With
additional reporting by Neveen A. Salem, IOL Washington D.C.
WASHINGTON
D.C., Sept 14 (IslamOnline & News Agencies) - A U.S. district judge
handed a victory to a U.S.-based Muslim charity Friday, tossing out
perjury charges against Benevolence International Foundation (BIF) and
its director Enaam Arnaout.
The
ruling, handed down Friday by Judge Joan Gottschall, paves the way for
Arnaout, 39, to be released Monday after four months in custody.
Arnaout
has been held without bond since he was arrested April 30 at his home in
suburban Chicago on charges that he allegedly lied about his
organization’s ties to military groups, including Al-Qa’eda and the
Chechen mujahedin.
However,
Patrick Fitzgerald, the U.S. attorney for the Northern District of
Illinois, said he would seek to keep Arnaout behind bars by filing
charges of obstruction of justice and making false statements prior to a
hearing Monday.
Fitzgerald
filed the new criminal complaint late Friday night, news Agencies
reported.
As
for Judge Gottschall's decision, Fitzgerald, said "we respectfully
disagree with the judge's ruling. The opinion relies on a technical
interpretation of the perjury statute and has no bearing on the facts of
the case."
The
charges are a technicality: federal prosecutors were afraid that Arnaout
would flee the country before they could build a case against him and
BIF for allegedly funneling charitable donations to militants overseas.
American
Muslim and civil rights activists assert that the charges against
Benevolence Foundation, and other American Muslim charities, are nothing
more than the latest arsenal in the U.S.’s “witch-hunt” of
American Muslims.
"This
is definitely another witch-hunt," Shaker Al Sayed of the Muslim
American Society [MAS] told IslamOnline in the early days of the
investigation.
"The
established facts are that in the past several months the U.S.
Department of Justice [DOJ] has arrested or detained thousands of
Muslims, and in the end charged no one with any crimes.
"The
maximum was charging one person with knowing one of the hijackers of
September 11. And even that charge was thrown out of court by the judge
for government misconduct," El Sayed continued, referring to Judge
Shira A. Scheindlin's ruling earlier this year that the Justice
Department has "overreached in imprisoning as 'material witnesses'
men the authorities believe might have information for grand juries
investigating terrorism."
U.S.
authorities raided BIF offices in Palos Hills, Illinois in December last
year and froze the charity's assets as part of its post September 11
clampdown on U.S.-based Muslim charities it suspected of channeling
money to so called “militants”.
BIF
sued to have the block on their assets frozen in January 2002, and when
Arnaout later indicated he intended to travel to Saudi Arabia, federal
prosecutors stepped in and filed perjury charges, alleging he lied in
court filings submitted as part of that lawsuit.
Arnaout
has repeatedly asserted that the foundation "never provided
meaningful support for organizations engaged in violence, terrorist
activities or military operations of any nature," in a sworn
affidavit filed as part of the civil suit the charity has brought
against U.S. authorities.
Neither
Armout nor his lawyers have been available for comment.