Despite
Muslims drive to strike a compromise, the French government gave a
mixed signal, saying the ban could also force Muslim men to shave
their beards.
French
Education Minister Luc Ferry was quoted by the BBC as saying that the
law, which will be debated in parliament next month, could ban hijabs,
bandannas and beards if they are considered a sign of faith.
Ferry
told a National Assembly legal committee hearing about the draft law
that the definition of a religious symbol in the proposed law was
broad so that pupils could not bypass it simply by deviating from a
list of proscribed items.
Some
Muslim girls use bandannas to cover their hair as an alternative to
the traditional hijab, feeling it is easier to blend in to the crowd.
Asked
about beards, as worn by many Muslims, Ferry said: "As soon as it
becomes a religious sign and the code is apparent, it would fall under
this law".
Growing
beards is a great Sunnah of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH).
However,
Muslims differed regarding its ruling some of them state that it is
mandatory and shaving it is forbidden while others view that it is an
optional Sunnah and hence there is no harm in shaving it.
Jacques
Myard, an MP from Chirac's ruling party, told the BBC that beards
would not be an issue in schools.
"Beards
are not at stake because we have young boys and they don't have
beards," he was quoted by the BBC News Online as saying.
"This
is more a question of discipline than any religious or political
affair but I would say today that we are not facing a religious
approach with the Muslims.
French
opposition Socialists have described the proposals as misguided and
unclear.
"This
is putting a comic face on a very serious issue," Socialist
deputy Julien Dray was quoted by the BBC News Online as saying.
The
minister said Sikhs were not permitted by their religion to cut their
hair, and suggested that they could wear caps.
But
he said ordinary headbands, which he described as "invisible
turbans", were preferable to traditional headgear.