By
Zafarul-Islam Khan
IOL
South Asia correspondent
NEW
DELHI, Feb. 28 (IslamOnline) - New evidence says that Muslims were not involved
in yesterday's train attack. Rather, the attackers were Hindu people from the
washermen (dhobi) community whose women were mistreated by the so-called
"volunteers". The media kept claiming that the attackers were
"Muslims". This led to communal flare-ups in various parts of the
state of Gujarat where the train incident took place.
The
Indian government finally issued orders yesterday to state governments to stop
the convergence of Hindu fanatics in the town of Ayodhya. It ordered local
authorities in the town to prevent the transportation of building materials to
the site where fanatics want to start building a temple on March 15.
In
a communication to the state government, the central home ministry has now asked
the authorities to stop group reservation in trains and come down heavily on
travelers without tickets. Temple extremists are known to travel without
tickets, taking over reserved seats and misbehaving with other travelers. A ban
has been imposed on the movement of stone pillars and other construction
materials by VHP activists to Ayodhya.
This
change of heart came because of the tragic train incident yesterday, in which 57
"volunteers" of the temple movement have been killed.
All
opposition parties, including several partners of the ruling National Democratic
Alliance (NDA), have expressed doubts over the BJP-led central government's
assurance that it will maintain status quo on the Babri Masjid issue in
Ayodhya.
After
vacillating for two long months while Hindu extremists made open preparations to
start building a "Ram Temple", the Vajpayee government at the Center
had finally called an all party meting on Ayodhya issue on February 26. It
promised in this meeting that it would not allow any alteration in the existing
situation at the disputed site. Even Home Minister LK Advani, who led the
Ayodhya movement and presided over the demolition of the Babri, has warned that
strict action would be taken against those who take the law into their own
hands. In a statement on February 26, Advani said VHP president Ashok Singhal
has embarked on a course of action that is "fraught with dangerous
consequences".
The
all party meeting was called amidst increasing signals that the rightist
fundamentalist Hindu outfits are again trying to rouse communal sentiments in
the already charged atmosphere in the country. The frenzy got momentum after the
BJP route in Uttar Pradesh and three other states in the just concluded
legislative assembly elections.
The
opposition had blocked the proceedings in both the houses of Parliament, Lok
Sabha and the Rajya Sabha on February 26. It demanded a full-fledged discussion
on the Vishwa Hindu Parishad's announcement to start the construction of Ram
temple on March 15 at the site where Babri Masjid stood for centuries. The
mosque was demolished by a frenzied Hindu mob led by the BJP on December 6,
1992.
Agitated
members of Parliament as well as some of the ruling alliance partners demanded
that the government provide details about the steps taken in Ayodhya to maintain
law and order. About 15 thousand fanatic Hindus have already arrived in the town
and the VHP projection is that there will be 700,000 such elements in the small
town on the appointed day. Now that this seems unlikely, the VHP is still
belligerent and claims that the program will go on as planned.
Since
the BJP will attract penalties in the Elections Act if it raised religious
issues from its own platform, it relies for this purpose on its proxies, mainly
the VHP and its youth wing, the Bajrang Dal. The VHP (World Hindu Council) has
been faithfully reviving the Temple issues before every state legislative
assembly and national parliament elections in order to consolidate the Hindu
vote behind the BJP.
The
Temple slogan has lost much of its appeal down the road since the Mosque
demolition in 1992. This time too it was revived but failed to influence voters
just like the other slogan of fighting "terrorism", which the BJP
touted recently.
Ever
since the demolition, Muslim position has been that they will accept a court
verdict whatever it was. However, extremist Hindus refuse this, knowing that
their case is weak and may be thrown out even by the most sympathetic courts.
To
overcome this, they demolished the Mosque to create a new status quo and
now they want to complete the construction of the Temple in order to create
another fait accompli. Prime Minister Vajpayee had tried to bring round
some Muslims to accept a certain formula to hand over the site to the
extremists. He had given the deadline of March 12 to accomplish this but no
movement could be made since no Muslim individual or organization is ready to
provide this coup de grace to the Masjid-Temple imbroglio.
The
VHP has been preparing for the proposed temple. Three workshops, one in Ayodhya
itself, have been busy, without any hindrance from the authorities, for many
years preparing the carved stones which are to be used in the Temple.
Meanwhile,
the Lucknow bench of the Allahabad High Court is looking into the legal case and
there is no hope of any early verdict. Another judicial body, Liberhan
Commission, is looking into the conspiracy that led to the demolition of the
Mosque in 1992 and has yet to present its report to the government.
Exasperated,
the VHP recently revived the issue with a much-hyped show of Chetawani Yatra
(Warning March) and announced to start the construction of the Ram temple at the
martyred Babri Masjid site on March 15.
Ram
Chandra Pramhans, one of the prominent leaders of the temple movement, set the
ball rolling when he announced, "we will wait till March 12, not a day
more. We have given the government enough time. We cannot wait any longer. They
(the government) will be well advised not to test our patience any longer."
He later announced that the movement of the construction material for the temple
from the Karsevakpuram, the township built by the fanatics, to the Mosque site,
will begin from March 15. A large number of pillars and beams, planned to be
used in the proposed temple, are ready in several workshops (Karyashalas)
in Ayodhya, Jaipur and Mount Abu.
The
VHP’s plan to arouse communal sentiments and rally common people behind the
BJP has already suffered a set back with common people refusing to rally behind
the ultra rightist Hindu party and thereby giving it a severe jolt in its quest
to seek another stint of power at the Center.
The
BJP has failed to secure support for the Temple cause from several of its
alliance partners in the central government. The VHP has been claiming for quite
some time that several partners of the NDA government at the Center have assured
support for the Ram temple movement. But much to its chagrin, several leaders
including the DMK’s Karunanidhi and West Bengal Chief Minister Buddhadeb
Bhattacharjee, refused to even meet Temple movement leaders. Several others
about whom it was claimed that they have agreed to support the construction of
the Temple at the Babri site have also denied to have ever said so.
The
current belligerence shows that the VHP seems to have concluded that it is time
to do something to check the eroding popularity of the ultra rightist
"saffron" brigade. So it is going steady with its plan to rake up the
Ram temple issue, which has been the only reason of the spectacular rise of the
BJP during the last two decades, as even the Home Minister LK Advani has
conceded.
The
BJP's rout in the recent state assembly elections has also provided an
opportunity to revive the issue through its proxies. Earlier the Rashtriya
Swayam Sevak Sangh (RSS), the parent body of the rightist Hindu outfits, did not
approve of the VHP going all out on the issue as any such movement threatened
the survival of the BJP government in both the state and the Center. Now it is
the question of the survival of all the saffron parties including the RSS and
the BJP. With a secular government at the helm in the state of Uttar Pradesh
(UP), they will try to turn the heat against secular forces and rally Hindu
voters of the state behind the BJP. The Temple issue has proved to be the best
prescription for such a plan.
This
has caused panic in all political circles. They fear that a repeat of the 6
December 1992 is in the offing again. It was thousands of so-called
"karsevaks" (volunteers) who stormed the 15th century mosque in 1992
demolished it and quickly erected a makeshift temple with precise planning.
The
government assurance that it will maintain the status quo at the site has
not been able to satisfy members of Parliament. During the all-party meeting,
the BJP-led government failed to answer the main question raised by almost all
speakers, including leaders of the ruling NDA, as to how it planned to tackle
the situation. Both Vajpayee and Advani failed to give a categorical assurance
that the Karsevaks (volunteers) already in Ayodhya would be sent back and no
more would be allowed into the city. Vajpayee simply stated that there is
difference between 'demolition' which takes just a few hours and 'construction'
which takes time.
Senior
Congress party leader Arjun Singh described the discussion as an exercise in
futility, "since the center failed to spell out its so-called appropriate
action." Similarly, the Communist Party of India (CPIM) leader Somnath
Chatterjee expressed anxiety over the turn of events. He said the BJP could not
be taken for its words in view of the 6 December 1992 mosque demolition. The
BJP, which was in power in UP at the time, had assured the Supreme Court that it
would not allow the mosque to be demolished. Still, thugs led by present central
ministers went out to demolish the mosque.
NDA
partners, including TDP, MDMK, Trinamool Congress and the Janata Dal (S), put
the government in a spot by questioning the government's actions so far. Yerren
Naidu of the TDP pointedly demanded to know the government's plan of action.
"It will be a disaster if December 6 is repeated," he declared.
Meanwhile,
the VHP has declared that it will not stop and will go all-out to start
construction on the appointed date despite the government warning yesterday. It
has also said that it is happy that there is the prospect of Mulayam Singh of
the Samajwadi Party being at the helms in UP as this will help the extremists to
incite common people against secular parties. "If Mulayam Singh becomes the
chief minister, we have a plan by which we will go all out. If it had been a BJP
chief minister, it would have meant a little more restraint for us," VHP
general secretary told media on Tuesday. He said that that VHP has worked out a
plan for both favorable and unfavorable conditions. This includes deciding on
leaders who will go underground and front commanders who will stay to lead the
extremists.