferate nuclear secrets
|
By
Asif Farooqi, IOL Correspondent
ISLAMABAD,
February 3 (IslamOnline.net & News Agencies) - Attempts to
prosecute the disgraced father of Pakistan's nuclear program Abdul
Qadeer Khan for allegedly selling nuclear secrets could backfire by
placing the military's reported role under scrutiny, according to
analysts.
Khan
confessed in an 11-page statement at the weekend to selling nuclear
expertise to Iran, Libya and North Korea from 1988 to at least 1997,
according to the government.
The
government is now weighing up whether to prosecute Khan, one of
Pakistan's most revered national heroes, Agence France-Presse (AFP)
said.
The
government has already sacked him as special adviser on strategic
affairs.
But
analysts like Riffat Hussain, head of the Strategic Studies Department
at Islamabad's Quaid-e-Azam University, said trying Khan would open a
"Pandora's box".
"Pushed
to the wall, A.Q. Khan can spill the beans, which can complicate
matters - especially Islamabad's claims that technology leakage was
done without official sanction," Hussain said.
Tape
Khan's
daughter left Pakistan last month carrying a cassette recording of
Khan "in which he defends himself and levels charges against
certain people," The News daily reported Monday, February
2.
It
said officials were trying to retrieve the tape "fearing it might
damage the country if it fell into the hands of the anti-Pakistan
lobby."
In
his statement, Khan accused former army chiefs Aslam Beg and Jehangir
Karamat of "indirectly instructing" him to proliferate, a
senior military official told AFP.
"He
named two gentlemen, (retired) generals Beg and Karamat, who were then
questioned," the official said, requesting anonymity.
Beg,
who denied in interviews last week approving or being aware that
nuclear secrets were being sold off, was army chief from 1988 to 1991,
and Karamat was army chief until 1998.
"(Khan)
said they were in the know. In one case he said he did it on their
instructions, but not directly. They asked someone else and that
fellow instructed A.Q. Khan and that man is now dead."
The
middleman was the late brigadier Imtiaz, defense adviser to Benazir
Bhutto during her first tenure as Prime Minister from 1988 to 1990.
"There
was no evidence found of what A.Q. Khan was saying, so it could not be
sustained," the official said.
But
Beg and Karamat were questioned thoroughly, he added.
"If
there is any more evidence of involvement of anyone else they will be
questioned, no one is above the law," he said.
President
Pervez Musharraf has adamantly denied that the military or former
governments encouraged or approved the transfers of nuclear technology
and expertise, blaming civilian scientists and the world black market.
Pakistan's
military was "not at all" concerned about possible scrutiny
if Khan is put to trial, the military official said.
Officials
also insist that no proliferation occurred after 2000, when the
military established the National Command Authority (NCA) and command
and control structures to secure the country's nuclear program.
"Certainly
nothing happened after the NCA was established in 2000," a
government official said Monday.
Observers,
however, are skeptical that Khan could have proliferated so widely
without military approval.
"What
is rather clear to me is that it was not just personal profit that was
involved, nor was the action of mere individuals possible,"
Pervez Hoodbhoy, a physics professor who campaigns for nuclear
disarmament, said.
"Rather
it has to be something much deeper than that and which involved state
apparatus, because the transfer of such materials is impossible
without explicit permission from the security apparatus that
constantly surrounds the nuclear establishment, installations and
personnel," he said.
Dangerous
Limits
On
a deeper layer, the ongoing investigations into the alleged leakage
have exposed Pakistan’s otherwise reticent nuclear program out to
“dangerous” limits.
Over
the past one month, government agencies have picked up for questioning
more than a dozen scientists and engineers who have been associated
with the country's nuclear program.
Some
of them were later released but at least six members of the community
are still under what the government insists was “debriefing” of
these most senior scientists.
Khan
and some of his close associates were unceremoniously called
into debriefing sessions last month following media
reports that International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) has complained
to the Pakistani government that some of its scientists have been
found to be involved in nuclear transfer to Iran, and probably Libya.
In
a memorandum sent to Pakistan by IAEA directorate, the Agency alleged
without naming any scientists that evidence found during its
inspections in Iran has suggested that Pakistan was a source of
technology transfer to Iran during its alleged quest for nuclear
weapons development in late eighties and early nineties.
Pakistan
immediately launched an investigation into the allegations and within
days a Foreign Ministry spokesman announced that evidence was found
that some scientists had privately been involved in the nuclear
transfers in the past.
“There
are indications that some individuals might have been motivated by
personal ambitions or greed. But let me also add that we have not made
a final determination” Masood Khan, foreign office spokesman said on
December 23.
This
statement kicked off a media trial of the scientists who once had been
godly figures in the eyes and hearts of the countrymen who were told
that these scientists saved Pakistan from Indian hegemonic designs and
diverted a direct Indian threat by gifting the country with the
nuclear deterrent.
The
smear media campaign was spearheaded by the government. General
Musharraf himself said in a television interview last week that if
found guilty, these scientists would be dealt with as “national
enemies” and would reward no mercy.
Special
media reports based on selective leaks have appeared in the local
newspapers since the questioning started last month which labeled
these scientists everything from womanizers to money launderers.
A
similar report appeared in local newspapers Wednesday, January 28 said
Khan spent 50 million rupees on personal image building as head of
Pakistan’s nuclear program.
The
government claimed that these scientists acted individually and no
government institution was involved in these transactions.
The
scientists deny these allegations, accusing army officials or ordering
the leakage.
Greatest
Nuclear Threats
Pakistan’s
nuclear program has been center of controversy for many years. At
least twice it became a potential target of a military strike.
In
1991 Pakistan issued warnings to the United States and other foreign
countries that it was all prepared to launch attack on nuclear
installations in India, which the Pakistani government said was
planning a similar attack on Pakistani installations with the help of
Israel.
Similarly,
midnight of December 22, 2001, Pakistani chief of army rang up the
world capitals to tell them of a similar design by India.
Pakistan
assured of retaliation and thus was able to attract attention of the
world community and the Indian plans were thwarted.
But
many Pakistani leaders now believe that the so-called investigation
and interrogation of the nuclear scientists was the actual threat to
country’s nuclear assets.
“Pakistan’s
nuclear program faces the gravest threat ever,” Nisar Ali Khan,
Parliamentary leader of Pakistan Muslim League (N) told
IslamOnline.net.
He
said the process of investigation was being carried out to please the
Americans and other countries that are opposed to Pakistan being a
nuclear power.
Though
Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto, former Pakistani President and Prime Minister was
the founder of Pakistan's Nuclear Program, Dr. Khan is credited with
the technical development of the Bomb and hence called “father” of
the nuclear program.
'Islamic
Bomb'
Pakistan's
nuclear program was launched in earnest shortly after the loss of East
Pakistan in the 1971 war with India, when Bhutto initiated a program
to develop nuclear weapons with a meeting of physicists and engineers
at Multan in January 1972.
In
1974, India successfully tested a nuclear "device". Bhutto
reacted strongly to this test and said Pakistan must develop its own
"Islamic bomb".
Pakistan
lacks an extensive civil nuclear power infrastructure, and its weapons
program is not as broad as India's. Much of its nuclear program is
focused on weapons applications.
Initially,
Pakistan focused on the plutonium path for building a nuclear weapon.
Plutonium can be obtained from fuel that has been reprocessed from
nuclear power plants, and in October 1974, Pakistan signed a contract
with France for the design of a reprocessing facility for the fuel
from its power plant at Karachi and other planned facilities.
However,
over the next two years Pakistan's international nuclear collaborators
withdrew as Pakistan's nuclear ambitions became more apparent. The
French were among the last to withdraw at the end of 1976, following
sustained pressure from the United States.
A
major advance jump to Pakistan's nuclear program was the arrival of
Dr. Khan in 1975, who brought with him the plans for uranium
enrichment centrifuges, and lists of sources of the necessary
technology.
On
this basis, Pakistan initially focused its development efforts on
highly enriched uranium (HEU), and exploited an extensive clandestine
procurement network to support these efforts.
Khan
evidently persuaded Pakistan to work with Uranium (as compared to
Plutonium) because Plutonium involves more arduous and hazardous
procedures and cumbersome and expensive processes.
Pakistan's
activities were initially centered in a few facilities. Khan founded
the Engineering Research Laboratories at Kahuta in 1976, which later
to became the Dr. A. Q. Khan Research Laboratories (KRL).
Click
Here To Read Detailed Chronology of Pakistan's Nuclear Development