Home | Iraq in Transition

Updated:Tue. Mar. 21, 2006

Comments and Replies

Freedom

Reader's Comments:

It will take some time to get your government running smoothly. We need to get your police force of Iraqi people established so that the former regime will not come to power again. This means training and helping with those of you who have been excluded from these possibilities before the downfall of the Saddam regime.

You will need to learn how to structure your society with freedom as you are not used to having this freedom; and choices need to be made for the betterment of all your citizens. We are not trying to take away your religion or rights to worship as you please.

You seem to be a very intelligent and schooled society and this will be of great help to you. If we wanted to occupy your country, you would not be allowed free speech, free worship, and any forming of any country. Most of us in the USA are Christians and not Muslims. We are truly trying to do for you what we would want you to do to us if things were reversed. We are trying to work with Islam, a religion that most of us know little about, and sometimes we make terrible mistakes – we are sorry for these things to happen.

I wish you peace and prosperity with your present and future.

 Reply:

As Muslims and Arabs, the speedy restoration of services and order to Iraq is not our sole concern, though it is a major one. It is hard not to notice that the new police force being formed in Iraq may well contain the same torturers the US used as a pretext for its invasion. This has been noted by journalists in Iraq who have come to realize that there has been no effort by US troops to find records of torture and the names of those responsible for perpetrating it.  

Additionally, it is very distressing to us to find that the US bombed and killed with the stated aim of restoring Iraq 's freedom from oppression, and yet, Donald Rumsfeld specifically ruled out the option of Islamic rule. How is that in keeping with the idea of freedom and democracy? Iraq was denied an Islamic system under Saddam; it is being denied the same under  US occupation. What is the point?

We thank you for your concern and your e-mail.


The articles posted on this page reflect solely the opinions of the authors.

News | Shari`ah | Health & Science | Politics in Depth | Reading Islam | Family | Culture | Youth | Euro-Muslims | IOL Radio

About Us | Speech of Sheikh Qaradawi | Contact Us | Advertise | Support IOL | Site Map