The
State Department said earlier this year in its report on global
religious practices that there was no freedom of religion in the
kingdom, but Secretary of State Colin Powell decided not to add the
country to the U.S. religious freedom blacklist.
In
its annual report, the congressionally mandated watchdog, set up to
provide policy advice to the U.S. government, described the decision
as a mistake and called on the White House to address the spread of
Wahhabism in the kingdom, Agence France-Presse (AFP) said.
"The
U.S. government should designate Saudi Arabia a 'country of particular
concern' under the International Religious Freedom Act of 1998,"
the report said.
It
also urged top officials to determine whether "the Saudis are
directly or indirectly funding efforts to propagate globally,
including in the United States, a religious ideology that explicitly
promotes hate, intolerance, and other human rights violations, and in
some cases violence toward members of other religious groups."
President
Bush, speaking at the Indiana State Fairgrounds Tuesday, denounced the
attacks, and said it was the work of "killers whose only faith is
hate."
The
report was issued as Powell visited Saudi Arabia shortly before the
blasts, as the State Department has always been seen as favoring
private diplomacy over public confrontation with Saudi officials.
Some
officials in the State Department say it would be better to work
behind the scenes with the Saudis and give them a chance to improve
their record before designating them a country of concern.
"The
behind-the-scenes approach is practical, reasonable ways for moving
forward," one State Department official said.
Such
steps could include a project to revise Saudi textbooks or encourage
the Saudi government to furnish unadorned buildings for non-Muslim
religions, he added.
Exploited
Meanwhile,
the Christian Science Monitor said that the well-coordinated
bomb attacks in Saudi Arabia - the worst against Americans since 9/11
- are also believed to be a new attempt by terrorists to exploit
tensions between the United States and a key ally in the Middle East.
"That
was no accident - striking Americans in the heart of Saudi
Arabia," says Jean-Francois Seznec, an expert on Saudi Arabia at
Columbia University in New York, told the Monitor.
"Al-Qaeda
is sending a message to the Americans and to the Saudis. Even though
the military may leave, Americans are still too strong in the kingdom.
[Al-Qaeda] wants all links severed," he added.
Just
investigating who was behind the attack could exacerbate tensions
between Washington and Riyadh. Because American civilians were killed
in this attack, there will be pressure on the U.S. to manage the probe
and punish the culprits. And that may be hard for the Saudis to deal
with at home, the Monitor said
That
caused the U.S. to recalibrate its troop placements inside Saudi
Arabia. Moreover, the investigation that followed - carried out by the
FBI in tandem with the Saudis - resulted in a higher degree of tension
between the U.S and Saudi Arabia.
One
of the companies targeted in this latest attack, for example, is
Vinnell Corp., which trains the Saudi National Guard that is
controlled by Saudi Arabia's Crown Prince Abdullah.
"Particular
Concern"
The
watchdog also expressed concern over the rights of believers in
Russia, Vietnam, China, North Korea, Laos, Sudan and Belarus.
The
commission called on top American officials to ensure that freedom of
worship was respected in Afghanistan as the reconstruction process
grinds on.
Regarding
Russia, the commission urged the Bush government to explain to Moscow
that its efforts to combat terrorism should not be used as an excuse
to restrict the rights, including that of religious freedom, to ethnic
minorities.
It
also referred to a report cited by Russian newspaper Gazeta,
allegedly co-authored by Minister for National Affairs Vladimir Zorin
which purportedly warned of threats to Russian security from groups
such as the Roman Catholic church, Protestant groups and Islamic
groups.
"Though
welcoming the assurances from Russian government officials that the
so-called 'Zorin report' does not reflect government policy, the U.S.
government should continue to press the Russian government to ensure
that the views expressed in the leaked report are not adopted as
Russian government policy," the commission said.
In
Vietnam, the report called on the U.S. government to make clear to
Hanoi that an improved performance on religious toleration was
essential if its relations with Washington were to broaden.
A
list of actions Vietnam should be told to take was appended, including
the halt to surveillance and bans on religious meetings for ethnic
minorities, including those in the restive Central Highlands region.
It
also called on the State Department to designate Vietnam a country of
"particular concern" under U.S. law.
The
Belarus government should also face stiff U.S. pressure over human
rights, the report said, calling on U.S. officials to make clear they
favored genuine movements towards democracy and protection of
religious rights.
The
U.S. commission warned that it was "seriously concerned about
U.S. policies in Afghanistan and their impact on Afghanistan's
future."
"There
are indications that Afghanistan is being reconstructed -- without
serious U.S. opposition -- as a state in which an extreme
interpretation of Sharia would be enforced by the government which the
United States supports and with which our nation is closely
identified."
It
also called on Washington to call for the expansion of the
International Security Assistance force beyond Kabul and its environs
and to ensure that the country's fledgling new security forces screen
would be applicants to exclude past human rights violators.
The
commission also asked the U.S. government to pressure China, Laos and
Sudan among other nations to halt repression against believers in
religious freedom and bemoaned the complete lack of religious freedom
in Stalinist North Korea.