Home| World in Crisis

Your Mail 

 
 Search 
Advanced Search

   

Afghanistan & Beyond

Views & Analyses

Against the War

America & the World

Democracy & Civil Rights

Islam vs. West?

Muslim World

Live Dialogues

Discussion Forum

Book Reviews

Day by Day

Fatwa

Coloured Lights

By Leila Aboulela

Publisher: Polygon, 2001
ISBN 0 7486 6298 7
Reviewed by Joanne McEwan

23/12/2001

Many successful novelists have their trial runs in fiction by writing short stories, and it is often only after notoriety that they draw enough interest to publish their works. This collection of short stories, Coloured Lights, is only Leila Aboulela’s second set of published works. It is quite an impressive achievement for a newcomer - not to mention the fact that she won the “African Booker” - the Caine Prize for African Writing, for one of these short stories, The Museum. Her first novel, The Translator, received wide critical acclaim.

The stories in Coloured Lights reflect the complexities of Muslim immigrant life in a foreign and alien society. In some ways this anthology takes us steps further than The Translator in portraying life in Sudan and life for the foreigner in Britain. The writer also shows an understanding of the Scottish people who feature as some of the main characters in her stories. The last two stories, however, have a more mystical theme, with one of them, Days Rotate, being probably the first Muslim, science fiction story published in English.

But what is probably exceptional about this collection is the writer’s truthfulness and intrepidity in speaking frankly about the downside of many Muslims, and she does so without moralizing. Alcoholism, discrimination, materialism, “marrying for the visa,” and plain lack of faith are some of the faults affecting the characters. In contrast, there are many strong and positive figures.

The Ostrich is a moving story set in London and Khartoum. The protagonist, Sumra, is a Sudanese woman who returns to her husband, Majdy, in London after a two-month break in Sudan. Dressed in traditional Sudanese attire, she faces her husband’s censure upon arrival - with Majdy saying things like, “You look like something from the Third World.” Almost instantly she plunges into the diffidence associated with her life as a foreigner: a woman who is lonely, bored, and living in the shadow of a studious, self-centered husband. He often grotesquely belittles her for not assimilating Western ideals. Sumra surmises his thoughts and intentions, which often lead to phrases like, “They can forgive you for your ugly color, your thick lips and rough hair, but you must think modern thoughts, be like them in the inside if you can’t be from the outside.”

Despite the verbal and physical abuse, Sumra is intact as far as her identity is concerned. It is Majdy who is confused and lacking in confidence. He praises a country that is more advanced than Sudan, yet he suffers from racism: both hidden and blatant.

But Sumra has her own thoughts and her own secrets. Throughout the initial days of her return, she reminisces over her past and the choices she made; her thoughts turning towards an old colleague. She calls him the “Ostrich” because of the similitude of his gait to the bird. She recalls his crude manners and hilarious wit, his pathetic handicap and sharp intelligence. But it is the harshness she once displayed towards him - a misfit in his own country - that strikes a cord within her. She recoils from those memories of the past with regret and reflects upon her present situation – recognizing the subtle irony.

Aboulela entwines many forms of discrimination, psychological unrest and levels of faith into the few pages of the short stories. The Ostrich is a moving story of being “out of place” both at home and abroad. On the one hand, being black in the Britain and being handicapped in Sudan are the obvious physical differences that unfold in discrimination. On the other hand, having attitudes that are irreconcilable between Western and Eastern cultures, and the physically handicapped struggling for intellectual recognition are the more intangible differences. There is, however, a touching and poignant episode of a congregational prayer, which depicts a harmony between all people – be they rich or poor, young or old, educated or illiterate.

The prize-winning story, The Museum, is set in Aberdeen. Intent on completing her degree as a ticket for marriage, the key character, Shadia, leaves behind Sudan, her family, and her rich, upper-middle class fiancé. She is one of many foreign students struggling with their studies. She battles the biting cold, unfamiliarity, loneliness, and a language that she thought she had mastered until she hears the local dialect of North East Scotland. Scottish student Bryan - decked out with an earring and a ponytail – passed with distinction the previous year, and his help seems to be the only thing that will keep her from failing her exams.

But Shadia has a problem asking help of someone she considers an oddity; convincing herself that she is probably more distinguished than he is. Humbled, but intensely humiliated, she asks if she can borrow his notes and he obliges indifferently. Shadia is caught by surprise in the next lecture when he asks her to go for a coffee and later to meet at the museum. But Bryan does not seem to be the person she first envisaged. He is serious, polite, and most of all looking for “ the truth.” Shadia misses out on the opportunity to help enlighten Bryan, as she is guilty and confused by her own devious actions.

Aboulela raises the aspect of misconceptions in this story, which is one of the main stumbling blocks in cultural and racial harmony. Instead of the obvious paradigm, where the overseas student is at the receiving end of discrimination (although this kind of racism is present in the story), there is a focus on the foreigner who has preconceived notions of his/her hosts. This is further explored when Shadia actually believes that any man who can “look like a woman” must be weird. She assumes that Bryan will be adverse to Islam but finds out that he longs to understand it and is willing to change. She slowly realizes that she understands so little about Islam herself, and is too weak to help him.

“If she was strong she would have explained and not tired of explaining. She would have patiently taught him another language, letters curved like the epsilon and the gamma he knew from mathematics. She would have shown him that words could be read from left to right. If she was not small in the museum, if she was really strong, she would have made his trip to Mecca real, not only in a book.”

One wonders how many times non-Muslims have asked to know more about Islam and been faced with blank stares or complementary platitudes? Aboulela is brave enough to show that even a “born-Muslim” can be a spiritual vacuum, unable to respond his/her own mind and soul, never mind those of others.’

Coloured Lights is superb collection in gentle and moving prose. It is a pity that our acquaintance with each character is so brief. One wants each story to go on and on. This book is a comfort to converts and Muslims living in the West. It is certainly an incentive for any aspiring Muslim novelist

 

 

News

Views & Analyses

Qur'an

Hadith & Sunnah

Discover Islam

New to Islam

Live Dialogue

Live Fatwa

Discussion Forum

Contemporary Issues


FEEDBACK  | CONTACT US  | GUEST BOOK  | SITE MAP


Best viewed by:
MS Internet Explorer 4.0
and above.

Copyright © 2000 Islam Online
Al rights reserved

Disclaimer

Developed and Managed by
IslamOnline