NEW
DELHI, December 11 (IslamOnline) - There are growing apprehensions in
India now about an imminent international intervention in the Kashmir
issue. The stage is already set for such an intervention with the
proposed visit of former U.S. president Jimmy Carter to India and
Pakistan some time next year.
Carter’s
planned visit was disclosed by Srinagar-based daily Greater Kashmir
Tuesday, December 10.
Carter
is famous for his successful diplomatic initiatives in some of the
crisis spots around the world. Credit for the Camp David accord which
ultimately thawed relations between Egypt and Israel goes to Carter. The
United Nations had appointed Carter as the roving ambassador for peace
in war-torn nations. He was awarded the Nobel Prize for Peace Tuesday.
According
to the report, former Pakistani army chief Jahangir Karamat, India’s
Kashmir Committee chairman and former law minister Ram Jethmalani and
U.S.-based Kashmiri businessman Farooq Kathwari are the prominent
figures behind the Carter mission. “A consolidated report containing
suggestions would be placed before Washington, Islamabad and New
Delhi,” the Greater Kashmir report said.
The
report claimed that U.S. experts favor an independent Kashmir and that
ceaseless moves are afoot in this regard.
Robert
D Blackwill, U.S. ambassador to India, visited the state of Jammu and
Kashmir December 2. The visit which followed on the heels of the
recently-concluded elections assumed a great significance in Delhi
political circles.
“Kathwari
‘secretly visited Kashmir’ along with Blackwill,” the report
claimed. It was significant that Blackwill chose not to meet Hurriyat
Conference leaders this time round.
Blackwill
is better known for his strong advocacy of an independent Kashmir. He is
also believed to enjoy immense clout in the U.S. administration.
The
report failed to say whether Carter’s initiative was being backed by
the Bush administration. In the absence of a clear hint about Bush
administration’s blessings to Carter’s endeavor, the report said,
“Carter is convinced that the nuclear-capable troubled area needs his
attention.
Carter’s
relationship with the White House has been quite adverse on domestic
issues and Middle East policies.” Driven by his penchant for
undertaking initiatives in trouble-prone areas, Carter has decided to
visit the Subcontinent, the report said.
In
its report, the Pakistan-based Weekly Independent observed that
“either Carter is taking up the mission on his own or the Bush
administration has asked for his help,” adding that “either way, it
suits the Bush administration’s agenda and State Department’s
diplomatic help may be forthcoming.”
For
quite sometime now, Jimmy Carter had been taking keen interest in the
Kashmir issue. Carter Center held a seminar at Washington recently in
which several scholars and retired diplomats presented their viewpoints
for resolving the Kashmir issue. Salman Haider, former Indian foreign
secretary, Usman Ahmed, a prominent U.S.-based JKLF leader, and Hasan
Abbas, a South Asian expert from Pakistan, were major participants from
the Subcontinent.
Making
his presentation, Haider talked about the official line of the Indian
government while referring to “cross-border terrorism”. “If
cross-border terrorism was eliminated Kashmir will be a peaceful state
within India,” he said.
“General
Pervez Musharraf did not control jihadi outfits and would not be
able to stop infiltration,” Pakistani experts felt. “In order to
control the militant outfits Pakistan needed more time on the part of
India. However, if appropriate measures were not taken, India and
Pakistan faced a bigger chaos and prospects of disintegration,” they
argued.
JKLF
representative, Usman Ahmed, reiterated his organization’s stand, and
went on to accuse both India and Pakistan of derailing a solution in
order to suit their own ends. “Both India and Pakistan have been
duplicitous about Kashmir,” he claimed.
“Neither
India nor Pakistan would give up their respective positions, and so the
only solution is to establish a process by which Kashmir emerges as an
independent state,” the JKLF representative said. Most American
experts supported his views, the report claimed.
“Many
American experts have been working on devising such a mechanism which
can disentangle India and Pakistan establishing an enduring peace in the
region.
Most
American experts do not believe that the U.N. resolutions are relevant
any more or that they can yield any solution. For starters, Americans do
not trust any international law and maintain that solutions to the
international problems can be enforced by the U.S. and not by the
U.N.,” said the Weekly Independent report.
To
give fillip to his idea of an independent state out of the
Muslim-majority areas of Jammu and Kashmir, Kathwari had presented a
report on behalf of his Kashmir Study Group (KSG) in February 2000.
Interestingly, the KSG report, ‘Kashmir A Way Forward’, received
support from prominent American experts.
The
report specified five proposals for the creation of a sovereign
Muslim-majority Kashmir with its own constitution, citizenship, flag and
a legislature which would deal with all matters except defense and
foreign affairs.
On
the face of it, in the earlier greater autonomy proposal for Jammu and
Kashmir, the Indian government had outlined similar provisions wherein
it would have control over currency, foreign affairs and defense matters
for an autonomous Jammu and Kashmir. Despite assurances, the federal
government, however, has so far refused to even discuss autonomy of the
state.
New
Delhi sees the Kashmir issue as a bilateral one between India and
Pakistan. It has always advocated that the issue should be sorted out
only after negotiations between the two countries alone without the
intervention of any third party.
India
recently declined to attend a summit of South Asian Association for
Regional Cooperation (SAARC) scheduled to be held in Pakistan. The
government had continuously objected to Pakistan on several occasions
for raking up the Kashmir issue at various international conferences and
the United Nations, rather than sorting out the issues between
themselves