With
additional reporting by Hamdi El-Husseiny, IOL Cairo correspondent
CAIRO,
June 3 (IslamOnline & News Agencies) - Egyptian Parliament adopted
Monday, June 3, a law regulating the activities of non-governmental
organizations (NGOs) despite strong objections from human rights groups.
The
law, which Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak was expected to ratify, was
supported by 419 of the 454 members of the lower house of parliament,
Agence France-Presse (AFP) reporter in parliament said.
Human
rights activists said they were preparing a memorandum urging Mubarak
not to ratify this law. This would replace a law three years ago that
was thrown out by the high constitutional court after it failed, as
required, to pass first through the upper house of parliament, the Shura
Council. The new bill cleared the Shura Council late last month.
“This
law seeks to impose the hegemony of executive power on civil society,”
charged Hafez Abu Saada, secretary general of the Egyptian Organization
of Human Rights.
Saada
said earlier “he draft is worse than the previous law, because it
allows the minister to dissolve an NGO by a simple administrative
decision, without resorting to the courts.”
Twenty-eight
members voted against the bill: six from the Marxist party Tagamu, four
from the liberal Wafd party, and 18 independent MPs, including 12 who
are backed by the banned but partially tolerated Muslim Brotherhood.
Seven
independent members of parliament, including five backed by the Muslim
Brotherhood, abstained from voting, AFP said.
Human
rights groups in Egypt and abroad have opposed the legislation seeking
to regulate the activities, financing and status of NGOs, which include
human rights groups.
They
charge it gives the government a free hand to dissolve organizations
without resorting to the courts.
Activists
are bothered by the legislation’s provision for “the Minister of
Social Affairs to dissolve an NGO” if its article 17 is not respected.
An amendment said the NGO concerned and the NGO union would have to be
heard first.
“We
are against any imposed governmental or security restrictions on the
NGOs, and in case of any regulations, it is the court that should decide
what to be done,” said Diaa ElDin Daowd, head of the Nasserite party.
Dissolving
NGOs with administrative decisions, however, is totally unaccepted and
contradicts any democratic headings in this society, he added.
Abdel
Aziz Hegazy, former Egyptian prime minister and head of the union of
NGOs, said the union did not receive any information regarding this law
from the parliament or the government.
“We
demanded a copy of the law, so we can discuss it and prepare a memo
about our position regarding this law,” he added.
“I
suggested that the article of dissolving NGOs be cancelled,” said
Fahmi Ashid, Shura member. If the law was implemented with its current
status, it will be contested because it will be an unconstitutional move
that will take the country back to the past, he added.
On
the other side, Mamdouh Nakhla, head of human rights center, Kalema,
says that although that there are disreputable articles in the law, it
tackles bold issues no one spoke about them in Egypt before.
“To
implement the NGO, you only need to inform the Ministry of Social
Affairs, and if no reply was issued during a 60 days period, the NGO can
start functioning immediately,” he added.
Tahani
El-Gibali, human rights activists and a member in the Arab lawyers
union, said that it is very obvious the government is insisting this
time on passing the law regardless of fundamental defects.
According
to the law, the regional NGO that is taking Egypt as a headquarter, will
be required to have the approvals of the Ministry of Social Affairs and
that of the Ministry of the Foreign affairs, which will add more
bureaucracy to the issue.
“We
still have hopes that the parliament will be able to cleanse the new law
from the articles everyone rejects,” she added