ROME,
October 26 (IslamOnline.net & News Agencies) - An Italian court
order a kindergarten to take off all crucifixes from classrooms at the
request of a Muslim activist, sparking shock waves in the traditionally
Roman Catholic country.
Adel
Smith, a 43-year-old Italian-Egyptian convert who runs a group called
the Union of Muslims in Italy, secured Thursday a ruling from a court in
the central town of L'Aquila ordering the school to remove all
crucifixes from the walls of a playschool attended by his son, Agence
France-Presse (AFP) reported Sunday, October 26.
"The
presence of the symbol of the cross ...shows the will of the State in
the case of state-run schools to put the Catholic religion at the centre
of the universe as though it were an absolute truth, without the
slightest respect for the role played by other religious and social
phenomena in the development of humanity," read the court verdict.
Smith,
brought up in Egypt of an Italian father and an Egyptian mother,
initially suggested that a symbol from the holy Qur’an should be
displayed alongside the crucifix in his children's classrooms.
When
the school adamantly denied his request, the Muslim activist took the
issue to court.
Smith,
a printer to trade, converted to Islam in 1987.
Two
years ago he set up the Union of Muslims in Italy which now claims a
membership of 5,300 mainly converts.
Furor
However,
the decision triggered an uproar and re-opened a heated debate about
religious symbols.
"You
cannot eliminate a symbol of a nation's religious and cultural values
simply because it offends someone," the Corriere della Sera
newspaper quoted Cardinal Ersilio Tonini as saying.
"A
decision like this will encourage a form of intolerance towards symbols
of Christian faith," warned Rino Fisichella, deputy chairman of the
Italian bishops' conference.
"We
await the reasons for this decision and we will react firmly," he
told la Repubblica.
The
decision could cause ructions between Catholics and atheists, and also
between Christians generally and Muslims, warned the newspaper.
The
Italian press has compared the affair to controversy in France over the
wearing of Muslim hijab in schools.
The
ruling could also provide a legal precedent highlighting relations
between Church and State in Italy, where Catholicism is the state
religion and there is no separation between Church and State as in
France.
Two
laws dating from 1924 and 1927 and still in force authorize the presence
in schools of Catholic religious symbols.
It
has never been repealed - although the presence of crucifixes in
classrooms is left to individual head teachers, BBC said.
Last
month, Education Minister Letizia Moratti said the cross should remain
in state schools and hospitals.
She
also endorsed controversial funding for Catholic schools.
Fisichella
recalled that a ruling by Germany's Federal Court ordering the removal
of Christian symbols from public places "had the whole of (mainly
Catholic) Bavaria out on the streets."
The
court ruling was, however, welcomed by one teacher's union, saying it
was a reinforcement of the secular character of the education system.