ÚÑÈí
 

Counseling:

Ask the Scholar

|

Ask About Islam

|

Hajj & `Umrah

|

Cyber Counselor

|

Parenting Counselor

 

Search »

Advanced Search »

 

An Alternative Perspective on Sept. 11 by India’s Ace Photographer

Union Carbide plant in Bhopal

By IOL South Asia Correspondent

NEW DELHI, Sept 14 (IslamOnline) - As the world was busy commemorating the devastating attacks of September 11, India’s ace photographer Raghu Rai mounted an exhibition of some of the most stunning images of mass death, not in New York or Washington, but in Bhopal (central India).

As another exhibition of some of the most dramatic photographs of September 11 attack by celebrated American photographers was on somewhere else in New Delhi, Rai opened his exhibition of photographs of Bhopal gas disaster of December 3, 1984.

On that fateful night, 40 tons of lethal methyl isocyanate (MIC) gas leaked out of the (American) Union Carbide pesticide factory in Bhopal, killing 20,000 people and poisoning half a million others.

In stark, black and white images of “burial of unknown children, mass cremations, aborted foetuses, cluttered hospitals,” Rai brings out the enormity of the crime of Union Carbide and the scale of the tragedy that was far bigger than the September 11 attacks.

One of the photographs in the exhibition shows women carrying placards announcing “You want Osama, give us Anderson.” When pointed out that the exhibition might detract from the September 11 events, Rai explains, “What happened in New York is a universal tragedy, but the world is full of too much suffering to contain just one dominating tragedy.”

Some of the thousands of people struck by the gas leak

Rai says we must all join in search for Osama and bring him to justice. “But will America deliver to the victims of Bhopal, Warren Anderson, at the time Union Carbide’s CEO against whom the Bhopal court of justice issued a warrant for culpable homicide?.” Anderson, an American citizen, is at large. Reportedly he is hiding somewhere in, out of all places, New York

Last year, America’s Dow Chemicals bought Union Carbide, merging the two companies. Dow-Carbide has not shown any interest in the Bhopal gas tragedy, the greatest industrial disaster of history. This is in sharp contrast to Dow’s acceptance of Union Carbide’s liabilities in Texas, where they recently settled an asbestos-related lawsuit.

Large, multinational companies like Dow-Carbide have a dual system of work, under which they respect labour and environment laws in the West but are indifferent to such laws in the Third World.

The current exhibition, commissioned by Greenpeace, provides insight into the devastation wrought on ordinary people for no fault of their own. “What I saw was to change my life,” says Rai, winner of some of the highest international awards in photography.

“It was an unprecedented scene of chaos. What startled me was the silence of death,” reminisces Rai, once the chief photographer of India’s premier newsmagazine India Today.

“Thousands of people had already died; thousands more than died in 11 September attack on the World Trade Centre,” Rai says. He is concerned over the multinational corporations shirking responsibility for people hurt in the Third World because of their practices.

Masked protesters holding posters demanding repatriation of Carbide chahirman Anderson

“I vowed then and there to work to show the world what happens when corporations are not held liable for their operations, when they are allowed to cut costs and safety standards when they operate abroad,” Rai says.

Rai’s photographs were earlier launched as a touring exhibition by Greenpeace in Cape Town, South Africa in August to coincide with the Earth Summit “to urge governments to commit to an international agreement on corporate accountability and liability to stem the tide of corporate environmental abuses.”

The South African exhibition was supported by a Greenpeace report which compiled cases of corporate crime from various industrial sectors, including the chemical, forest, mining, genetic engineering, nuclear and oil industries from different parts of the world.

Greenpeace is working in India with a coalition of NGOs called Action Against Corporate Crime and Toxic Terror. Rai has for the last several years been associated with Magnum, an international agency specializing in documentary and reportage photography.

 

Yesterday's News

Search Articles 

 

 

News Archive :
Day:   Month: Year:   


Send Mail

News | Shari`ah | Health & Science | Politics in Depth | Reading Islam | Family | Culture | Youth | Euro-Muslims | IOL Radio

About Us | Speech of Sheikh Qaradawi | Contact Us | Advertise | Support IOL | Site Map