WASHINGTON,
June 19 (IslamOnline) - After a number of recent editorials
questioning the decision of Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI)
director Robert Mueller to speak at the upcoming American Muslim
Council (AMC) conference, Council officials are responding to what
they call a smear campaign against their organization.
“What
we hope is that people who really see this crusade against AMC and
character assassination of whoever is associated with AMC [will] stand
up and say what they know about us,” said board member Abdurahman
Alamoudi. “Because if today it’s AMC, tomorrow it will be somebody
else.”
One
of the editorials, written for U.S. daily newspaper, the New
York Post, on Tuesday, June 17, by Middle East Forum director
Daniel Pipes, decries the “blunder” that Mueller would be making
by agreeing to speak at AMC’s annual convention, set for June 28.
“Far
from being ‘the most mainstream Muslim group in the United
States,’ the AMC is among their most extreme,” Pipes, a
self-declared Middle East expert who is widely seen in the American
Muslim community as anti-Islam, says in his article.
“Rather
than endorse AMC by his presence, Robert Mueller should find other
lunch companions next Friday. Then he should put the organization
under surveillance, ascertain its funding sources, look over its
books, and check its staff’s visa status.”
Pipes
accuses AMC of apologizing for terrorists, and even suggests ties to
“other terrorists” including a well-respected scholar, Jamal
Barzinji, vice president of the International Institute for Islamic
Thought, whose home and organization were raided by the federal
government in March.
He
also accuses the group of “hostility to law enforcement” - because
its website links to a page advising Muslims not to talk to the FBI
without a lawyer present - and “hostility to the United States,’
because of a statement made by a speaker at an AMC event.
Another
editorial, written by Matt Continetti as a guest commentary for the National
Review Online on June 12, also accused AMC of having
sympathy for terrorism, and criticized Mueller’s speaking engagement
as a mistake.
"Mueller’s
appearance is yet another example of how the Bush administration, in
its attempt to assuage fear and anger in the Muslim-American
community, works with groups that sympathize with Islamic
extremism,” Continetti said.
“Though
the American Muslim Council publicly denies support of suicide
bombings and other terrorist operations, and is one of the few Muslim
lobby organizations to support last year’s bombing of Afghanistan,
it nevertheless has a history of sympathy and support for radical
Islam, as terrorism expert Steven Emerson reveals in American
Jihad.”
Emerson’s
book American Jihad was released in February of this
year; he is highly regarded, and disregarded, by many in Congress for
his purported “knowledge” of terrorist groups, but is denounced by
Muslims across the country for his part in associating Islam with
terrorism over the years.
And
in the Washington Times on Tuesday editorial writer
Frank J. Gaffney, Jr., calls the FBI’s labeling of AMC as a
mainstream group an “intelligence failure.”
Gaffney
quotes Emerson generously in his article in reference to AMC’s
supposed support for terrorism and says that “confusing
organizations like the AMC with mainstream Muslims - let alone
dignifying the former by affording them repeated access not only to
the FBI director but to the president and his Cabinet - serves to
legitimate the radicals while disenfranchising those who genuinely
adhere to moderate Islamic teachings.”
Alamoudi,
who is lambasted in the first two editorials as an unabashed supporter
of terrorism, said that people like Pipes are setting the idea of
exactly who fits the description of “moderate Muslim”.
“Daniel
Pipes is livid because anybody who speaks about Islam and doesn’t
speak about Daniel Pipes’ Islam is on the wrong side,” he said,
adding that “Daniel Pipes’ Islam is [that] we have to sit in our
mosques and pray, and when we go out, we have to behave like
non-Muslims.”
Alamoudi
believes that Pipes seems to want to quell any kind of Muslim
activism.
“Very
unfortunately we are all in his eyes like people who carry guns,” he
said. “I don’t know why he has this hatred of activist Muslims.”
He
defended his own record of “asking Muslims to be in the system,”
and had words of praise for Mueller for keeping the speaking
engagement.
“We
are grateful at least that Director Mueller is sticking to his
commitment,” he said. “I am very pleased that at least there are
some people who are in the administration who call people by their
names - yes, the American Muslim Council, whether Pipes [likes it] or
not, we are a mainstream organization, and we are the senior
mainstream [Muslim] political organization in Washington, D.C.”
In
response to what AMC has called a “smear campaign,” AMC Executive
Director Eric Erfan Vickers will be appearing on MSNBC’s Alan Keys
show Tuesday night and on Wednesday, June 19, on FoxNews Live with
Linda Wester, according to a press release by the organization.
On
the air, Vickers will talk about the “smear campaign” and the
forthcoming convention at which Mueller is scheduled to speak about
cooperation in the war against terrorism.