 |
|
 |
|
|
|
Last Update: 07:30 GMT, Mon., June 29, 2009 / Rajab 6, 1430
|
 |
|
Folders &
Special Pages > Society
|
 |
 |
|
Contributions
IslamOnline.net
invites you, the reader, to become more proactive with your website. We'll be
accepting articles, flash presentations, pictures, audio and video files
related to social issues. All contributions must be original and the sole
possession of the contributor. Each contribution will be considered separately
for publication, and only slight editing changes, when necessary, will be
performed.
We
also invite you to send us your comments and feedback ,whether negative or
positive Send your contributions with your name and email address to: counseling@islam-online.net
|
Contributions |
|
|
Sardonic, South Africa
Assalaamu alaikum
Sorry for responding long after the trail has grown cold.
To be very honest, I believe a lot of what is happening in SA is a result of moral decay. And also a lot of frustration when it comes to government. People have lost faith in government and their ability to rule, while at the same time many have developed a misguided sense of entitlement. Transformation is taking place, perhaps not as fast as blacks would want and much too fast for whites. Affirmative action is creating deep divides in our community and has led to the Afrikaner feeling marginalized. It is a complex issue. Even our 'Indian' children are disgruntled with quotas and such when it comes to Universities and education.
Having staggering amounts of foreigners in our midst has not helped matters either. The outlook seems bleak, or perhaps I'm, just being a pessimist. The ANC is now divided down the middle and one fears what the next election may well bring.
As for writing an article, if only I had the time, I would love it. But life has served me a plate that is rather full right now. Perhaps someday I can return to writing. For now, it's work, work, work.
FI amanillah
SS
July 15, 2008.
|
|
Abdulaziz,
U.A.E.
How
poor we are?
In
the name of Allah, The Most Merciful, The Most Gracious
How
poor are we?
One
day, the father of a very wealthy family took his son on a trip to the
country with the express purpose of showing him how poor people live.
They
spent a couple of days and nights on the farm of what would be
considered a very poor family.
On
their return from their trip, the father asked his son, "How was
the trip?"
"It
was great, Dad."
"Did
you see how poor people live?" the father asked.
"Oh
yeah," said the son.
"So,
tell me, what you learned from the trip?" asked the father.
The
son answered:
"I
saw that we have one dog and they had four.
We
have a pool that reaches to the middle of our garden and they have a
creek that has no end.
We
have imported lanterns in our garden and they have the stars at
night...
Our
patio reaches to the front yard and they have the whole horizon.
We
have a small piece of land to live on and they have fields that go
beyond our sight.
We
have servants who serve us, but they serve others.
We
buy our food, but they grow theirs.
We
have walls around our property to protect us; they have friends to
protect them."
The
boy's father was speechless.
Then
his son added,
"Thanks
Dad for showing me how poor we are."
Prophet
Muhammad, peace be upon him said.
Riches
does not mean having a great amount of property, real wealth is
self-contentment.
Sahih
Bukhari Book 81, Chapter 15. Narrator Hazrat Abu Huraira
May
28, 2008.
|
|
Fizz
Khan
Upbringing
& nurturing children
Mentality
- be aware of it but don't let that destroy the family many people
marry within a different culture - one must keep culture and
religion separate (cultural deprivation) otherwise marital problems
increase.
Women
go thru a lot before/after having children & they need all the
support they can get especially from their husbands - additionally
if both parents stick to the same rules in order to bring up their
children then children are more likely to listen to them, as they
won't be confused or disobedient.
I
hope & pray insha Allah that the new generation is brought up
properly so that the world is a better place for all Muslim brothers
& sisters.
March 26,
2008
|
|
Nasir
Pregnancy
with out marriage/teenage
I
would only add that West is just using women for pleasure &
the so called laws and regulations only give them a feel of
protection. In actuality, the protection is only given to the
'act' of getting into such relationship till the time the girl
& boy want to remain engaged. Otherwise, there is hardly any
religion divine or otherwise which allows such relationships &
births. It is only Men who alters the laws to best suit his evil
objectives.
March
2, 2008
|
|
Thureya
Title:
teenage pregnancy
when
a 12year old gets pregnant in UK, its ok-their health is already
caretered for by the parliamentary provisions through contraceptives
and all. when a 12year old is married off in Pakistan, Human Rights
activists complain it endangers the health and mental capacity of
the child. In one case a 12year old is free to be sexually involved
as long as it is illegal intercourse while in the other the same age
group is considered 'incapable' of involving in legal intercourse
and a violation of their basic right. The world is coming to an
end...wont you agree?
March
1,2008
|
|
Mohamed
,Canada
One
Muslim at a Time
Bismillah
ar-Rahman ar-Raheem
It
was narrated that Abu Hurayrah (may Allah be pleased with him) said:
The
Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) said: "How
wonderful is the affair of the believer, for all of it is good, and
that applies to no one except the believer. If something good
happens to him he gives thanks, and that is good for him, and if
something bad befalls him he bears it with patience and that is good
for him."
Narrated
by Muslim (2999)
An
American psychologist said: Living a happy life is a fine art which
entails ten things:
Do
a work that you love. If you cannot do that, then find a hobby that
you love and do it in your spare time and reinforce it.
Take
care of your health for it is the spirit of happiness. This means
being moderate in eating and drinking, exercising regularly and
avoiding bad habits.
Have
a goal in life, for this will give you motivation and energy.
Take
life as it comes, and accept the bitter and the sweet.
Live
in the present, with no regret for the past and no anxiety about
tomorrow that has not come yet.
Think
hard about any action or decision, and do not blame anyone else for
your decision or its consequences.
Look
at those who are worse off than you.
Have
the habit of smiling and being cheerful, and keep company with
optimistic people.
Strive
to make others happy so that you may benefit from the atmosphere of
happiness.
Make
the most of occasions of happiness and joy, and regard them as
necessary to renew your own happiness.
Making
a Difference, One Muslim at a Time
“Do
people imagine that they will be left at ease because they say 'We
have faith!' and will not be tested? But certainly We tested those
who were before them..” [Quran 29:2-3]
March
3, 2008.
|
|
Hodan
, UK
Assalamu
Alaikum.
Tomorrow
marks the 2nd anniversary of my husband's release from an Egyptian
jail where he suffered torture.
I
am a freelance journalist and would like to submit a piece for the
website. It is from my point of view, the wife left raising the
kids for four years alone as well as running a successful human
rights campaign for her husband's release. I was in Egypt at
the time of the raid. I also visited my husband in jail many times
and met the families of Egyptian prisoners with some phenomenal
stories.
Now
that it is all over for us legally, is it really over at home on the
emotional and day to day front? With the recent convictions of
the 'paint-balling' Muslims in the UK; I would like to add
color to this type of story by providing insight of what life is
like for those left behind.
I
do not expect to be commissioned for this.
Please
let me know if you are interested in running this.
JazakumAllah
khair.
Wasalam.
Yours
sincerely,
March
2, 2008
|
|
Mohamed,
Canada.
Alsalam
alikom all,
hope
all are had or having a good weekend inshaa Allah,
i
have found this link and it is for teaching Arabic for free, it is
very well developed website and it shall serve all levels as well
from beginner to advanced
it
is really a good start, may Allah bless who done such work
Please
click here http://www.madinaharabic.com/
Salamo
aliakom
February
2008 .
|
|
Sardonic,
South Africa
The
perfect state of Iman has been described a state of being between
hope and fear. And that's true, very true.
This
message was drummed hope by cane wielding Molwis, was it not? The
guys who stood beside you while you recited the Kalaam of Allah
and let their cane whistle through the air and find its mark on
you each time you made an error. Or by the kinds of sadists who
made you balance a chalkboard duster on the nape of your neck each
time you committed a misdemeanour and should the said duster fall
– which it inevitably would – the punishment (it was coming
anyway) would be a solidly humiliating caning.
It
was repeated often enough by those lovely Arabs who would say, 'If
you wear shorts on weekends, Allah will put you in Jahannum' (No
explanation of the qualifier – the shorts could be Bermudas
which cover/reach the knees and not a thought for the whole
concept of Allah being the sole Judge, shorts notwithstanding).
Until you reached a stage- in the manner of childhood Magical
Thinking – where you wondered whether Allah was the Arab's Big
Brother who was always waiting for you to put a foot wrong so that
He could punish you the way the Arab wanted you to be punished. A
truly fear inspiring 'Brotherhood . And would you believe it, it
still happens in the here and now where corporal punishment has
been outlawed? My son regularly has run-ins with the cane of an
Ustaad who has (disrespectfully, I might add) been dubbed Batista.
Force
children to succeed by creating a fear in them of the outcome
should they fail. Yet should the desire to succeed not stem from a
desire to please, which is often borne out of love? This is the
way the Prophet Mohammed (SAW) did things. The ahadith tells us
about how he never struck a woman of child in his entire life. I
remember reading of the young Sahabi who was taught the etiquettes
of eating by example and with love. Their love for Nabi SAW due to
his excellent character left them with a dread of displeasing him.
Read the incident of the 'Three who were left behind' in the
Qur`an. The Tabuk expedition. Read of the misery experienced by
the companions whose grief was not because they felt that they
would now be punished, but rather because they felt most acutely
the removal of the Prophet (SAW) pleasure. A fear to displease
borne of love.
Which
should also be the way we view Allah. We should love Him to such a
level that He should become the conscience that guides, that
inspires, that decides. A fear to displease the Rabb who remains
the Sole Benefactor. The Only Benefactor truly worth mentioning,
Whose bounty does not cease, even when we, sinful beings that we
are, fail to give Him thanks.
Isn't
it perhaps time we re-evaluated our relationship with Allah? And
perhaps gave more thought to the messages we give our children and
would like to convey to them?
Yours
in Faith
January,
2008.
|
|
Shamsuddeen,
S. Africa
Please
ask your chairman ( or those of similar relevance ) to CHECK OUT
THE LINK BELOW, & request them to figure out a
"practical" way to be "ribaa"-free in doing
the same. Remember, I'm not an expert, and these are suggestions
you could try implementing, for a start, in those districts of
Kerala which do not even have 1 medical college presently, let
alone in the whole of India.
But
u do need an EDUCATIONAL TRUST for the same. Its practically
doable by resource mobilisation, but being practically ribaa-free
is the challenge.
http://www.mciindia.org/helpdesk/how_to_start/new_college.htm
December
25 2007.
|
|
Wahida
My
sincere hope is that 2.5 million or more Muslim who went to hajj had
a great transformation of their heart and soul and will come back
all charged up to fight against in justice, poverty, and
oppression. Hajj must have a greater purpose than just a
ritual in which the hajj are supposedly have all their sins
removed and return pure as a new born baby. Every
act of Ibadah as I understand it has a social and
psychological component to it and that demand actions, struggle and
sacrifices. The Qur'an casts a wide net concerning our social and
moral obligations, and these can only be fulfilled if we are
actively engaged in the process of creating a just society in a just
world.
Have
You Seen? <>Consider this small Surah in the Qur’an:
Have you seen the one who consciously denies the system [of the
Qur’an]? It is he who will repel the orphans and will urge
not feeding the needy. Woe unto those who worship, yet are
headless of the purpose of it. Who could be seen at worship
but refuse even small necessities to the needy? (Qur’an 107:1-7)
December
23 2007.
|
|
Pauline,
Australia
Looking
at one of the topics called "more beautiful than whom?"
I am amused to see that the person asking the question thinks
there are not as many beautiful Muslim women as there are non
Muslims. If that person ever sees those non Muslim sisters without
make up they would be in for a shock ha ha ha
Before
any color is even applied the skin is coated in concealer, primer
and then foundation. Then starts the coloring in. There is the
blush to highlight the cheekbones, the several different shades of
eye color plus eye liner, mascara primer, then mascara and eyebrow
pencils (the eyebrow is shaped by waxing of course) then lipstick
and lip liner.
This
is all set with a powder. Then there is the hair which is tinted
and colored and blow dried and curled or straightened ....... We
haven't even got to the clothes or the surgery, or the implants,
or the injections .....
Beautiful?
Yes ... but most paintings on canvas's are beautiful. Make up is
amazing. Truly it is. And for the most part is filled with
poisons.
I
believe that you are part of a team that works on www.IslamOnline.net
I am fairly new to that website, having found it is referred to in
some of the discussions on Face book as a reference for more
information on particular topics. I have found it
particularly useful.
I
guess what I have to offer is the fact that I have done a lot of
spiritual work on myself long before I came to Islam and I also
see many places where other religions, yoga and meditative
practices overlap with what Islam teaches. Which makes Islam
all the more valuable in my eyes as it is a comprehensive source
of this wisdom that is scattered amongst the others I have delved
into. I also know why I willingly embraced Islam when it
came into my life ...
Nov
22, 2007
|
|
Sardonic
Scholar, South Africa
Muslim
Youth Mentality
I
have committed the ultimate folly of sending my kids to an Islamic
School. I am now left frustrated with a system that is both
archaic and pedantic, that does not encourage freedom of
expression. Freedom of thought, well they've almost got a thought
police in place. They are teaching my children all the narrow
interpretations that I would rather not have them exposed to at
all and worse, I am powerless to do anything about it.
So
now what? Either I uproot then – yet again – and do the
madrassah bit by myself. Or I go with the flow and tell them a
different tale every time they come home and tell me stuff like,
"You mustn't listen to Yusuf Islam. He is no longer a
Muslim."
Now
I'm not one for minding my P's and Q's, so when I hear gunk like
that it takes all my self control not to spew out the first words
that springs to the tip of my tongue. Then I take them aside and
tell them the 'other' story. The one that is less judgmental and
open to allowing people a point of view. Will this confuse them?
Most like it will. That or leave them with an unhealthy disrespect
for authority. Since authority has now been proven to be highly
mistaken.
But
that's not the only problem I have with Islamic schools. I have an
issue with someone who tells my son that he cannot wear Bermudas
on weekends and threatens to hit him (yes, you read right) for
that. So yes, I'll go no further.
Yet it is in this same environment where my son is given the
impression that name brands maketh the man. That cars put you up
there, with the stars – the soccer stars – English Premier
League. And that houses are meant to have six bedrooms and a movie
theatre. Kids come to school and discuss – and exaggerate most
wildly too (I wonder where they learnt to do that?) – the
turnover in their father's businesses. And – wait for it –
some even sell 'stuff' at school.
Something
is clearly not right with the state of Islamic Schools. Is this a
reflection of the moral decay that pervades our society and has
driven us so far from the Path that is Islam that we cannot see it
anymore? Hmmm, I wonder…
Nov
22, 2007
|
|
Mohammad,
Canada
The
method by which the Muslim acquires knowledge and thought is
critical in determining the impact of the Islamic thoughts upon
the individual.
If
the method of acquiring knowledge was correct and based upon
research, profound thinking, and analysis (as Allah (swt) ordered)
then it will produce effective results, and such a person will
turn into an ideological person who thinks in a distinct manner.
Allah
(swt) orders the human being to think about many aspects of His
Creation in a profound and enlightened manner:
"Verily!
In the creation of the heavens and the earth, and in the
alternation of night and day, there are indeed signs for men of
understanding." [TMQ 3:190]
"Do
they not then consider the Qur’an carefully? Had it been from
other than Allah, they would surely have found within it many
contradictions." [TMQ 4:82]
"Tell
Me! The water that you drink — is it you who causes it to come
down from the rainclouds, or are We the Cause for it to come
down?" [TMQ 56:68-69]
"He
is created from a fluid poured forth — proceeding from between
the back bone and the ribs." [TMQ 86:6-7]
"Do
they not look at the camels, how they are created? And at the
heaven, how it is raised? And at the mountains, how they are
rooted and fixed firm? And at the earth, how it is spread
out?" [TMQ 88:17-20]
In
all of these five ayahs above, Allah directs the human being to
think and analyze in order to build the Aqeedah (true belief) of
Islam within him through a definite conviction.
Thus,
the method that Islam encourages in pursuing knowledge is based
upon the intellect and entails thinking, research, and analysis.
Examining
Muslims today shows that the Muslims acquire Islam through three
principle methods
The
Scholastic, or Academic, Method
This
method emphasizes delivering Islam as a curriculum in a scholastic
format in which information, and not concepts and thoughts, is the
substance. The student-teacher relationship is the approach of
this method, and giving instructions constitutes its style.
If
the student graduates, he will resemble a book that carries
information and spits it out, and Islam would consist of nothing
more than information dictated to him.
Such
a person would repeat quotations from scholars and their works
without any critical thinking or consideration to the evidences
and arguments simply because he cannot do so.
His/her
capability would be confined to relaying the information that was
handed to him just as a database would download information when
programmed to do so.
Studying
Islam in this erroneous method will produce neither a thinker
based on Islam nor a mujtahid, but will produce human textbooks
whom the extent of their contributions will be limited to copying
the works of others and writing some commentaries on them. Such a
method could be useful in studying an information-based discipline
such as geography or history.
However,
it cannot be taken as a method of studying the foundation or
Aqeedah and the thoughts because the Islamic Aqeedah or foundation
and its thoughts must be acquired intellectually through a dynamic
process of relating the thoughts to the situation until they
become firmly-rooted thoughts and not just theoretical information
carried by the person like the words on the pages of a book.
The
Emotional Method
The
essence of this method entails bringing stories and preaching
Islamic personalities.
It
depends on the emotional approach and not the thinking process in
order to push a person to function.
Because
this approach realizes that emotions by their intrinsic nature can
get out of control, it depends on programming the individual in a
specific way.
The
individual who acquires Islam through this method will start
learning that discipline and obedience towards the shaykhs and the
mas’ooleen is a part of Islam.
This
method is, relatively speaking, a new method because it was
influenced by the psychological-based sciences that came with
disciplines such as psychology, sociology, and education.
This
approach does not regard man, life and the universe as the subject
of thinking and research but instead places the human psyche and
its development as the ultimate objective.
The
scope of thinking and research remains restricted to the psyche of
the individual through promoting its positive aspects and treating
its negative aspects.
Also,
it connects such individuals with the mas’ooleen and the shaykhs
emotionally in the same manner that a person is connected with his
father or therapist.
As
a result, those who acquired Islam in this way are attached to
certain personalities whom they regard as holy and follow as
examples without any thinking.
Such
a method does not produce intellectuals, thinkers, or mujtahids,
nor does it claim to produce them.
It
could be used in dealing with the young children or with those who
do not think and therefore look forward to those who would think
on their behalf and relieve them of the burden of thinking.
This
approach could also apply to those who do not think and are
seeking a group of people to associate with in order to enjoy the
social environment and activities that this group or tribe
provides them, such as friendship, visits, and collective
activities involving ibadat, trips, and sports. Therefore, this
method cannot initiate the revival of the Ummah or the muslims as
a nation, nor can it provide the Ummah with the thought and the
awareness needed for such a revival.
The
Sufi Method
This
approach is influenced by the notion that the human being consists
of two components – the spirit and the material aspect – that
are mutually antagonistic.
Thus,
the human being has a spiritual momentum that must be elevated,
and the only way to do so is to deprive the body of its physical
needs. This process continues until the person attains a level
where he merges with God and he sees God in himself.
From
the vantage point of this method, Islam and its rules as mere
signs and symbols guiding the person in his/her path towards God.
The
value of these rules and symbols lay in comprehending their
concealed or hidden meanings, what the Sufis call the
"Haqiqah" or the reality.
This
truth or "Haqiqah" is distinct from what they refer to
as the apparent meaning, which they use to denote the Shariah.
Sufism
upholds the idea of Fatalism in which everything is predestined
and man has no will of his own.
Thus,
the Sufis claim that a person must surrender to his situation and
cannot change it. Furthermore, Sufism encourages the human being
to live in seclusion and give the natural phenomena in the
universe a metaphysical interpretation.
The
Sufis also encourage passiveness, total surrender to the reality,
and being careless about the reality because, according to their
claim, these qualities characterize the one who suppresses
himself, his/her desires, and his/her physical inclinations.
These
qualities are needed for the one who wants to conceal his mind
because they constitute the first step towards evanescence and
merging into God’s entity.
Some
people who either failed in the life or who just look to the Deen
as an escape from the current situation may use this approach as
an outlet of contentment or solace. This is an extremely dangerous
approach because it kills the awareness and the thinking in the
Ummah and propagates passiveness and total surrender to the status
quo without any attempt to change it.
"Do
they not then consider the Qur’an carefully? Had it been from
other than Allah, they would surely have found within it many
contradictions." [Qr 4:82]
"Tell
Me! The water that you drink — is it you who causes it to come
down from the rainclouds, or are We the Cause for it to come
down?" [Qr 56:68-69]
"He
is created from a fluid poured forth — proceeding from between
the back bone and the ribs." [Qr 86:6-7]
"Do
they not look at the camels, how they are created? And at the
heaven, how it is raised? And at the mountains, how they are
rooted and fixed firm? And at the earth, how it is spread
out?" [Qr 88:17-20]
In
all of these ayahs or phrases from the Quran, Allah directs the
human being to think and analyze in order to build the Aqeedah of
Islam within him through a definite conviction.
Thus,
the method that Islam encourages in pursuing knowledge is based
upon the intellect and entails thinking, research, and analysis.
It
is not built upon blind faith, emotional belief, or submission
without any discussion.
Such
methods will not produce a dynamic Iman and cannot serve either as
a foundation for a point of view of life or as a foundation to
build other thoughts upon.
A
person who adopts Islam through these methods will remain a
hostage to the concepts that he/she carried from his/her previous
background.
Although
such a person may turn to Islam in a limited scope for such
aspects as his/her ibadat, he/she will continue in his/her
thinking to refer to other concepts.
He/She
will constantly shift between a superficial Iman or faith that is
not built upon a correct thinking process and indulging in
discussion without a specific frame of mind, which will lead him
either to diverging or straying from Islam altogether.
And
he/she will not escape this spiral except by either compromising
between what he/she adopted from Islam and whatever erroneous
concepts he/she already possesses in order to bridge the gap, or
by separating Islam from his/her thinking by restricting Islam to
his/her rituals and thinking in a secular or pragmatic manner, or
by deciding not to think at all except in his/her livelihood in
order to save himself/herself from diverting.
All
of these options are incorrect and, in reality, will not get the
person out of this spiral.
Eventually,
this cycle with drain the person’s power, particularly his
intellectual capacity, which is the most valuable possession of
man in this life.
Such
an endless spiral results from an incorrect method of adopting
Islam and acquiring knowledge.
“Do
people imagine that they will be left at ease because they say 'We
have faith!' and will not be tested? But certainly We tested those
who were before them..” [Quran 29:2-3]
Nov
22, 2007
|
|
Comment
on: Husband Unable to Perform
I
would like to add something to the advice given at: Husband
unable to perform sexually. As Muslims, we need to be real with
one another. One of the best traits of the Prophet (peace and prayer
be upon him) in my opinion was his frankness coupled with sound and
straightforward dealings with people. I don't think it is wise for
us to balk at calling sin what it is.
Sexual
deprivation of one's wife is an injustice against her, just as the
same against a husband would be injustice against him. So I will say
this from a combined counselor's and Muslim's point of view. There
is NO SUCH THING as 'unable to function sexually' for anyone who was
able to function in the past. There are physical problems specific
to the private parts, but we have many parts of our body with which
to express intimacy.
A
man may feel embarrassed about his condition, but it is nowhere near
as embarrassed as he would be in hell. As a husband he is obligated
to maintain the stability and peace in his home. If his pride gets
in the way of this, he is in the wrong. If he loves her and loves
Allah he will use the brain and the body he was blessed with, and do
what he can to take care of his wife. No excuses.
Millions
of people have the same problem, and almost everyone will because of
age or illness either lose their drives or they will lower. This is
a normal part of life, and all of us should be prepared for this
eventuality when we marry. Perhaps if his duaa is directed towards
dealing with his pride rather than just bringing back his potency,
Allah will bless him with both.
I
know from dealing with couples for years that often things are made
better when the man becomes less centered on a specific way of
intimacy, and opens his heart. Many men who had problems for awhile,
realized that they do still have quite a bit of functioning. It's
just not as easy as it was when they were younger. Their
testosterone has lowered with age usually by 50 years old or so, and
they actually need the 'touching and sweet words'. When they realize
this, they move past frustration and realize that this is a
beautiful phase in their lives when they become more understanding
of their wives. As you like to say, Allah knows best. We were made
wonderfully, and sometimes the things we consider to be flaws are
actually good for us.
Ibtisam
May
4, 2006
|
|
Double
Standards in A Barren Life
Assalamu
aleikum Usually I find Brother Abdullah Abdur Rahman's answers the
best on your site. But today he missed the boat. In his answer to A
Barren Life? he questioned why the woman thought she did not have
a 'proper marriage'.
To
the reader the answer is clear - the husband is impotent! I hardly
think that if a wife could not have sex with her husband for the
greater part of 15 years that there would be any question that he
should leave her.
Why
the hesitation when the woman is left unfulfilled? Please do not
continue these double standards which afflict Muslims - that a husband
should divorce his wife or take another if his first wife has
problems, but that the wife should remain patient with her husband and
stay with him pretty much no matter what or bad his defects are.
Brenda
May
21, 2006
|
|
Re:
Abdullah Abdur Rahman [counselor] on After
Divorce, I Hate the Single Life.
My
comments is relating to the author writing on the above topic. The
author had given a good advise about women after divorce may only
permissible to marry Muslim men. However, the author seemed to has
a double standard arguing that Muslim men may be permissible
married Muslim women or women from the “Book/Kitab”. Why such
double standard EXIST?. I personally doubt the presence groups of
women who comes from the book / kitab which Muslim men are
permitted to marrying them. According to the author such practice
is not be allowed to Muslim women. I believed there are no women
from the “Book/ Kitab” exist in this millennium which Muslim
men are permitted according to Islam to marrying them. I believe
there are a pocket of Muslim scholars whom are men tend to make
fatwa which is double standard and only trying to suit their fatwa
according to their want and need mainly men and hide themselves
behind the authentic Islamic fundamentalist.
Noraini,
New Zealand
February
27th 2006
|
|
Maria's
Hussain's recent article Dress
for Success: In This World And The Next was
an interesting read. It was well written and made some very good
points about how you are perceived based on the way you are
dressed. However, there were some points in the article that
conflict with Islamic Law and therefore I wish to point those out
respectfully. 1) Declining to shake hands with someone of the
opposite gender may be considered rude in the West. However, in
Islamic Law it really is not a matter of whether someone would
think of you as indecent or not were you to shake hands, as the
article implies, but rather it is something forbidden. Whether its
out of politeness or whether it lacks any lust, the touch is
forbidden as we well know. And Allah knows best. 2) Again loose
pants may be 'loose' but in all honestly, pants in general do not
cover a woman properly. If a person can look at you and tell you
your trouser/shirt size, you may not be dressed modestly enough.
And this is exactly what happens when a woman wears pants. Having
worked in the IT field as a woman who wore long skirts/shirts and
even jilbabs with long scarfs, I know that it is perfectly
acceptable to wear those clothes without having to wear pants. And
Allah knows best. 3) I also think her comment about tying the
scarf behind the head or under the chin was not in good taste.
While these things may have certain meanings in the West, I think
we all know that slowly but surely overtime things acquire new
meanings. And I believe we need to be confident about who we are.
Wearing a pin in a specific place as long as it looks decent does
not need to be an issue, because then it just seems like we are
being apologetic about who we are. If someone wishes to think of
me as a 'housewife'(and I don't know how I'm supposed to perceive
that as an insult unless I am myself influenced by feminist
ideals) because of the way my pin is placed on my hijab, in all
honesty, I think that is their concern, not mine.
|
NM
January
30, 2006
Maria's
Hussain's recent article Dress
for Success: In This World And The Next was an interesting read.
It was well written and made some very good points about how you are
perceived based on the way you are dressed. However, there were some
points in the article that conflict with Islamic Law and therefore I
wish to point those out respectfully. 1) Declining to shake hands with
someone of the opposite gender may be considered rude in the West.
However, in Islamic Law it really is not a matter of whether someone
would think of you as indecent or not were you to shake hands, as the
article implies, but rather it is something forbidden. Whether its out
of politeness or whether it lacks any lust, the touch is forbidden as we
well know. And Allah knows best. 2) Again loose pants may be 'loose' but
in all honestly, pants in general do not cover a woman properly. If a
person can look at you and tell you your trouser/shirt size, you may not
be dressed modestly enough. And this is exactly what happens when a
woman wears pants. Having worked in the IT field as a woman who wore
long skirts/shirts and even jilbabs with long scarfs, I know that it is
perfectly acceptable to wear those clothes without having to wear pants.
And Allah knows best. 3) I also think her comment about tying the scarf
behind the head or under the chin was not in good taste. While these
things may have certain meanings in the West, I think we all know that
slowly but surely overtime things acquire new meanings. And I believe we
need to be confident about who we are. Wearing a pin in a specific place
as long as it looks decent does not need to be an issue, because then it
just seems like we are being apologetic about who we are. If someone
wishes to think of me as a 'housewife'(and I don't know how I'm supposed
to perceive that as an insult unless I am myself influenced by feminist
ideals) because of the way my pin is placed on my hijab, in all honesty,
I think that is their concern, not mine.
NM
January 30, 2006
With
regard to the article on Khul'
written by Amatullah Abdullah, I just wanted to comment that the
separation between Barirah had no relation to khul' or to her feelings
towards him. She and her husband were both slaves. When Ai`shah RAA
bought and freed her the marriage was automatically dissolved as a
result of her gaining her freedom though she was given the choice to
remain with her husband if she so desired. Thus it should be clarified
that the Prophet SAWS didn't grant Barirah a divorce in the text that
was quoted. The dissolution of the marriage had already taken place and
the Prophet was merely interceding on the behalf of her ex-husband who
hoped that she would return to him.
Ai`sha
January
09, 2006
I
have to comment a recently published article. The Article to my Daughter
letter has a lot of important information in it, but I must take issue
with the author's use of the known forgery, The
Protocols of the Learned Elders of Zion as a basis for his
arguments. This document receives so much attention among Muslims yet it
is a proven forgery. We should never rely - nor need to rely - on
falsehood to make the kind of arguments that the author did in his
article. His points are well stated and justified without having to
mention The Protocols if you are interested published in the Executive
Intelligence Review, Lyndon Larouche's weekly publication in the U.S.,
who is also a very good friend of the Arab world. Wa
salam
Abdul-Lateef
December 29, 2005
Dear
Brother or Sister:
As
salamu `alaykum (peace be upon you):
My
name is Abdul Rahman Kattih, I am the director of the Islamic Education
and Services institute. (The Islamic education and services institute is
a non profit organization registered in the state of Tennessee under permit number 0448281. we follow the regulations regarding
donations and fund raisings established by the IRS).
We
are getting ready to launch an Islamic Public Library and education
center in Chattanooga, TN. This will be the only dedicated DAWA center in the South of the
United States that we know of!
Our
aim is to help everyone in this area better understand Islam and its
practices.
The
center will offer educational and social services to both Muslims and
non Muslims, and the Library will include a range of materials about
Islam for Muslims and non Muslims, adults and children, a desktop, and a
small theatre room to watch movies and presentations about Islam. Some
of the materials we are seeking are:
-
Books
about Islam and Muslims.
-
Islamic
DVD's and VHS.
-
Islamic
Children's books and crafts.
-
Audio
tapes and CD's.
-
Islamic
software for the computer.
We
are seeking your help in fulfilling the library with books, If you can
donate any books to our project we will be so grateful, if every person
that gets this email send us 1 book/CD or DVD we will have a full
library in no time. Or you can make a direct donation through paypal to (admin@2discoverislam.com.
A
receipt will be issued for any donated books.
If
you have any questions please call me directly on the number below, and
if you wish to learn more
about our organization, please visit our website at www.2discoverislam.com.
We
are looking forward to hearing from you and receiving your donation.
Abdul
Rahman Kattih.
December
08
|
My
husband and I have become closer through out this pregnancy. He
has gone to the doctor's appointments, childbirth classes, and
we've registered for the baby shower together. This is our 1st
pregnancy and he has been there for me and our baby girl since day
one. It shocked me when he actually drew me a bath and bathed me
by candle light. He has made me feel so beautiful through out this
pregnancy. It's been a great experience and a true blessing and I
want to share this with your readers. I'm a good reader to
this page.
|
Nesma
November
29th 2005
I
am writing this in the interest of clarifying some of the information
given by certain scholars concerning the pagan holiday of Samhain/Halloween
particularly Halloween:
Through Muslim Eyes I do this because as Muslims need to
clarify their beliefs and eliminate misunderstandings and misconceptions
to those who know little about their faith as a practicing pagan, I feel
that I need to do the same. In the article mentioned above, he
writes; It is derived from rituals involving dead spirits and devil
worship and symbolizes the beginning of the ancient Druid's New
Year, who hold that the dead revisit their homes at that time. In
essence, Halloween represents the devil worshipper's New Year. Muslim
commemoration of such a day is therefore sinful and haram; as
it involves the most evil elements of polytheism and disbelief.
This is not a holiday celebrating devil worship. I feel that I can't
emphasize this enough. This is a common question I have been
asked, and also been accused of. Wicca is not the same as satanism, as
most Wiccans don't even believe in a devil at all. If you take
nothing else away from this please understand one thing. Wicca is not a
religion of devil worship.
The
Celtic year began on November 1st with a festival of called Samhain. The
ancient Druids, believed that on that evening, Samhain, the lord of the
dead, called forth hosts of
>
evil spirits. On the eve of Samhain, October 31st, laughing bands of
young people disguised themselves in grotesque masks and carved lanterns
from turnips and carried them through villages. Samhain is the name of
the holiday not the name of our God. We believe that on Samhain, our God
passes> beyond this world-he dies-and is reborn on Yule (around Dec
21). Evil
spirits
are not called forth! Even those pagans that believe in spiritual
contact are cautioned to do so with care the spirits of those who have
died wish to be left alone. They don't seek to harm those in the mortal
world.As for the history of mask making-I honestly can't be sure. I do
know that Éearly Celts and Irish would carry a turnip with a face
carved in it as a symbol to ward off evil. It was a talisman of
protection against any
Number
of ills. The second precursor to Halloween dates to the Dark Ages in
central Europe. There, the Christian church destroyed many of the
temples of
Various Greek gods and goddesses, such as
Diana and Apollo. However, this pagan worship was never completely
eradicated and later took on the form of witchcraft. One of the most
important aspects of witchcraft is a number of celebrations each year
which are called "Witches' Sabbaths." One of the highest of
the Witches' Sabbaths is the High Sabbath or the Black Sabbath
Of
Witches on October 31st. Today, much of Halloween's folklore such as
black cats, broomsticks, cauldrons and spells come from the Black
Sabbath. High Sabbath simply means a high holiday. Inquisitors and
members of the Christian church who tried to destroy this old system of
beliefs took what they saw and twisted it into something horrible,
over-emphasizing or just outright lying. That is where you get
"Black" Sabbath, and the odd
superstition that black cats are bad luck. A broomstick is simply a
ritual tool, a cauldron is a symbol of life and rebirth and creation,
and I have explained spells as 'prayer with extra direction.' None of
these are the harmful or evil things that they have been associated with
by these early Christian missionaries. I have read the Qur'an many
times, and have a
great deal of respect for your religion. I
have found myself on more than one occasion, correcting coworkers on any
aspect of Islam, and trying to dispel the common misconceptions of your
faith. It is in that spirit in which I write this to you.
As
salamu `alaykum.
Jennifer
November 15th 2005
As
salamu `alaykum brothers and sisters, I
tried to search the site to see if there are any articles on stopping
children viewing pornographic content on the computer but i came up
empty. The following is a free program to block pornographic sites and
best of all, can be upgraded so that parents can monitor their kid's
websites and chat from anywhere in the world. http://ape.childcontrols.com
Hopefully, if parents know of such software, they can make sure their
kids cannot watch pornographic content.
Ahmed
September 15th 2005
As
salamu`alaykum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh,
`In
sha'ALLAH I hope that all is well. May
ALLAH Subhanahu wa Ta'ala reward you for making an effort to help
the Muslims.
In
the case of the depressed sister from Afghanistan who titled her request
Tearful
Times I would like to comment `Insha'ALLAH. In
this case, the Islamic advice as well as "other" advice could
have been given to the sister in a better way. I would like to have an
opportunity to email the sister and share some advice with her
permission because the issues that she deals with have been dealt with
by other sisters who can understand her better and respond better. I
felt after reading the response that it was insufficient to deal with
the depth of her issues and did not offer practical, positive solutions.
If
you could ask the sister permission to allow me to email her, `In
sha'ALLAH we could help her as sisters.
Jazakum
ALLAH Khayrun.
your
sister PS--If it is not possible for you to give me her email address,
please respond to this email and allow me to share the advice with her
and you can email her indirectly or post my reply to Cyber Counselor so
that it could help `In sh'ALLAH.
Jazakum
ALLAH Khayrun.
Your
sister
Latifa
Dad,
You Are a Miserable Parent
Have
you heard anymore from the young man named Nayel? He wrote to you on
August 15 about his unhappy life. It is sad that such a young person is
being abused by a parent. He seems quite mature but it's not right that
he has to assume the role of the parent in dealing with his unkind
father.
Dawn
August
21, 2005
As
salamu alaykum. I ask you
please to read my comment fully, and take me seriously. Dear Scholars,
The main danger of the media is the fact that viewers generalize what
they see. This is how the media is used against Islam. Things such as
over-reporting and re-reporting works because of the way viewers
generalize what they see. I am concerned with the Parenting
Counselor section of your website. Please understand that
viewers who read this section do not keep in mind that the ones who post
at this section are the ones who need help; the ones who have no
problems will not post.
These
viewers will generalize what they read about the Muslims, or will at
least over-estimate the frequency of these problems in the Muslim world.
I am talking about entries of sexual nature. At this point my concern is
no longer a cheating wife or husband, but entries such as "How to
Control Sexually Active Teen". I hope that you are a born Muslim,
brought up in a Muslim country, reading this so that you are with me at
the same emotional level. From now on I will assume you are a born
Muslim, brought up in a Muslim country.(Please, if you are not, ask
someone who is to read my comment; I need someone who has the average
psychology of Muslims today, and psychology is affected mostly by your
upbringing, not just your religion. Take no offense please.) If you read
"How
to Control Sexually Active Teen", you will see why
this is so wrong at so many levels. Despite the state of Islam today, we
are still very conservative cultures in our Muslim countries. As a born
Muslim brought up in a Muslim country, you know that the glimpse of a
bad rumor involving sex could completely destroy a Muslim woman. As an
Arab you know exactly what I am talking about. You are probably already
boiling just thinking a rumor appears about your daughter, or any of
your women. I am trying to point out our conservative nature. "We
think she has had somewhere between 19 and 24 boyfriends in the last 2
years. We know that she has been sexually active with at least 7 guys.
" , from ( How to Control Sexually Active Teen )
As
a born Muslim brought up in a Muslim country you already see the problem
with this. If a Muslim just hears a glimpse of a rumor about one man
going into his daughter, Hell will break lose. You know exactly what I
am talking about. There is no way a Muslim could make such comments.
Remember I am not speaking to your mind, but to your emotions, your
psychology, which is that of an average Muslim. We Muslims, even the bad
amongst us, have such extreme jealousy for our self respect (this is due
to our conservative brought up, which is due to our religion) that
something like this cannot be imagined written by a Muslim. It is not
"glimpse of a rumor", but "know"; it is not
"one man", but "7 guys". And "we know" may
imply that other too know, erg, the teachers. The teachers, westerns or
not, a Muslim does not risk his reputation Again, this is due to our
psychology which is due to our conservative brought up, which is due to
our religion, hence why I want a born Muslim brought up in a Muslim
country to read my comment. The other reason why I want such a person
reading my comment is because such a person has a general idea of the
state of Muslims in the Muslim world. Such a person would be much more
insulted than any other when a non-Muslim western says "Muslims are
sex maniacs". This is because where most people know that western
have tens of sexual partners during their lives, this person also knows
that Muslim have one sexual partner on average during their lives; this
person also 'felt' the conservative nature of the Muslims; he would most
be insulted when associating sex with Muslims in such manner. Remember
recent convert have not 'felt' this conservative environment. (This
point is very important.)
With
the knowledge that "one man" went into one's daughter, a
Muslim would go berserk. You know exactly what I mean. Please note that
the above quote, from ( How to Control Sexually Active Teen ), is
written at the very beginning of this entry's question. I ask YOU, would
you be so quick in writing such information if you were faced with such
a problem!!!? A Muslim 'would beat around the bush' at the beginning and
slowly tell the dirty part. (psychologically speaking the person is
trying to delay his confession of what he sees is bad. This happens all
the time in our everyday life. Whether you are confessing something bad,
embarrassing, or damaging to your reputation, you do that.) Even when
you begin telling the dirty part, you are NOT going to give numbers.
(psychologically speaking, this is another
'defensive mechanism' that a person uses in such circumstances; you use
the least 'bad sounding' way of confessing something bad. For example,
instead of saying "Dad, I stole something", a person would say
"Dad, I talk something that does not belong to me"). You would
NOT use numbers in a situation like this; this is making the problem
sound bad to it's fullestextinct. A Muslim would be boiling and shaking
when writing something like this; he is not going to be so sharply
honest; you know exactly what I mean. "One time we found her in our
home giving oral sex to a young man. ", from (How to Control
Sexually Active Teen ) I am not even going to comment here. Something
like this happening to a Muslim parent could easily end up murdering
murder. I am trying to point out the extreme lack of jealousy for ones
honor this person, who wrote the above comment, has! This entry is a
fake entry.
This
is making use of the generalizing concept, which viewers have, to
inflict damage on Islam. Something like this gets the people to say
"Look, they have that too". The first two gays they wrote
about in the media getting married, in Canada, one of them had his
second name as Ali. From all the people they have, they picked one whose
second name is `Ali! I have discussed this entry in your website with a
female mahram, and she said the same things; they are trying to
damage our reputation. At first, mahram blanket out. The next
thing she said is the website is not Muslim. I had to tell her much
about your website before she was convinced it is in fact made by
Muslims. You cannot deny that you do not know the identity of the ones
who make these entries. I am begging you, brother, take such entries
out. I beg you from all my heart to take such entries out. Help us win
this war, brother. If you wish to take the people who make such entries
by good will, by all means help them, but privately; help these people
privately; perhaps my email. Do not post the entries publicly. This
entry is, without any doubt, fake. I am begging you take it out. I am
begging you with your Muslim blood that is thick with the essence of
self respect to take out such entries. I am begging you with the Muslim
blood that its heat would melt mountains if faced by such tragedy. I am
asking you by the name of Allah to do so. One final note: In the entry Masturbation
or Premarital Sex: Which Is Worse? The answer is very
simple. You are comparing a dust particle to MOUNTAINS. The answer is
premarital sex of course. My concern is that nowhere was this made clear
in the two responses. The questioner must know this first, then tell him
that you should not choose between two evils. Remember the punishment
for premarital sex goes as far Stoning, while masturbation is still
under debate whether it is haram or not to even consider a
punishment for it. Zina is explicitly forbidden in the Qur`an. I
am very surprised that there are Muslims ignorant enough to ask such
questions; perhaps the questioner is a recent convert. Please always
make such responses quick and clear. A sentence at the beginning of the
response such as "You are comparing a dust particle to
MOUNTAINS." is much more effective to put the person right in the
picture. I also ask you to be harsh sometimes in your responses. If you
show easiness when dealing with big problems you will make the person
belittle the problem. Remember, you are not going to have tens of
counseling session with these people, you will probably only get one
chance to speak to them. When you are expecting to spend tens of
counseling sessions with a person, then yes, going easy is THE proper
approach. This is a one time thing; get straight to the point; When you
need to be harsh, be harsh.
As
salamu `alaykum.
July
25th 2005
You
may want to visit the Healing Arts for Tsunami Survivors program of the
International Child Art Foundation (www.icaf.org
) and include reference to it in the informative article you wrote What
Future for Muslim Orphans? for Islam-online.
Sincerely,
Ashfaq Ishaq, PhD www.icaf.org
July
18 2005
Subject
Comment on the article: Misyar
Marriages
Jazakum
Allahu khayrun for the article.
It's
a good one. One major issue though. The mentioned verse (2:235) was
quoted out of Yusuf `Ali's translation. Based on the words of the
translation, the author of the article thought that the verse was
talking about certain honorable terms and she took these terms to mean
the terms of marriage. This is a typical example of how using the
translation can confuse the meaning. The phrase in Arabic does not talk
about any terms. It says: "illa an taqoulou qawlan ma'roufan".
It talks about the "talk" or the "saying". Basically
talk in an honorable and dignified manner, not in secret, when you want
to show your intent to marry a woman in `idda. The translator
uses the word "terms" with the intent to describe the speech.
However, this word can easily be misunderstood as we can see here. I'd
appreciate if you can convey this message to the author. It was a great
article, nonetheless.
-Seif
Re:
Father
Encourages Teenage Daughter's Sexuality-contribution 1
As-salamu
`alaykum.
First
of all you do a good job providing a resource for all of us who are
troubled at times of our lives and for this I thank you. The reason I
write is because I feel the question posed above was inappropriate to
have gone into such detail on Islam on line - I understand that people
can be anxious about such things but it would be better if this was
discussed in a private forum. As a mother of growing children I look for
you for support and I encourage my eldest daughter to use you as a
resource - and frankly I was aghast when I realized she was exposed to
the above problem. I should also like to add that I feel that Islam
Online should take care that you are not being abused. Please consider
my opinion and may Allah forgive me if I am misguided in writing to you.
Um
Yousuf
May
20th 2005.
As-salamu
`alaykum.
Here
is something I would like to share on Pursued
Me Before and Abused Me After.
Dear
sister
First
of all I would like to say sorry and making du`aa for you to get out of
this situation as soon as possible. It was a wonderful reply from
Brother Abdullah Abdur Rahman. I am sure you are not alone anymore. You
know we can feel we are alone, but in reality we are not.. Our
Creator is always with us. I want to add a few things here that
might help you or others.
Personally
I feel you are too good with him. I am sure you love him blindly, but
unfortunately he is not the person to be loved. Please don’t be loved
with him blindly anymore. It is time for you to stand up for your rights
and future. Let him know that you are not alone in this world and
without his mercy you can survive. I am sure you too know too much of
anything is wrong and you have done that.
Please
share all this with your parents and you are lucky to have such a
wonderful parents. Please forget about culture and tradition. This is
why Islam always advocates parent’s involvement in marriage because
they are the most important person of our life. Please involve them in
your future actions. Furthermore, I believe your incident can be an eye
opener for many of others those who support blindly love marriage.
Please
make lots of du`aa to Almighty who always observe us and don’t waste
your time for a person who is not grateful at all…. Life is not what
is happening with you…. I am sure golden future is very close to you,
which will be blessed by Almighty Allah….
Take
care and Allah Hafiz
Your
Brother in Islam
Zahid
05-12-05
As-salamu
`alaykum.
May
Allah reward you for your great efforts. there was a posting on the
cyber counselor A
Broken Trust, after reading it, I was so drawn to this person,
and her situation, since it is exactly like mine. I was wondering if you
could ask this woman if I would be able to write to her, or if she would
like to write to me. I think with support `in sha'allah we can help one
another and `in sha'allah help come close to Allah (swt), and pray for
both of us to be able to fix our families. `In sha'allah you will be
able to help me. My heart goes out to this woman, because I know what
she is going through. Subhanallah, she even mentioned she has 2
children, and they are the same age as my son. Please ask her if i can
write to her, or if she would like to write to me, my e-mail is ***
(contact through Society@iolteam.com)
Jazaka
Allahu Khayran
May
Allah reward you.
Wife
May
2nd 2005
Waste
Not Want Not.

(Download
the Text)
As-salamu `alaykum.
First
of my congratulations for your job well done on this Website, you have
made available through this Website a lot knowledge and news for
everybody. I personally have benefited a lot from this Website, thank
you for a job well done.
My
intention for this mail is I really liked 'Waste Not Want Not'.where the
presentation has a story of a king. I have two boys one is 6 and the
other is two, I think this story is great to share it with my 6 year
old, I know I can tell him this story, but if only I had a downloadable
version or a printer version of this story I can then print it and use
it like a book for him and read it with him, he loves books and I always
buy him lots of books. Is it possible to get a printer
version/downloadable version of this story, please let me know. Thank
you.
Shabana
April
14th 2005
As-salamu
`alaykum
May
Allah reward you for your great efforts. On April
26, 2005, there was
a posting on the cyber counselor,
A
Broken Trust ,
after reading it, I was so drawn to this person, and her situation,
since it is exactly like mine. I was wondering if you could ask this
woman if I would be able to write to her, or if she would like to write
to me. I think with support `in sha'allah we can help one another
and `in sha'allah help come close to Allah (swt), and pray for
both of us to be able to fix our families. `In sha'allah you will
be able to help me, my heart goes out to this woman, because I know what
she is going through. Subhanallah, even she mentioned she has 2
children, and they are the same age as my son. Please ask her if I can
write to her, or if she would like to write to me
Jazakum
Allahu Khairan
May Allah reward you.
Asalamu
Alaykum
As-salamu
`alaykum.
I am a
Interior Architect and am in the process of designing a building for
people suffering from depression by creating a "Time Out"
environment. Please could you send me any information to the following
address which you think may be useful via society@iolteam.com.
Andrea
April 20th – Hampshire, U.K.
As-salamu `alaykum.
I
would like to make a comment concerning the advice which you gave to
"concerned sister Iman" from the United States - Brother
Will Not Give Up His Girlfriend. Being in
Canada myself, from a non-Muslim Canadian mother and an Arab father,
having studied in the public school system and knowing the western
culture and mentality, I think that your way of handling the issue of
the young man and his girlfriend and the advice that you gave are
incomplete to say the least. I ask you to pardon me for being so blunt
but it seems to me that if you keep pushing what the boy is doing is
wrong. You are in fact encouraging him to keep on doing more of the same
and he will eventually do worst in defiance of your authority.
You
need to understand that modern western culture teaches in school and in
the society at large to rebel against and question authority models.
Push for independence at any cost (right or wrong) is a cultural trait
of the West that is very strong since the French and American
revolutions and has become prevalent since the cultural revolution of
the sixties. If the boys parents keep telling him that he is in the
devils path and so on, this will only push the boy to rebel some more.
You need to preach by example by keep on praying and doing good but
never mention the girlfriend. He needs to understand that you don't
really like it, but that you tolerate it and understand it.
I
know this might seem preposterous to you and it is very likely that I'm
wasting my time writing this letter, but I think that he could be doing
far worst then having a girlfriend. I know very well that this kind of
relationship is haram, but in the context of American society if
the boys mind is made up about the issue it will be practically
impossible to change his ways and the more you tell him "no"
the more his mind will say "yes". So let him have his
experiences even tough it might seem horrific and put your trust in
Allah All-Mighty that he will come back once he understands by himself
why the libertarian western lifestyle is flawed and very limited,
bringing only false freedom.
So
many parents who were so strict with their kids have just contributed to
the young ones rebellion by being completely intolerant of their
choices. I personally know families who fell apart because the parents
were so strict. Being too strict only pushes the children to rebel.
Raising children in a western society has to be more than just yelling
and saying no. That's the trouble, you cant just be strict and except
the children to obey : It doesn't work like that in the west. Being
completely careless like so many western parents doesn't work either.
Many brothers and sisters have done so much worst than having a
girlfriend or a boyfriend and came back to the straight path wiser,
smarter and with a firmer and more enlightened faith. If you tolerate
the girlfriend by closing your eyes on the issue but keep on talking
about deen, eventually (not now but once the teenage crisis is over) the
boy will come back to religion, `in sha'Allah,
I
am very certain of this. I have seen this type of behavior tens and tens
of time. I write you because I'm very concerned that your advice which
is given in good faith and with the purpose to please Allah and help the
boy and his family will only worsen the situation. please accept my
apologies, and for the Love and Mercy of Allah, pass my comment to
"concerned sister Iman"s family.
`Ali
– U.S.
As-salamu
`alaykum
This
is in reply to advice given to a brother Mohammed in the UK, entitled
'beyond caste', I believe I may have some advice to help him, and have
replied to the advice given by Ms. Layla Asamarai, which I hope can be
passed on to him****************** Reply to Beyond
Caste
Salaam,
I have been reading the replies to people’s
problems on this Website
for some time and I have found the advice in many cases very helpful to
me. However this is the first time that I have come across a problem so
similar to my own yet with such a misinformed analysis of it. With all
my respect for Ms Asamarai, I have read her replies many times before
and have found her advice so good that I have on occasion forwarded it
onto my friends. However in this case I believe you may have erred. It
seems to me that the lady in question was insecure, due to her family's
expectations of her future husband, and of the behavior of the man she
was in love with. This caused her to act irrationally, and to cause her
extreme fear.
Allow
me to explain, she would not take a chance on someone who her family
would potentially reject due to cultural reasons unless she had very
true and very deep feelings towards this man. She would not have
mentioned marriage to him unless she was religious, she would either
enjoy the courtship, or let him do all the running, only a woman who
believes in the teachings of Allah and his prophet and knows of the
qualities Islam respects in women, would be strong enough to mention
marriage to a man. Mohammed says that she changed once he said they
should discuss matters with their families, my question is, did he act
on this? Was he prompt in his action? Maybe she was faster in discussing
him with her family then he was, and when their family knew of him, and
expected to hear from him, they felt he delayed? Thus putting pressure
on the woman and causing her to question his commitment to her? This
would explain her accusations that he did not call often enough, asking
where he is, these are the signs of someone who is insecure in her
relationship. It also tells of low self-esteem, this is supported by her
statement that lots of men are interested in her, she was convincing
herself more than him. His discussion of ultimatums did not help either,
‘either we end it or marry’, to a woman who is in love yet insecure
this translates as ‘lets get married now, otherwise I can easily find
someone else’. Maybe she was testing to see his commitment and respect
for her, avoiding contact to give him the message ‘if you want me,
come to my family and ask for me’. I am not saying that he should be
able to decipher this, she must quite naďve and un-worldly. She reads
to me like a lady severely hurt, and unable to behave in the manner she
usually behaves in. Her love and desire for him eventually conquer her
‘test’ and she contacts him again, she wanted him to contact her
though, and when she asks for a meeting and he refuses (okay he has
reasons, but what are appointments where love is concerned she thinks),
she totally loses it. She sees that he is not committed and does not
love her, she starts going on about material issues, which she never
mentioned before? She is convincing herself that he is no good for her,
because she needs some vent for the hurt she is feelings. She is also
scared of making the wrong choice. She is thinking that because he has
done XYZ he does not care, she may not recall the good times, hurt
caused by the one you love is unparallel to any, and she starts ranting.
She is clearly an insecure, low-self esteemed lady who loves Mohammed
very much, like every woman she wants to be her loves number one, to be
his queen to be cherished by him, and in turn to be herself with him, to
not feel fear when she expresses her love for him. Maybe Mohammed should
re-consider, maybe he should speak with his family about her, and get in
touch formally proposing, be brave even if they say no, he knows he did
his best. He would have done something highly respectable. Remember she
called him after 3 months, for a woman to do this is THE HARDEST THING.
I strongly believe she is of low self esteem and that she felt insecure,
and yes he is partly to blame. His next action should be to consider
what he wants, does he still love her? Then act on it. The reason I feel
strongly about this is because a similar thing happened to me, and I was
the crazy girl in the story. I just felt he needs to know this, and hope
my hideous experience may give some hope/help to a fellow human being.
Regards, Layla
`Ali
– U.S.
March
15th 2005
As-salamu
`alaykum
I
just wanted to forward my opinions on a question in your counseling
section titled Two
Months of Confusion. What I want to say to this sister is
that I am married to a person who isn't very religious, goes to clubs
and has led a very un-Islamic life style.
Although
my marriage was arranged, each day I live torn between my affection for
him and the hurt caused to me by his unreligious behavior. He is a very
nice man in every other way and has an amazing human interaction. It's
only his religion which falters. What I want to say to you is that at
this point you can see yourself as making a difference in his life or
helping him, but the more involved you will get in this the more hurt
you will be by his irreligious actions. As for guidance the only one who
can give him guidance is Allah almighty so just pray for his guidance
and do not try to form any sort of relations with him.
May
Allah help Us and Guide Us All.
Anonymous
Feb
17th 2005
Dear
Brothers as salamu `alaykum wa rahmatu Allah
IOL
is the only web site I visit on daily basis for all my knowledge needs
and I am very fond of the site and all the Fatwas and content I read. I
hear a lot from IOL, may Allah help you keep it strong to spread the
knowledge of Allah SWT.
Today
I clicked on the Family link and click on this Audio link Raising
Positive Children: The Seventh Day - Male Circumcision and
came across the description of circumcision. It explains what is it for
the boys, but to my surprise you also mention the circumcision for
girls. To be truthful, I am so confused right now. I have been raised to
know that female circumcision is not Islamic and it is not in the Sunnah
of the Prophet (PBUH), If I am right, IOL is promoting female
circumcision by listing it on this page. Please put my mind at peace and
remove it from that page.
Wa
`alaykum as-salamu wa ahmatullahi wa Barakatuh
Jan
16th 2005
Mohsen
As
salamu `alaykum.
I
had a comment on the advice given by respected counselor for the sender
of the question Committed
By Me or Shaytan? . The sender said years ago. he has had a
problem hearing or feeling bad words about religion going on his mind
during prayers. I had the same problem too a few years ago. I asked some
religious people and they gave me the same answer given by the respected
counselor. When things didn't get better I sought therapy. I was
diagnosed for Obsessive Compulsive Disorder known as (wawas kahry)
and one of its symptoms was the as same described by the sender. Since I
knew that it wasn't me saying those bad words in mind, I started taking
medicines and praying harder till I overcame this problem by the help of
God. So I wanted to tell the sender that if it wasn't bad thoughts by
shaytan and they went away or if they are getting more difficult he
should consult a therapist because this is a very difficult illness.
May
Allah help you all and bless you. Please publish this so it may help
other readers and the one who sent the question.
As
salamu `alaykum and thanks lot for helping people your site is
great.
Yusra,
Egypt
Feb
05th 2005
I love Islamonline.net, it is my Home Page and I am addicted to it
because it is full of knowledge. Islam Online made it possible for me to
learn more about Islam and life. I read the news, the fatwas, and
the people's problems and solutions given to them by your great
counselors (Cyber Counselor)and I learn so many things in life. I hope
you keep all of the questions and answers posted because they will help
so many people solve similar problems `insha'allah. Having read
your counselors' answers to the questions made it possible for me to
advice people the same way. I think I am a counselor now. May the peace
of Allah be upon you all. I pray Allah that Islam Online grows and
exists forever because it helps change our lives for the better.
As
salamu alaykum
I
strongly object to the poor advice given by Asuman Martone to a woman
with an adulterous husband in His
Adulterous Nature. I highly doubt that he (she?) would have recommended the same for his
own daughter. How dare he ask the wife to look for her role in the
husband's haram activities. SHE is not the zinnia. Adultery is a
capital crime in Islam and there is NO excuse for it, especially for a
married man whose wife is waiting for him at home. This woman should be
advised to get checked for STDs and stay far away from her partner until
he reforms or she divorces him. His statements that he wants to marry
another while abusing the rights of his only wife is telling. He has no
qualms about breaking the law, no feelings for his wife and no qualms
about engaging in major sin. We need to support women who are the
victims of such men and not in any way blame them for being abused.
Brenda
01-06-05
Answer

As
Salamu Alaikum Wrt. Wbt.
Thanks
sister Layla A. Asamarai for her excellent and emotional reply. I would
like to add some rational point if view. My dear little sister my heart
cries for you. I am sure many heart will cry for you and hundreds of
heart cried like you many years except the so-called human being those
who are worst than an animal (I am sorry!!). I cannot find a word to say
something to such a person that has done such a bad thing with someone
can consider as his daughter. What a shame? And he is moving around and
even never says sorry. Anyway it will not change the situation if he
says sorry. You are killing yourself and unfortunately you are alone. I
want to stress that are you deserve to be killing yourself. I am sure
you are not!! Than why should you kill yourself?
Islam
always teaches us to stand against injustice. Unfortunately, we are
always silent when it comes to injustice like this. We always value our
tradition and culture and for that we believe we should not talk about
this issue with close one like parents. But silent cry is now the
dangerous disease in our society. This is the time for us to stand
together and voice out about this issue. Please don’t keep silent try
to talk to your parents. You need them with you to reduce the pain.
Please don’t forget they are your greatest shelter in this world.
We
should not forget if we don’t create social awareness or identify this
type of human animal. This human animal will do more harm in our
society. Please my sister breaks the tradition and stand for yourself
and many others. Please don’t forget Allah (swt) will help us if we
want to help ourselves. Please move forward with your life and work for
your golden future. Allah (swt) put you in a huge test and inshallah you
will overcome it. A BELIEVER IS ALWAYS A
WINNER!!
Finally,
please make lot of Dua to Allah (swt). And we all hope for your golden
future and Allah (swt) will give you the power to over come this
situation. Allah (swt) blesses you always in your way.
Wa
Salamu `alaykum
Your
brother with lots best wishes
Md.
Zahidul Islam
26 December 2004
As
salamu `alaykum dear brother.
Jazaha
llah khayr Sister Hwaa had an amazing response (see Living
a Useless Life ). I just wanted to it.
-
First,
al hamdu Lillah that you had the manners not to get involved with
this girl before marriage. Think of the consequences that
might have arose then.
-
Second,
al hamdu Lillah that you were able to find a decent job.
-
Third,
al hamdu lillah that you are recovering from your illness. All
these are signs of Allah's bounties and his protection (SWT).
As we are told by the Prophet (PBUH) that the affairs of a Muslim is
such that when he is given bounties he says al hamdu lillah and when
he is hit with a calamity he also says al hamdu lillah.
This
is directly related to another Islamic concept: Not to hate
anything because it might actually be good for us. No creature
knows where his wealth or bounties lie. It is by Allah's Grace
that we actually get these things. I just wanted to point out
these things in the hope of getting you thinking about them in order to
help you get over this `in sha’Allah. God knows best.
As
salamu ` alaykum.
--Mohammad
As
salamu Alaikum Wrt. Wbt.
My
dear sister, I just want to add some more points regarding to your
situation. I believe that your situation is not very uncommon in our
subcontinent. We are so respectful to our culture sometime even we
violate the basic rules and regulation of Islam. Honestly you are the
victim of our tradition. I hope many of us will get lesson for your
incident.
Al
hamdu lillah you are successful
in your life and following the way of Islam. From your letter it
indicates that you were not even agreed for your first marriage and
tried your best to make that marriage a successful one. I am sure Allah
knows better what you have done and you will be rewarded for that `in
sha’Allah. But for the second marriage did you pray to Allah (swt)
before making the decision to marry him? Please make sure in future when
you make a decision first pray Istikhara prayer for guidance from Allah
(swt)
My
dear sister we all hope for better tomorrow and `in sha’Allah
you will be blessed by the Allah (swt). We should not forget that this
world a difficult place for the believer. Please be patience and move
with your life. I suspect you are thinking a lot with your current
situation and it is not unusual. But if we only think about ‘A’
always then we will not able to know about ‘B – Z’. Please explore
yourself in different avenue you may think to join Muslim woman group
and spend some time with them for Dawah, which will give you opportunity
to know many people and spending a quality time too. Another think I
want to add as you are blessed with wealth why don’t you extent your
helping hands to Muslim children for their education and so on.
Last
but not least, please don’t forget Allah (swt) is the best provider.
Try to make more du’aa to Him. Please read Qur`an more, give
charity and believe that Allah (swt) will blessed you here and in the
Hereafter.
Allah
hafiz
Your
Brother
Md.
Zahidul Islam
|
|
|
Archives |
|
|
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
 |