KUALA
LUMPUR, December 23 (IslamOnline.net) - The U.S. criticism against
Malaysia on religious freedom is still making waves in the country
with high officials saying they will lodge an official protest against
the super power if the fifth annual International Religious Freedom
Report released by the Department of State was to affect Malaysia's
image and world standing, news agencies reported Tuesday, December 23.
"Malaysia
will lodge an official protest against the United States but would
first hold discussions with the U.S. Embassy to seek an explanation
over the report," which was released last Thursday, Malaysian
Foreign Minister Seri Syed Hamid Albar, was quoted by the official
Bernama news agency as saying Tuesday.
"We'll
wait until we've read the full report. If we were to find that it
projects a situation which is totally untrue and completely baseless,
we'll submit a protest note.
"We're
raising objections because we're not happy over the move to come up
with a report in such a way which could tarnish the image of our
country and erode confidence towards our country," he told
reporters after attending the district's Hari Raya gathering.
This
is not the first time that the U.S. state department on religious
freedom touched negatively on Malaysia. In 2002, a similar report
lambasted Malaysia for preventing Muslims from changing faith.
The
report stirred debates in the country on apostates and further divided
the supporters of the government and the opposition on the issue.
"We
want to hear their side of the story. We wish to find out the criteria
they've applied in coming up with the report," the Minsiter
added.
The
Minister further maintained that the report also had an implication on
the country's security pertaining to the multi-religious aspects of
the people in the country.
The
report identified Malaysia as among the nine countries with laws or
policies that favor certain religions and place others at a
disadvantage. It claims that such policies have led to the curtailment
of religious freedom.
Syed
Hamid said that Malaysia had come a long way compared with some
Western countries in terms of religious freedom including permission
to set up schools by practitioners of the various faiths.
Western
countries, he said, not only disallow headscarves to be worn in
schools but also revoke citizenship of Muslims and enforce various
laws which discriminate against them.
"In
Malaysia, you can wear anything as long as you take into account the
sensitivities of the other religions," he said.
The Minister added that in obtaining input, the views of the
government should also be sought to ensure that it was a balanced
report.
He
went on to explain that Malaysians could experience and outsiders
witness for themselves the freedom of worship in the country.
Malaysians are free to practice their diverse religions, though Islam
is the main force in the country.
A
large chunk of the country's population of 25 million are of Muslim
faith, which amounts to 60 or 65 percent according to recent census
figures.
Asked
whether the report would strain ties between Kuala Lumpur and
Washington, Syed Hamid, however, expressed confidence that relations
would not be affected and would remain normal.
On
Malaysia, the report said "Islam is the official religion
although the constitution provides for freedom of religion.
"Non-Muslim
religious minorities generally worship freely although with some
restrictions, such as construction of places of worship and new
cemeteries."
The
report alleged that the government monitored the activities of the
Shiite minority and claimed the right to detain members of what it
considers Islamic "deviant sects", i.e. groups that do not
follow the official Sunni teachings.
The
report is mandated by Congress and may affect U.S. aid or relationship
with that country if there were no improvement.
Meanwhile,
a statement posted on the website of the State Department said that
the report does not criticize the amount of religious diversity in
Malaysia or a lack of interaction among the many faiths found in the
country, as reported by some media.
At
the same time, a report released by the Bureau of Democracy, Human
Rights and Labor, among others, said that the Malaysian constitution
provides for freedom of religion, however the government places some
restrictions on this right and although Islam is the official
religion, the practice of Islamic beliefs other than Sunni Islam is
restricted significantly.
This
U.S. report, which was carried by the local media, was widely
criticized by Malaysian politicians, religious groups and community
leaders.
"The
full text of the executive summary of the 2003 U.S. State Department
International Religious Freedom Report and the specific report on
Malaysia are being made available on this website to allow everyone to
read the report and make their own judgments," said the
statement.
The
report is an annual Congressional required report that discusses
religious freedom in every nation.